Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1] 2   Go Down

Author Topic: Which melodeon?  (Read 8052 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

OldJack

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 76
    • Suisun Sailor
Which melodeon?
« on: April 01, 2012, 09:11:52 PM »

I've been working a one row C, 4 stops that I like (aside from some needed adjustments/repairs) but miss the accidentals on my Anglo concertina (need more practice). So, I've been searching this net for clues about what to do/buy next. I don't understand the reason for different tunings such as C/G, C/D, etc. unless it is a cultural preference. Since my own sparse musical background is in the U.S. I haven't a particular culture style as a favorite and like just a bit of everything. So, a C/C# seems like a reasonable next step except they appear to be out of favor and unavailable. The B/C looks like an answer except the sharps are in row two while the sharps on my concertina are in row 1. Where the advantages in all these different key arrangements may lie completely escapes me. Just to add a little salt, I really like the four stops because I can change the register and add or blank out the high. My concertina's upper register is just to high for my old ears so the lower register of the melodeon sounds wonderful to me. Also, for my tastes I sometimes like only the single reed, or two. On the other hand, some four reed shanties really work for me.

Any comments, suggestions or advice will certainly be helpful. I'm only eight hours away to the west and look forward to all responses.

Jack :-\
Logged

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: Which melodeon?
« Reply #1 on: April 02, 2012, 10:41:35 AM »

Welcome to the forum, Jack.

I understand the dilemma and the confusion induced by the plethora of systems since I faced it myself a few years ago when contemplating taking up the box.

I don't play concertina but I'd advise you not to reject any solution because it does things the other way around from your Anglo (position of accidental row, etc.), and not to have a custom system built to resemble some aspects of the Anglo layout. Go with a standard choice and learn it. Lots of great players master both Anglo and DBA/melodeon.

The usual advice is to base your choice on the type of music you want to play. For example, if you like English music, choose some permutation of a D/G (possibly a 2½ row to give you a ½-row of accidentals), or choose a G/C system if you like French music, and a semitone system (B/C or C#/D) if you like Irish or Scottish music.

While you can to some extent play any of these types of music on any system, the advantages of going with the standard are that a) you immediately cut down the confusion factor  (:) and b) any tuition or help you can get from other players will address issues in the type of music you want to play. In other words, if you choose G/C + accidentals for playing Irish music (for example), there aren't many people out there able to help you with making that music fit on that box. Likewise if you want to play French music and choose B/C.

Why not seek out players of various systems in your neck of the woods, get together with them, talk about the options, get them to show you what they do, and so on?

PS If you like the 4-stop sound and choose a box with two or more rows, you're looking at something pretty heavy. Perhaps one of the extended one-row systems being made here in Québec would give you what you want. See here: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=1873.0
« Last Edit: April 02, 2012, 10:45:25 AM by Steve Jones »
Logged

Just4Fun

  • Guest
Re: Which melodeon?
« Reply #2 on: April 02, 2012, 11:08:01 AM »

Hi Jack,
Whilst I don't claim to be an expert I can certainly echo Steve's thoughts and also offer my experience and thought processes which might be of relevance since they're fairly recent.
Two and a half years ago I fell in love with a Battlefield band track and decided it was time to learn a squeezy thing! After slight deliberation and discussion with a local music shop I bought a B/C box as I obviously wanted to play Scottish and Irish music so a chromatic system was the way to go. BUT, within weeks the dust had settled and I realised that English was my preferred poison and that I had got the wrong box!
I duly traded in my B/C for a D/G and for a while struggled unlearning one fingering and relearning a new system. However, having finally worked out what it was that I wanted to play I've now reached an OKish standard and get a huge amount of pleasure out of it.
Inevitably I've done what most people do and acquired a few boxes along the way. I've now got a lovely old D/G (converted) 1930s Hohner Erika for sessions and a relatively new '70s Erica which I use when playing for a local clog side as it's beer and rain proof.
So the tuning I needed was down to the type of music I wanted to be involved in and then the make/model, number of rows etc. became a more a matter of personal taste rather than necessity. Good luck and enjoy the MAD!!!
Logged

OldJack

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 76
    • Suisun Sailor
Re: Which melodeon?
« Reply #3 on: April 02, 2012, 09:43:55 PM »

Thanks to both of you. I was beginning to suspect there is no universal key or arrangement of keys that would work unless it was something like a bc; but, you have shown me the light. I'm going to keep chugging along but will check out the new machine in Quebec. I must try to avoid MAD. I have a wife and a boat to support. I've kept your comments for my personnel reference. Thanks again.

Jack
Logged

Rob2Hook

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2278
  • Castagnaris, Hohners & Baffetti
Re: Which melodeon?
« Reply #4 on: April 02, 2012, 10:18:42 PM »

The choice of fingering systems and keys really only becomes critical if you are going to play with other box players.  In general though the semitone boxes are best suited to celtic music.  The tuning makes them all but chromatic with the disadvantage that the limited basses often prove unusable.  Quint tuned boxes are far more limited in the keys in which they can be played, but are well suited to folk dance tunes as the simple basses really make them a percussion instrument and the pushing and pulling imposes a bouncy playing style.  With most players this bounciness is lost with a piano acordion, although there are notable exceptions.

As already mentioned it can help to be playing the same tuning as anyone with whom you are playing and the European convention is D/G for English, G/C for French and C/F for most others.  On the celtic scene, I believe there are shifts every decade to various tunings, B/C, C/C#, C#/D, etc.  I'm not into that sort of thing, being basically a D/G player myself, but they can all play together once the scales have been learnt.  I think the norm for TexMex and Conjunto is  a three row G/C/F.

Quite a few of my friends play both D/G and anglo.  It isn't too confusing as although the patterns are broadly speaking reversed, the awareness of which row will yield the right note is still there.  One good friend always played his 4-stop in the upper register as he said it was much more like the anglo.

Rob.
Logged

Andrel

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 246
Re: Which melodeon?
« Reply #5 on: April 03, 2012, 06:11:08 AM »

I agree with Steve on this one. I would keep the one-row in C and get a Bouchard in D with the half-row of accidentals. It would allow you to also play in G and A, and with working stops (important) you could turn the reeds on or off at will. Good luck.
Andre
Logged
Bertrand Gaillard D/C#, Acadian in C, Castagnari Ciacy
B/C, Castagnari Sharon D/C#

Quebecois

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1206
  • Accordez-vous donc, c'est si beau, l'accordéon!
Re: Which melodeon?
« Reply #6 on: April 03, 2012, 02:34:45 PM »

In general though the semitone boxes are best suited to celtic music.  The tuning makes them all but chromatic with the disadvantage that the limited basses often prove unusable.  
I tend to disagree! The "modern" Hohner layout works fine on a B/C with the most common keys (D, G, A) and of course C. You can even do some F and E. On my box I changed the E chord for a E minor. Unlike the fourth- (quint?) tuned boxes the basses are not "in accord" with the treble rows (the word "accordion" does not really apply to semitone boxes!) except for C and the 2 lower buttons of the outer bass row.  Hence,  you don't use basses in Irish music the same as English or other styles, you have to use "accents" of bass notes or chords where they can fit, instead of doing a continuous bass-chord or bass-chord-chord routine.

Also I believe that Tex-Mex and Conjunto mostly use Bb/Eb/Ab, shown as B-Es-As in German, and called "cinco letras", or five letters, in Spanish.
Logged
Hohner Morgane D/G, pre-Erica Hohner in C/F and G/C,
Hohner Erica A/D, Roland FR-18

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: Which melodeon?
« Reply #7 on: April 03, 2012, 03:16:09 PM »

I agree with Steve on this one. I would keep the one-row in C and get a Bouchard in D with the half-row of accidentals.

Except that I think the Sag'né design, with 5 extra pallets and 10 extra notes, is much more versatile than the Bouchard, which has only 2 extra pallets and 4 extra notes.

Agree with François about semitone-box basses. Not so much unusable as "differently usable."

Andrew Wigglesworth

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1101
  • 07
    • My website
Re: Which melodeon?
« Reply #8 on: April 03, 2012, 04:14:35 PM »

Heh, I think I'm going to be a bit more controversial in my answer :P

Simply describing B/C or C#/D boxes as chromatic always sets me on edge (not as much as the term "celtic music", but I'll leave that one for now). The intention of these boxes was not to play chromatically and it is certainly not the practical outcome.

There is no particular reason that the Irish tend to play "quint" boxes and the English tend to play D/G other than a modern ingrained habit. I can't see that one is truly more suited than the other in either case. Communities of musicians pick up and pass on habits and prejudices and if you want to learn inside these communities then following certain habits is often a good idea. I could give someone a start playing on a D/G box, I would have more trouble if they had a B/C. You're more likely to get detailed advice in how to play English music on a D/G box, but this does not mean that quint boxes are really unsuited or that D/G players do not play Irish material (or Scottish).

The biggest question is who you are playing with, what they play and the keys that they are playing in. If you're playing essentially on your own and are interested in the music of the British Isles generally then I think you'll get along fine on either a B/C, C#/D or D/G box. There's learning materials for each of these. Just make a choice and get on with it.

Who do you like listening to?

Afraid of making a mistake? Well, you'll only ever know if you try. Reading about it will only get you so far. Is there anyone who can lend you an instrument for a while? Some shops will loan an instrument and then take the fee off the purchase price. In any event, with a reasonable quality second-hand instrument you're not going to make much of a loss if you resell it a few months later. That's if you don't pay over the odds for it of course.

I'll let others talk of French and other style tunings ...

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: Which melodeon?
« Reply #9 on: April 03, 2012, 06:10:36 PM »

Andrew, I thought that that the term "quint" meant "fourth-apart" instruments (D/G, G/C) but you seem to be using the term to mean "semitone" boxes (C#/D, B/C).

Much of what you say in your 3rd paragraph echoes what I said in the 5th paragraph of my first answer. But I think there's more to the Irish choice of semitone boxes than a "modern ingrained habit". For starters, is it "modern"? There's a probably a direct line leading from Peter Wyper's invention of the B/C in about 1915 to Paddy O'Brien's getting one in 1935 and then his wowing the Irish-box world with his 1953 78rpm recordings. The style of play he developed and which was so influential is simply not possible on anything but a semitone box.

Please note I'm not saying great Irish music can't be played on a D/G. It can. (And I mean really great music by people whose primary or sole interest is Irish music.) Or English music on a B/C, no doubt, although I have no experience of that beyond hearing John Kirkpatrick years ago. But this doesn't negate the fact that Irish players, for reasons of style, would be unwilling to trade the advantages for their music of the B/C or C#/D for the different advantages of the D/G. Or that English players would abandon the D/G and what it can do in favour of the B/C. - Speaking as someone who seriously considered D/G before opting for C#/D.

PS if there are decent learning materials out there for C#/D, as you suggest, I haven't seen any.



Quebecois

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1206
  • Accordez-vous donc, c'est si beau, l'accordéon!
Re: Which melodeon?
« Reply #10 on: April 03, 2012, 06:48:55 PM »

(...) Paddy O'Brien's (...) The style of play he developed and which was so influential is simply not possible on anything but a semitone box.
Yep, it's all about the "sound" and dynamics of the B/C. Yet very many Irish tunes would be "easier" to play on a D/G... but just won't sound the same.
Logged
Hohner Morgane D/G, pre-Erica Hohner in C/F and G/C,
Hohner Erica A/D, Roland FR-18

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: Which melodeon?
« Reply #11 on: April 03, 2012, 07:14:25 PM »

Yet very many Irish tunes would be "easier" to play on a D/G...

But don't forget that lots of Irish tunes that are easy or feasible on B/C could not be played on an ordinary D/G, and only with difficulty on a D/G with a half-row of accidentals. Think of all those lovely fiddle reels in D minor (a snap on the B/C) and G minor (only slightly more difficult).

Andrew Wigglesworth

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1101
  • 07
    • My website
Re: Which melodeon?
« Reply #12 on: April 03, 2012, 07:56:11 PM »

Andrew, I thought that that the term "quint" meant "fourth-apart" instruments (D/G, G/C) but you seem to be using the term to mean "semitone" boxes (C#/D, B/C).

Oh sod, I knew I'd probably got that wrong when I typed it and meant to check ... I usually just call them button accordions and then say which type.

Andrew Wigglesworth

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1101
  • 07
    • My website
Re: Which melodeon?
« Reply #13 on: April 03, 2012, 08:17:39 PM »

Andrew, I thought that that the term "quint" meant "fourth-apart" instruments (D/G, G/C) but you seem to be using the term to mean "semitone" boxes (C#/D, B/C).

Much of what you say in your 3rd paragraph echoes what I said in the 5th paragraph of my first answer. But I think there's more to the Irish choice of semitone boxes than a "modern ingrained habit". For starters, is it "modern"? There's a probably a direct line leading from Peter Wyper's invention of the B/C in about 1915 to Paddy O'Brien's getting one in 1935 and then his wowing the Irish-box world with his 1953 78rpm recordings. The style of play he developed and which was so influential is simply not possible on anything but a semitone box.

Please note I'm not saying great Irish music can't be played on a D/G. It can. (And I mean really great music by people whose primary or sole interest is Irish music.) Or English music on a B/C, no doubt, although I have no experience of that beyond hearing John Kirkpatrick years ago. But this doesn't negate the fact that Irish players, for reasons of style, would be unwilling to trade the advantages for their music of the B/C or C#/D for the different advantages of the D/G. Or that English players would abandon the D/G and what it can do in favour of the B/C. - Speaking as someone who seriously considered D/G before opting for C#/D.

PS if there are decent learning materials out there for C#/D, as you suggest, I haven't seen any.

Now for the rest ...

I slipped in "modern" as an afterthought. Simply thinking a nebulous thought that all this hasn't really been around all that long in historical terms, and some of the decisions about tunings have been much more recent even than then invention of melodeons.

That's all.

I'm not advocating that anyone abandons anything, simply commenting upon the certitude of some statements about what box is supposed to always be played for whatever. For instance, we would all be talking about the greatness of C#/D for proper English music if that had been chosen back when.

I'm not making any great case for change, I probably won't ever personally, but for someone off in the US who doesn't seem to have a "folk community" around them or a particular attachment to a tradition, I am not going to say that buying a B/C box will shackle them to Irish (or Scottish) music and will severely inhibit their ability to enjoy playing English music.

C#/D learning material? Um, maybe I was a bit hasty on that   ::)  Are there any Jackie Daly videos?   (:)

oggiesnr

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 995
  • Dino BPII, Alfred Arnold Bandoneon, Loffet G/C
Re: Which melodeon?
« Reply #14 on: April 03, 2012, 11:26:37 PM »

Dave Mallinson plays irish music as well as anyone I've heard on a D/G box without any problem.  In fact a D/G box covers pretty well all the keys you're going to need for modern Irish music.

Steve
Logged

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: Which melodeon?
« Reply #15 on: April 04, 2012, 04:25:25 AM »

Dave Mallinson plays irish music as well as anyone I've heard on a D/G box without any problem.  In fact a D/G box covers pretty well all the keys you're going to need for modern Irish music.

Steve, does that mean, "as well as anyone I've heard, on a D/G box..." or "as well as anyone I've heard on a D/G box"?

As for covering all the keys "you're" going to need, I respectfully suggest that that depends on the "you." If you had said "I'm going to need" then nobody could take issue with you, but since you didn't, I will cheerfully disagree.

oggiesnr

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 995
  • Dino BPII, Alfred Arnold Bandoneon, Loffet G/C
Re: Which melodeon?
« Reply #16 on: April 04, 2012, 08:21:44 AM »

Dave Mallinson plays irish music as well as anyone I've heard on a D/G box without any problem.  In fact a D/G box covers pretty well all the keys you're going to need for modern Irish music.

Steve, does that mean, "as well as anyone I've heard, on a D/G box..." or "as well as anyone I've heard on a D/G box"?

As for covering all the keys "you're" going to need, I respectfully suggest that that depends on the "you." If you had said "I'm going to need" then nobody could take issue with you, but since you didn't, I will cheerfully disagree.


Pretty well as well as anyone on either system.

Certainly round here try playing in irish sessions outside of D/G/A and their related keys and you get net with "what the **** is that!".  But we'll have to agree to differ  (:)

Obviously if you're playing a different repertoire then key requirements will vary.

Steve
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Which melodeon?
« Reply #17 on: April 04, 2012, 08:28:05 AM »

 .. whereas last time I was in Galway they played several *F in tunes in F !

   could of been yet another way of keeping the English out, of course
* not including Kirkpatrick's palindromic polka


I could offer the joys of a C#/D/G system which suits me, loves blues scales!  It can give you quint/halftone fingering on one box.  But a 'french system' row (or ½ row) of non scale** notes is a very robust and well-tried workhorse.  The most useful buttons in actual play will be the reversals - allowing bits of scale to play without reversing the bellows.  A 12 bass is also very liberating - again having say an "A" on push .. opens up so many possibilities.

Keys? Well, that depends on what company you keep.  Hereabouts the session  keys (in rough order of frequency) run  G, Emdorian with C#, D, Emwith C nat, Amdorian with F#, Bmwith G nat, (C), (Amnat with F), (Dm) - that's why the D/G is the major box in England.

** These notes are never accidental!
« Last Edit: April 04, 2012, 08:52:31 AM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Quebecois

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1206
  • Accordez-vous donc, c'est si beau, l'accordéon!
Re: Which melodeon?
« Reply #18 on: April 04, 2012, 03:02:28 PM »

Dave Mallinson plays irish music as well as anyone I've heard on a D/G box without any problem.  In fact a D/G box covers pretty well all the keys you're going to need for modern Irish music.
Uhhh... as long as it's in D, G, Bm or Em! I guess one has to adapt the keys to play many of those Irish tunes on a D/G!  It's tough to play a Dm tune but if you make it Em it falls into the proper range. Same with tunes usually played in A. Not easy to render on a D/G...
« Last Edit: April 04, 2012, 04:49:51 PM by Québécois »
Logged
Hohner Morgane D/G, pre-Erica Hohner in C/F and G/C,
Hohner Erica A/D, Roland FR-18

waltzman

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 943
Re: Which melodeon?
« Reply #19 on: April 04, 2012, 03:16:16 PM »

The most useful buttons in actual play will be the reversals - allowing bits of scale to play without reversing the bellows.  A 12 bass is also very liberating - again having say an "A" on push .. opens up so many possibilities.

I very much agree with these bits of advice which apply to the very readily available ADG three row.  I'm still amazed that that system isn't more popular in the UK than it appears to be.
Logged
Pages: [1] 2   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal