Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Daddy Long Les on August 06, 2012, 10:51:44 AM
-
Hi,
I bought one of these the other day and was wondering if anyone on here has one like it?
It's certainly a fascinating little box. Having played it for a few days my main concern is that the bellows are very "sloppy". I've done all the usual tests for leaks and actually can't find any so maybe it's just the age of the box. It's got a few tuning problems and reed issues (only one firing instead of two) - all this I know can be fixed but I'm not so sure about the bellows - I seem to be spending a lot of my playing time closing them.
I'd only had it a few hours when the air button spring snapped but thanks to a suggestion from Lester, I was able to fix it with a safety pin. This has proved to be very effective so I don't think that the air is escaping from this source.
The bottom line is I love the sound - wet in a sweet and folky way but not too wet so ideal for what I want. Theo has certainly done a lovely job inside -pallets, reeds etc. This work was done a few years ago but she still looks clean as a whistle - it's certainly cosy inside with all those notes to cram into such a small box!! (It only weighs 6 lbs).
This is my first full three row box and I'm really enjoying all those extra notes and the row crossing. I just hope that this bellows problem can be rectified - I guess I've been spoilt with all my other boxes that certainly don't have this problem.
Any thoughts would be appreciated.
Les
-
Hokay .. what do you mean by Sloppy ? , are they easy to pull and push without any buttons pressed ?.
if so you need to find where the air is escaping , my findings are that prime targets are bellows gasket (where the frames meet the ends), pallets front and rear, inside frame joints (where soundboard meets outer shell), bellows to bellows frame separation, various screws (strap mounts, grille screws or any others which penetrate the inside area of the box) and bellows gussest which can go porous or the glue cracks .
your tongue and face are the best things to feel for seeping air, get the general area with the face and finalize where its escaping from with the tongue (I also have a mechanics stethoscope) ..
As for the reed not sounding, often its just stuck and a quick flick will get it sounding again , could be a bit of wood fibre etc
-
Hokay .. what do you mean by Sloppy ? , are they easy to pull and push without any buttons pressed ?.
if so you need to find where the air is escaping , my findings are that prime targets are bellows gasket (where the frames meet the ends), pallets front and rear, inside frame joints (where soundboard meets outer shell), bellows to bellows frame separation, various screws (strap mounts, grille screws or any others which penetrate the inside area of the box) and bellows gussest which can go porous or the glue cracks .
your tongue and face are the best things to feel for seeping air, get the general area with the face and finalize where its escaping from with the tongue (I also have a mechanics stethoscope) ..
As for the reed not sounding, often its just stuck and a quick flick will get it sounding again , could be a bit of wood fibre etc
Thanks Adam. The problem is that the bellows kind of fall open pretty easily with gravity. There seems to be a fair amount of compression (quite hard to pull open or push shut with out pressing any buttons) so I don't think I've got a leak - I've tried all the moistened lips/ shining a torch etc. things and I can't detect a draught of any kind.
I'll try your trick with the reeds.
Les
-
the better the sealing, the less chance of them falling open without pressing a button . there may be good compression meaning its not a serious leak but it`s leaks all the same . technically, the bellows shouldn`t open at all under gravity unless a button is pressed but few boxes are that well sealed . its harder to feel leaks through the pallets, you need to remove the grille.
-
The problem is that the bellows kind of fall open pretty easily with gravity.
There seems to be a fair amount of compression (quite hard to pull open or push shut with out pressing any buttons) so I don't think I've got a leak
These two statements seem to be at variance with each other. If the bellows open under gravity air is leaking into the bellows somewhere. These things can be very hard to find especially by posting on forums ;). Sure martyn will be able to help when he is back in circulation.
-
The problem is that the bellows kind of fall open pretty easily with gravity.
There seems to be a fair amount of compression (quite hard to pull open or push shut with out pressing any buttons) so I don't think I've got a leak
These two statements seem to be at variance with each other. If the bellows open under gravity air is leaking into the bellows somewhere. These things can be very hard to find especially by posting on forums ;). Sure martyn will be able to help when he is back in circulation.
Yes - it's a mystery isn't it? Maybe I'm being fussy about an 80 year old box??!! After all I don't work too well and I'm only 59!!! ;) ;) ;) - cue loads of jokes about valves, leaks, wheezing etc, etc.
-
Problem identified - it's the air button. When I hold the air button up the bellows stop opening. I've taken the bass grill off and my safety pin/spring repair on the air button isn't tight enough. I've bunged some Blu-Tac into the hole on the other side but this has not helped at all. Any suggestions other than removing the mechanism and opening out the safety pin even more?
At least I'm learning a lot about how it all works!!
-
Spring strength is one thing, but how is the seal of the air button's pallet? May need to change the leather face if it's dry. And possibly all of the pallets' leather!
-
Spring strength is one thing, but how is the seal of the air button's pallet? May need to change the leather face if it's dry. And possibly all of the pallets' leather!
Thanks for this. I'll look into it.
-
If you check all the suggestions and still have air loss then you might have bellows that have become porous. I found this recently on my 1930s Hohner Club. Minute amounts of air were escaping from numerous places in the gussets and in the internal fold lines, and adding up to sugnificant air loss with the same symptoms you described. New bellows made a huge difference, but you need to be sure before committing to a major spend like new bellows.
-
If you check all the suggestions and still have air loss then you might have bellows that have become porous. I found this recently on my 1930s Hohner Club. Minute amounts of air were escaping from numerous places in the gussets and in the internal fold lines, and adding up to sugnificant air loss with the same symptoms you described. New bellows made a huge difference, but you need to be sure before committing to a major spend like new bellows.
Yes, this is what I'm afraid of. Obviously I'll get Martyn to check it out but just so I know, how much, roughly, would new bellows for this instrument cost and would I even be able to get them for such a weird sized instrument?
-
Yes, this is what I'm afraid of. Obviously I'll get Martyn to check it out but just so I know, how much, roughly, would new bellows for this instrument cost and would I even be able to get them for such a weird sized instrument?
http://www.theboxplace.co.uk/purchase/bellows/cat_12.html (http://www.theboxplace.co.uk/purchase/bellows/cat_12.html)
-
Ok - the air button repair didn't hold so I've removed the mechanism completely and very carefully plugged the air button hole with Blu-Tac. The bellows are still opening and I can hear/feel air escaping from the bass end from the air button end - this is just from letting the bellows open - they're not under any load other than that of gravity. I can't hear or feel any air coming from the bellows. Is there any surefire way of finding out if the bellows are indeed porous? It's going to be quite a while before anyone can look at this for me so I'm obviously anxious to at least know what I'm facing.
Be glad of any advice - as always!! ;)
-
Ok - the air button repair didn't hold so I've removed the mechanism completely and very carefully plugged the air button hole with Blu-Tac. The bellows are still opening and I can hear/feel air escaping from the bass end from the air button end - this is just from letting the bellows open - they're not under any load other than that of gravity. I can't hear or feel any air coming from the bellows. Is there any surefire way of finding out if the bellows are indeed porous? It's going to be quite a while before anyone can look at this for me so I'm obviously anxious to at least know what I'm facing.
Be glad of any advice - as always!! ;)
Tracking down this sort of leak is a pain. You say you can hear/feel the air from "the air button end", do you mean from the air button or from its vicinity? One thing it could be is is that the seal between the fondo and the casework is leaking, find this on Hohners from time to time, I usually run some superglue around the joint to fix this but others may suggest other glue.
-
You could try putting some clingfilm over the bass end, initially covering the bellows seal, then peeling it back to just cover the end. You might even see the clingfilm move as you move the bellows.
I think you said you problem is on suck rather than blow, so it should pull in.
Similarly you could wrap some around the bellows. Might not be pretty, but if you can get it to seal (or tape it) then you might be able to identify the area of the leak more accurately.
-
If you want to try a temporary seal of the air valve I would guess blutac would not be very good, masking tape much better.
If you can hear air escaping then my guess would be it is one or two gaps somewhere that are fixable. My experience of porus bellows is that the leaks are silent.
It just boils down to detective work I'm afraid and can be a complete pain. Lesters suggestion is a good one, screw holes ate another possible leak site.
-
Thanks to everyone for your kind help. I'll start again tomorrow and try out all these suggestions. I'm sure it will be worth it in the end as the tone is really nice and the box is a joy to play.
This is all new to me as all the squeezeboxes I've bought thus far have been either nearly new or suitably prepared by an expert. Guess I've been spoilt but I guess I can't complain seeing as this box is getting on a bit!! (:) (:)
-
Ok - sealed the air button hole with several strips of masking tape (both sides). Bellows still opening but nowhere near as much. To be honest all of my boxes' bellows open in the same way (i.e with gravity) - this box is only a bit worse than this so I guess the problem lies with the air button. I don't remember any problem with the bellows prior to the air button spring snapping but I only played it for a few hours before this happened and it wasn't something I was looking for!
Now, if I could only fix the air button mechanism! Sadly, in trying to fit a stronger spring yesterday I snapped a bit of wood off the air button housing (the slot where the retaining pin goes through). I could glue it but to be honest I doubt if it would hold for very long so I'm probably looking at a new block to be glued in place. I think I'll leave that to someone who knows what they're doing.
Anyway - thanks for all the help. Malcolm - the cling film worked a treat btw!!
-
I`ve not seen inside the bass end but Theo & Owen will know if a Pokerwork airbutton / pallet mech could be fitted.
http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Hohner_Parts.html#13
-
I`ve not seen inside the bass end but Theo & Owen will know if a Pokerwork airbutton / pallet mech could be fitted.
http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Hohner_Parts.html#13
Don't think so as there's not enough room for the pallet. I'll try and take a photo to show you.
-
I`ve not seen inside the bass end but Theo & Owen will know if a Pokerwork airbutton / pallet mech could be fitted.
http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Hohner_Parts.html#13
Don't think so as there's not enough room for the pallet. I'll try and take a photo to show you.
Ok - pretty poor quality photo but you can see the double hole that was drilled for the air button pallet with the masking tape behind it. To the right of this you can see the housing for the air button. You can see the open slot where the retaining pin goes - the other side (on top of this) as you can see, has been snapped off. Between the inner side of the box and the housing is a clearance of about 3/4 inch so not sure if a Pokerwork mechanism would fit in here. The area of the double hole is 1 inch x 1/2 inch. This box currently has a push-in type button rather than a slide-down type.
-
My first thought would be a glue repair (assuming you still have the top) then make up some plates to reinforce across the joint, screw or bolt them on. Personally I might use old glass fibre circuit board material which can be glued, but any thin sheet metal would do.
However, it's tricky to get a clear mental picture of scale from this distance.
-
Ok - here's a photo of the actually air button which, because of the need to reach the slot opening on the bass plate, has obviously been built up at some point. As you can see from the pallet to the top of the button is getting on for about 2 inches. I just looked at my Erica and although the height is about the same, the surface area needed to mount the metal frame and for the pallet to go down is far greater than I have here on this little box. Oh well, never mind I'm sure something can be done.
-
I'm fairly certain that a Hohner air valve will not fit on that space.
The choices are either repair the damaged wooden block, or make a new one. It is the fragile nature of components like this that makes me avoid Saxony built boxes!
-
My first thought would be a glue repair (assuming you still have the top) then make up some plates to reinforce across the joint, screw or bolt them on. Personally I might use old glass fibre circuit board material which can be glued, but any thin sheet metal would do.
However, it's tricky to get a clear mental picture of scale from this distance.
Yep I get your drift. The only trouble is the bit that broke off is really small - about 3/8 by 1/4 inch so I don't thing screwing into it is an option. Thanks for your suggestion though. (:)
-
If you have the technology - and possibly an old baked beans tin or something (beer cans, sadly, may not be strong enough - but don't let me stop you experimenting with a few), you could form an inverted U-shaped yoke over the top with a small bolt lower down to fix.
Personally I think a repair with a decent woodworking glue would be strong enough, but it it were to break again it would be harder to repair next time so I would be looking at belt and braces.
You might just be able to glue another shaped bit of wood alongside it.
-
I'm fairly certain that a Hohner air valve will not fit on that space.
The choices are either repair the damaged wooden block, or make a new one. It is the fragile nature of components like this that makes me avoid Saxony built boxes!
"Make a new one" gets my vote. A job for Martyn upon his return methinks. Totally agree about the build quality etc. and if it wasn't for the sound I would have probably deposited this box in the bin by now and put it down to experience. Still, if nothing else, it's taught me loads about the inner workings so that's got to be a good thing, right?
Again, thanks to everyone for your input.
I'll re-post when I get it sorted out and I'm sure I'll feature the box in a future blog.
-
If you have the technology - and possibly an old baked beans tin or something (beer cans, sadly, may not be strong enough - but don't let me stop you experimenting with a few), you could form an inverted U-shaped yoke over the top with a small bolt lower down to fix.
Personally I think a repair with a decent woodworking glue would be strong enough, but it it were to break again it would be harder to repair next time so I would be looking at belt and braces.
You might just be able to glue another shaped bit of wood alongside it.
Hmm - I understand where you're coming from here Malcolm but as I don't really have the technology and I'm quite fond of my fingers I think I'll leave this to someone who's a bit handier than me. (That's about 99.999999% of the human race btw!!). Very many thanks with all your kind help with this problem though.
-
I`m sure Martyn will be able to sort it .
Unwittingly you`ll have contracted MFD (Melnet Fettling Disease), OK Sybil may end up at Martyn`s for sorting but bet your boots your interest will be perked up when you see a tatty Hohner on the cheap which needs bits doing - before long you`ll have fingers covered in reedwax, dead reedvalves bunging up the dyson, the smell of Wax, PVA and polish wafting through the house and a hot-line to Charlie Marshall for bits.
-
I`m sure Martyn will be able to sort it .
Unwittingly you`ll have contracted MFD (Melnet Fettling Disease), OK Sybil may end up at Martyn`s for sorting but bet your boots your interest will be perked up when you see a tatty Hohner on the cheap which needs bits doing - before long you`ll have fingers covered in reedwax, dead reedvalves bunging up the dyson, the smell of Wax, PVA and polish wafting through the house and a hot-line to Charlie Marshall for bits.
You don't know me Adam or you wouldn't be saying this!! I've always been a "I play 'em, I don't fix 'em" kind of guy. I've earned my living all my life from teaching the guitar. Yes, I can change strings but I leave truss rod adjustments and fret dressing to those who know about these things. The only reason I've got under the hood with this box is that I couldn't get it looked at by an expert and being a school teacher, I've got plenty of time on my hands. ;) ;) ;D ;D
-
You don't know me Adam or you wouldn't be saying this!! I've always been a "I play 'em, I don't fix 'em" kind of guy.
So had I with boxes ........... before I discovered Melnet, you had "A BOX" (in my case a big wardrobe of a PA) , Make that two if you did a lot of pubbing as a small one id beneficial, if it went wrong (or not if a decent one and bought from a reliable source) then you sent it to one of a few places who fixed them and you`re back on the road again ....... I fixed Synths because I had to but the box was for playing .....
Then there was Melnet and my first poke inside freeing a sawdust filled reed in a Chinese Stella PA . then it was tinkering an old 1 row Hohner back to playability and so on and so on . Never say Never Les even though you`ve been on the forum a long time, one sniff of reed wax and you`ll be hooked - maybe best to say NO now ;D
-
If you check all the suggestions and still have air loss then you might have bellows that have become porous. I found this recently on my 1930s Hohner Club. Minute amounts of air were escaping from numerous places in the gussets and in the internal fold lines, and adding up to sugnificant air loss with the same symptoms you described. New bellows made a huge difference, but you need to be sure before committing to a major spend like new bellows.
I'm worried that's happened with my Preccy :( There always seems to be some leak with the bellows. Last time it happened was earlier this year, when I got it out of the box and it was gulping air. In desperation I waxed the joins inside - something which I now know that I categorically should not have done, but in my defence it was right before a gig and I needed the damn thing to play. I think that it made a difference, but I will be sending it off to Mike soon :(
-
Les, just a thought re tracing your leak. Try this:
1. Open the bellows to full extent.
2. Insert appropriate flexible pipe into air-hole and seal around it.
3. Attach other end of pipe to gas cooker and fill bellows with gas.
4. Remove pipe from box and seal air-hole.
5. Compress bellows with one hand while using a lighter to trace the leak.
6. The escaping gas will be ignited where it's leaking.
7. Easy; job done.
I doubt that there will be much left of the bellows after this, nor possible the box, dry wood really burns, you know, but at least you will know where the leak originated from.
You might want to do a risk assessment first, and it's not something that others should attempt at home; this is a job for a professional.
I do have a chain saw should you really be desperate.
Cheers, Ian
-
I would suggest holding the lighter on the side away from you. That will make it easier to tell if it's the bellows, or your clothing, that's on fire.
-
I think that it's very sad that people are advocating such hi-tech methods when there are much simpler, easier ones available. Simply fill a bathtub with water, place the box in it, squeeze and look for bubbles.
-
However good an idea, there's always someone wants to pour cold water on it. ::)
-
In desperation I waxed the joins inside - something which I now know that I categorically should not have done, but in my defence it was right before a gig and I needed the damn thing to play.
A certain "Melodeon repairer" (who is NOT a regular of this parish) has done that to a HA114 I`ve now got , the joints on the bellows frames and end boards on these Sieves of boxes are reknown for widening and this guy has filled the thing with reed wax, I`ve no idea how to reverse what he`s done and if when I`ve finished renovating it, it`s still more of a sieve than these things usually are, I`ve no alternative to use wax also as PVA doesn`t stick to reedwax :( . any ideas would be gratefully received.
-
A small triangular section fillet of wood, pinned in place?
-
Les, just a thought re tracing your leak. Try this:
1. Open the bellows to full extent.
2. Insert appropriate flexible pipe into air-hole and seal around it.
3. Attach other end of pipe to gas cooker and fill bellows with gas.
4. Remove pipe from box and seal air-hole.
5. Compress bellows with one hand while using a lighter to trace the leak.
6. The escaping gas will be ignited where it's leaking.
7. Easy; job done.
I doubt that there will be much left of the bellows after this, nor possible the box, dry wood really burns, you know, but at least you will know where the leak originated from.
You might want to do a risk assessment first, and it's not something that others should attempt at home; this is a job for a professional.
I do have a chain saw should you really be desperate.
Cheers, Ian
I've heard of gallows humour - I guess this is bellows humour!!! ;D ;D ;D ;D
-
However good an idea, there's always someone wants to pour cold water on it. ::)
Right on, Malcolm. I think it's called professional jealousy.
-
Well Sybil is back from Martyn's. Lots of things fixed and Dedic-tuned. She sounds really nice but she's still falling open way too much. Martyn is going to do something with the bass pallets on Tuesday which he hopes might address the problem. If not, I fear new bellows might be the only answer.
It occurred to me the other day that an instrument that probably cost just a few Marks back in the thirties has caused something like £1000 to change hands in the last few years. Crazy!!! :-\
-
Hope he sorts it but if not, Theo can get bellows custom made so no doubt Martyn can too while its there .
I`ve got a car like that box of yours (a 20yr old mid engined sports car) which is my only car .. it was in good nick and at a good price for what it is but needed a lot of steering and supension components due to age, then the Exhaust system (which isn`t easy or cheap on Mid engined cars), Rear tyres (weird sized due to their width which were a nightmare to find) then it needed some MOT work then the alternator packed up ..
Like Sybil, you can`t buy anything similar now unless you go for a Costalotti (expensive Italian whatever) so just keep on throwing money at it or end back up with something boring which will still need bits from time to time (same for Melodeons) .
Again, Like Sybil , I guess the answer was to pay a lot more to begin with for a fully fettled one - but also likewise, the uncommon-ness means you hardly get to pluck one off the shelf and that`ll need bits no doubt too pretty soon.
regarding My Boxes, I dread something going wrong with the Zupan (especially breaking one of those massive Voci AM Helikon reeds) , Me fixing it would be like "tinkering" with a Bentley with a lump hammer and adjustable spanner :( .. thankfully like Bentleys, there`s a lot less chance of it needing it in my lifetime despite being made in the 80s.
-
Hope he sorts it but if not, Theo can get bellows custom made so no doubt Martyn can too while its there .
But you do want to be pretty sure that the bellows is the "real" problem before spending significant amounts of more money. The mechanism, both treble and bass, on those boxes leaves a lot to be desired, and even when everything looks ok there can still be numerous tiny leaks that add up to a not-very-airtight box.
-
Yes, it's turned into a bit of a nightmare but as you say Theo, I definitely won't be buying bellows unless I can be sure that will solve the problem. Martyn doesn't seem to think that the bellows are the problem. The air does seem to be escaping from the bass side so maybe what he does on Tuesday will help. It's frustrating because I really love the sound/feel/look of this box. I'm sure that there were many of these made but it's the only one like this that I've seen.
-
Very sensible. The frustrating thing about some of these better quality Saxony boxes is that the reeds can sound very sweet, but the build quality of the action in particular, really lets them down badly. Once Hohner introduced their all metal action around 1930 that set a standard that the other German makers could never really reach.
-
Ok - the saga continues. Spent five hours at Martyn White's workshop the other day where at no extra charge, he very kindly re-felted/leathered the bass pallets and pulled and tweaked generally.
Lester you would be interested to know that he found a leak on the treble side which he fixed by running wax around the place where the soundboard joins the casing.
Anyhow the upshot of all this is that Sybil is a bit tighter than she was and I'm just going to have to accept that this is "as good as it gets".
One small thing that made a big difference was tightening the bass strap so I am more in control of that side.
Start of a new term so up to my neck in school work but when the dust settles I'll do a blog that features her.
-
Lester you would be interested to know that he found a leak on the treble side which he fixed by running wax around the place where the soundboard joins the casing.
Lester passed on the valuable tip of using Superglue for that, it only works when the gap is very narrow because it`ll run through larger gaps but the great thing about it is that it`s runny and gets to the leak like the old "leakfix" windscreen sealant used to on car screen leaks. I use PVA glue for larger gaps . I`ve still not worked out how to stop old hohner bellows frame corners from leaking yet though.
Glad to see that Sybil is finally on the road, and that Martyn threw in some goodwill work on it too :)
-
Lester you would be interested to know that he found a leak on the treble side which he fixed by running wax around the place where the soundboard joins the casing.
Lester passed on the valuable tip of using Superglue for that, it only works when the gap is very narrow because it`ll run through larger gaps but the great thing about it is that it`s runny and gets to the leak like the old "leakfix" windscreen sealant used to on car screen leaks. I use PVA glue for larger gaps . I`ve still not worked out how to stop old hohner bellows frame corners from leaking yet though.
Glad to see that Sybil is finally on the road, and that Martyn threw in some goodwill work on it too :)
Thanks Adam.
Yep, Martyn is a really good chap who takes great pride about what goes out of his workshop. I got coffee and biscuits too!! ;)
-
His work looks superb, I wish my renovations (although deliberately "Aged" looking) were a fraction as good , I really like that Erika restoration he did .. I`m getting there eventually and I like the two I`ve done anyway and that`s what matters :) ..
-
His work looks superb, I wish my renovations (although deliberately "Aged" looking) were a fraction as good , I really like that Erika restoration he did .. I`m getting there eventually and I like the two I`ve done anyway and that`s what matters :) ..
Yes, I'm sorely tempted by one of his Bb/Eb 1930's Erikas. I think it goes something like this "Er Jenny, you know I gave you my DG Erica well there's a gap on the shelf now......" ;D ;D ;D >:E >:E >:E
-
I`d like one too - I love the loud powerful sound of the 30s 2915 shape Doubleray I rebuilt , those old zinc plate reeds scream one minute and are quiet and controlled the next (probably down to being played in for 80 years ?), same for the "Studerwerk" PA (basically the same box with uni reeds and a wooden piano leyboard stuffed on) same deal .
I need a Bb Eb box anyway though I`m leaning towards another Gonk or a very old fettler Steirische - an old Oberhorner or Peter Stachl in need of valves etc would be ideal. I may however look an Erika in that key on German Fleabay , cash is the big issue here :(
-
The reason for using wax instead of PVA to seal the gap is that the soundboard would have been glued in place with scotch glue.
One of the tricks I learnt during the many years I spent restoring antiques is, one of the best ways to clean off old scotch glue is to put some pva on it.
This will soften it and turn it to a jelly which can then be easily scraped off. I don't think Les would have thanked me if Syb ended up falling apart :o. Superglue I'm sure would also attack the scotch glue. Because reed wax has a much lower melting point than the glue, this I considered to be the safest and most effective method to use.
Martyn
-
The reason for using wax instead of PVA to seal the gap is that the soundboard would have been glued in place with scotch glue.
One of the tricks I learnt during the many years I spent restoring antiques is, one of the best ways to clean off old scotch glue is to put some pva on it.
I love the stuff you learn from this forum ! . thanks Martyn - Apart from a 48 bass Galotta PA (weltmeister), I`ve only had to glue Hohners soundboard joins
-
The reason for using wax instead of PVA to seal the gap is that the soundboard would have been glued in place with scotch glue.
One of the tricks I learnt during the many years I spent restoring antiques is, one of the best ways to clean off old scotch glue is to put some pva on it.
This will soften it and turn it to a jelly which can then be easily scraped off. I don't think Les would have thanked me if Syb ended up falling apart :o. Superglue I'm sure would also attack the scotch glue. Because reed wax has a much lower melting point than the glue, this I considered to be the safest and most effective method to use.
Martyn
Interesting insights. My instinct would have been to use scotch glue, where that was the original glue. Is there a reason for preferring wax?
-
Apart from it probably taking a couple of hours to get the old glue pot cleaned out and fired up :|bl you would really need to dismantle the joint, clean off all of the old glue and re-glue it for it to be an effective repair using scotch glue.
Martyn
-
Blog 20 which features Sibyl is now up if you want to have a look.
http://youtu.be/Hi2ZURYyxFM
-
Exellent stuff ! the treble end doesn`t look any worse built than a Liliput ..
-
Lester passed on the valuable tip of using Superglue for that, it only works when the gap is very narrow because it`ll run through larger gaps but the great thing about it is that it`s runny and gets to the leak like the old "leakfix" windscreen sealant used to on car screen leaks.
[/quote]
If you check around wood workers supply stores, you will find that "superglue" comes in many forms now. Gap filling, extra thin, thick, and flexible ,to name a few.
A simple tool you may find handy to find leaks, and that I find handy at the shop is a Doctors stethoscope that I cut off just before the disc, and add a piece of 1/8 in metal tube about 6 in long. You pass the tube end along a suspected leak area (while squeezing the box), and you will hear a "woosh" as you pass over the leak.
Works well for leaky pallets, as you can pass the tube along the edges, and between them.
-
A simple tool you may find handy to find leaks, and that I find handy at the shop is a Doctors stethoscope that I cut off just before the
That`s exactly what I use , it`s invaluable . I also use a thin sliver of greaseproof paper to check pallets touching the board uniformly when there are pallet leaks - check an end at a time to see if the pallet grips the paper