Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Chris Brimley on September 15, 2016, 10:14:11 AM

Title: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 15, 2016, 10:14:11 AM
Prompted by another recent thread, I've just tried something out, and it works, so I thought I'd share it in case others find it of use.

Miking up an accordion of any type is notoriously difficult to do.  There are lots of sources of sound, spread over quite a wide area, and the LH moves around all the time.  Any microphone system needs to accommodate all these evenly and faithfully, and also not be susceptible to feedback.

There have been different approaches to this problem.  Mine is to have two free-standing mics, one for the RH sources and the other for the average position of the LH sources, sufficiently far away to be reasonably even across all the sound sources.  And these mics need to be designed to have a narrow 'cone' of responsiveness along their axis, to have little response from the opposite direction, and to be positioned pointing away from the monitor speaker.  However, what I'm going to say applies equally to other systems such as close mics.

I've always advocated recording yourself to listen critically to what you sound like.  You just don't get an accurate impression when playing on stage of what the audience hears, because what you mainly hear is the acoustic sound of the box, that you're familiar with.  It's easy to imagine that's what the audience is hearing.  Therefore by recording yourself through the mic system you use you should be able to discern any problems.  This is an invaluable technique for all musicians, I reckon, but it is sadly underused.  Many seem to believe that from the point that they play a note, it is up to the sound engineer to reproduce it.  Wrong, sound engineers are human, and the systems needed to mic up an accordion are specific to the instrument, and usually not within their capabilities.

Now the snag with recording yourself, playing it back and re-adjusting your interface system is that it takes time - it is not immediate, and it can be painstaking.

So I just tried something else.  I've bought myself a sub-mixer for my personal use.  They're ridiculously cheap these days, about £70 in my case for a Behringer Xenyx 1202.  Most people would only need a cheaper mixer with few channels, but I play various instruments, so I bought a 12 channel model.  I plugged my (Samson Q1) mics in, turned on the phantom power to make them work and used some noise-cancelling headphones into the mixer output to listen directly to the sound the audience would hear.

Hey presto! I can then fiddle around with the mic positioning to my heart's content, and can immediately check what happens to the sound.  I can compare the notes produced at various points on the keyboard, and immediately compare with the natural acoustic sound, by taking off the headphones.  I can check for odd sounds, eq, and balance between RH and LH.

What did I learn?  First, that the concept of my system does work well - you can back off the box from the mics I use quite a lot to achieve an even sound, and it will still be picked up.  And variations in signal when moving the LH side through the 'cone' of sound are perfectly acceptable.  Second, that I needed to cut the top treble a little because of sibilance - when you listen to yourself playing, you're hearing a sound with less top treble than the audience, because treble frequencies are attenuated when you're sitting above the box.  And third, that the use of noise-cancelling headphones is not actually critical - any headphones will do, provided that they surround your ears and blanket the acoustic sound.

I'd really urge people who have bought, or are considering buying a microphone system for their box, to try this.

There's other benefits of having a personal sub-mixer - if you're a musician who likes to play at Open Mike sessions or amplified folk clubs, you're giving the sound engineer one DI lead to adjust for volume - he/she doesn't need to do anything else.




Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: IanD on September 15, 2016, 11:14:14 PM
Speaking as both box player and sound engineer, a stand mic for the left-hand end doesn't work very well on a stage with other instruments or foldback, it's too prone to picking up background noise/bleed from other instruments and feeding back, especially if the box player wants some bass end in their foldback and uses the bellows so the bass end moves around. Careful mic positioning helps, but it's either too far away so you have to turn the gain up (pong, howl...) or the volume varies a lot as it moves around. It can be OK for solo box players with relatively quiet foldback, but in a band on a crowded stage it's asking for trouble.

For treble end a stand mic (preferably hypercardioid) about the height of the box away works very well, for the bass end a gooseneck clip-on is a much more reliable solution than a stand mic. In both cases the sound isn't what you hear listening to the box either from the audience or as a player since the mics are a lot closer to the box and on-axis for all the treble sounds and key noise, you usually need some treble cut on both ends and often some carefully chosen mid cut on the bass end to remove any "honkyness".

For recording it's completely different, for a smooth sound and even pickup the best solution is a high-quality condenser mic for each end placed several feet away, assuming you're in a room or studio with good acoustics.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 16, 2016, 10:07:21 PM
There's two separate issues here - the first one is to do with feedback problems, which is not something I was covering in this thread (though it's equally easy to try out experimentally).  I have to say however that I don't find with my system that the LH mic, as I position it, is any more problematic than the RHS with regard to feedback (and indeed feedback is hardly ever a problem for me on either end).  Not surprising really, because I have both mics pointing directly away from the monitor, on which axis alignment signals of all frequencies are highly attenuated on my Q1's.  In fact, I find that other systems, where one or other mic moves around, are more unpredictable, and therefore more likely to cause feedback when the mic is pointing the wrong way.  Ian, I am sure you and I will many times have had the experience of a careless caller or musician aligning their mikes towards a monitor or FoH speaker, and then being surprised that they howl.  One of the benefits of a static system is that this doesn't usually happen.  The other thing is that small close mics are not usually as directional as larger free-standing ones, and that is why I suggest they may be more susceptible to causing the feedback problems you refer to.

The second issue is that of the quality and evenness of the sound of the LH mic, and that is where the experiment I was talking about comes into its own.  If the direction of travel of the LH end is perpendicular to the axis of the mic, and it is a reasonable distance away, say around 20cm, then my experiment showed me the sound can be faithful, and pretty even across the normal range of bellows movement, which is usually much the same as the displacement of sound sources on the RHS.  Provided both are within the 'cone' of even influence on the mic, the concept does seem to work very well.  I accept that the close mic idea might work well too on the LHS with suitable eq'ing because the sound sources are closer together, but the point of this thread is that it gives the player a chance to do that very comparison for themselves.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: IanD on September 17, 2016, 01:44:39 PM
There's two separate issues here - the first one is to do with feedback problems, which is not something I was covering in this thread (though it's equally easy to try out experimentally).  I have to say however that I don't find with my system that the LH mic, as I position it, is any more problematic than the RHS with regard to feedback (and indeed feedback is hardly ever a problem for me on either end).  Not surprising really, because I have both mics pointing directly away from the monitor, on which axis alignment signals of all frequencies are highly attenuated on my Q1's.  In fact, I find that other systems, where one or other mic moves around, are more unpredictable, and therefore more likely to cause feedback when the mic is pointing the wrong way.  Ian, I am sure you and I will many times have had the experience of a careless caller or musician aligning their mikes towards a monitor or FoH speaker, and then being surprised that they howl.  One of the benefits of a static system is that this doesn't usually happen.  The other thing is that small close mics are not usually as directional as larger free-standing ones, and that is why I suggest they may be more susceptible to causing the feedback problems you refer to.

The second issue is that of the quality and evenness of the sound of the LH mic, and that is where the experiment I was talking about comes into its own.  If the direction of travel of the LH end is perpendicular to the axis of the mic, and it is a reasonable distance away, say around 20cm, then my experiment showed me the sound can be faithful, and pretty even across the normal range of bellows movement, which is usually much the same as the displacement of sound sources on the RHS.  Provided both are within the 'cone' of even influence on the mic, the concept does seem to work very well.  I accept that the close mic idea might work well too on the LHS with suitable eq'ing because the sound sources are closer together, but the point of this thread is that it gives the player a chance to do that very comparison for themselves.

I have indeed had the "idiot caller" problem, but I've never had this problem with clip-on mics on the bass end -- assuming they're cardioid pattern (which most are, the same as most stand mics -- and being small capsule they've often got a more consistent pickup pattern) they're so much closer to the box than the foldback that this isn't really an issue. The big enemy on stage as far as feedback is concerned is distance from the mic -- if you find that you get reliable pickup with it 20cm away then you must move your bellows around a lot less than many other players, me included. A stand mic also relies on the player keeping the bass end position where it was when you did a soundcheck, which is also not always the case -- in other words in the right circumstances and used carefully (e.g. by you) it can work well, but in many cases it doesn't.

So I stand by my assertion that on stage a stand mic for the bass end is much more likely to cause problems than a (correctly positioned) clip-on, based on experience of mixing for a fair number of bands over the years. It's why I use one on stage as do many (most?) other box players, along with a stand mic for the treble end -- IMHO each is the best solution for two different problems.

If people find that stand mics on both ends work for them, that's fine. But then don't be surprised if at a booking you ask the sound guy for more bass end in the foldback (or out front) and he says he can't do that because of feedback -- I know, I've been there both on and off stage...
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 17, 2016, 03:11:25 PM
Certainly, I wouldn't trust my system to work using other mics I didn't know, I always take them with me.  The mic's characteristics are crucial to the success of this. 

But I still feel this is straying from the topic - I wasn't promoting the system I happen to use, I was promoting the idea that players carrying out their own experiments into whatever interface they are using, through a sub-mixer, and then decide for themselves.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: IanD on September 17, 2016, 03:59:52 PM
Certainly, I wouldn't trust my system to work using other mics I didn't know, I always take them with me.  The mic's characteristics are crucial to the success of this. 

But I still feel this is straying from the topic - I wasn't promoting the system I happen to use, I was promoting the idea that players carrying out their own experiments into whatever interface they are using, through a sub-mixer, and then decide for themselves.
That's fine Chris -- but you also said:

"There's other benefits of having a personal sub-mixer - if you're a musician who likes to play at Open Mike sessions or amplified folk clubs, you're giving the sound engineer one DI lead to adjust for volume - he/she doesn't need to do anything else."

Which is true (as far as it goes) under those circumstances, but not if you're in a band on a stage which is the other case you were talking about. It removes the ability for the sound engineer to change the balance between treble and bass ends, which might have been right when you listened to the instrument on its own but is very often not right when playing in a band (usually too much bass end) -- and especially not if there are any feedback problems from a bass end stand mic, so you can't turn the treble end up when the box is leading a tune...

Being blunt, players deciding for themselves (sub-mixing) can work so long as they know what they're doing (correct balance and EQ for both ends) and make the right decision for the circumstances (e.g. playing solo). In other cases (e.g. playing in a band, or with foldback) it can make it difficult or impossible to get a decent sound out to the audience, which is surely what matters?

Speaking from the POV of the guy behind the desk whose job this is, a single channel for both ends of a melodeon is a bad thing much more often than it is a good thing --- you can't adjust the treble/bass end balance, you can't EQ the two ends separately, you can't put mostly (or just) treble end in the monitors for other musicians, if the bass end feeds back first you can't turn the treble end up and nobody can hear the tune. And if the sound is bad, guess who will get the blame?

For most people in most circumstances -- one lead good, two leads better... ;-)

Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 18, 2016, 12:51:39 PM
I did indeed say that, Ian - I confess it was a bit of a throw-away comment at the time!  But yes, your comments go into an interesting area of the interplay between sound engineers and musicians, which I agree is highly worth discussing.

First, I think (for the reasons you give) that I agree with your idea of separate channels, if you're a sound engineer who understands about accordions, as you obviously are. (It sounds like it would be very enjoyable to play on a stage you are running!)  However, for the great majority of us on this forum, it's probably true to say that the sound engineers at folk clubs and open mic clubs (or even within dance bands?) are used to 95% of their musicians being vocalists or acoustic guitarists, whose needs are very different.  The truth is that many sound engineers are not specialist in mic'ing up accordions of any kind, and may need assistance from the player.

However, I also feel that when I'm the sound engineer, I really appreciate it when a musician has taken the trouble to listen to themselves through their own 'interface'  (I can't think of a better word to describe this), and tried to adjust it to best suit their requirements.  I would usually defer to their artistic decisions on the balance they want, if they've done that listening.  It is of concern that so few take the time to try out their systems, don't you agree?  (It is also slightly worrying to me that you and I are the only contributors to this thread so far, because if anyone out there ever wants to play amplified, this is stuff you'll probably need to consider!) 

In my view, producing a good sound from any instrument can only be an interactive process between sound engineer and musician.  As somebody said, 'If the gig's going well, the musicians are on top form.  If it's not, it must be the sound engineer's fault.' 

But I think we can move on from this.  As musicians, we've all come away from gigs complaining about the sound in some respect.  We hardly ever say to ourselves 'so next time let's agree x y and z with the sound engineer, in advance.'

I think you and I are going in the same direction, Ian.  Your argument is I think that the sound engineer should be responsible for doing it.  Mine is that that's true, but it's a good idea for any accordionist to understand the inherent problems they're giving the sound engineer, if they want a better sound.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Rob2Hook on September 18, 2016, 02:32:46 PM
OK, so the two of you have some common experience but many differences.  I'd have to agree that many sound engineers have no idea how to mic and process an accordian.  I well remember diong a turn on the Sidmouth main stage.  Nobody else will, it was raining so hard the only "audience" couldn't get his wheelchair out of the mud!  It struck me as odd that the sound crew only set up a single mic for each box and told us to play as close as we could to it.  In fact we all stood back, so the sound included the basses.

In our ceilidh band, we considered running all the signal leads back to a desk, but in the end preferred tohave the drummer set us up through headphones on stage with a second opinion from his wife standing in the body of the hall.  I use a pair of AKG C1000s on drum stands (more copact than the average stand) and find their directional characteristics prevent feedback far better than some of the cheaper mics in use - usually cheap dynamic types

Of course, Ian spent quite some time playing in a band with their own "full-time" sound engineer who always managed to achieve more than you'd believe the hall's accoustics would allow - but he intimately knew every instrument in the band..

Horses for courses - you're both right given the right circumstances.

Rob.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 18, 2016, 02:47:20 PM
Quote
It struck me as odd that the sound crew only set up a single mic for each box and told us to play as close as we could to it.

Oh dear, for Sidmouth main stage, that is pretty awful advice!  I'm hoping this was maybe some time ago?
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: IanD on September 18, 2016, 05:03:32 PM
For sure, it helps if musicians understand about how to mic up their instruments -- whatever method they choose -- and can make helpful suggestions to whoever is doing the sound. There are some excellent sound engineers around (e.g. Sam Skey who used to knob for TCB) but also some not-so-capable ones (who are often the ones who aren't willing to listen to such helpful suggestions), we've had bad experiences even at festivals where you wouldn't expect it.

For most bands a separate sound engineer sitting at a desk out front is not an option, either because of lack of availability or cost, so they have to do their own mixing from the stage. This can be made much easier nowadays with the advent of modern digital mixers (we now use a Behringer XR18 "mixer-in-a-stage-box") which can be remote-controlled from a laptop/tablet/phone, so at setup one of the band members can walk out into the hall and check and adjust the sound from there, instead of having to shout instructions back to somebody on stage -- and if there are numbers where they don't play some of the time, they can do this again during the gig to check volume and balance.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: vof on September 18, 2016, 07:44:07 PM
(It is also slightly worrying to me that you and I are the only contributors to this thread so far, because if anyone out there ever wants to play amplified, this is stuff you'll probably need to consider!) 

Don't worry Chris, there are some of us out here reading and inwardly digesting every word in this thread against the time and situation we will need to amp our boxes. For myself, those I play with at the moment think my Pokerwork is too loud as it is >:E so I don't have anything to contribute here.

Vince
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Andy Next Tune on September 19, 2016, 10:57:26 AM
A few months ago I purchased a Behringer Xenyx 802USB and some AKG studio headphones in order to be able to do the type of experimentation Chris has suggested.

This thread and previous ones around the topics of mics, PA, etc have been very helpful increasing my understanding of the challenges of amplifying a ceilidh band. Like most bands, we don't have the luxury of a sound guy, and tend to focus on volume and instrument balance, rather than the sound 'quality' of individual instruments.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Howard Jones on September 19, 2016, 11:19:52 AM
I play concertina as well as melodeon and I've found that stand mics don't work for me.  In the beginning I played with a stand mic for the treble end and tiepin mic for the bass, before ditching the stand for a custom made microvox-style stuck on with velcro.  In the interests of freedom of movement, reducing spill from other instruments, and simply space on stage when we're playing in village halls with a stage slightly smaller than the band, for me it's now clip-on mics all the way.  With Albireo I now use an AKG C516 on the treble end and T-bone C75s on the bass end and the concertinas. I'm afraid flexibility and ease of use win out over getting perfect sound, but this is for a live ceilidh, not for recording or even a concert.

For a long time I used a small sub-mixer, but mainly to mute the channels I'm not using. Since I often change instruments mid-set, and since our soundie is also the bass player and sometimes the caller (although he'll only do 2 of these jobs at once), it's unfair to expect him to manage this as well. I don't touch the EQ, and once the channels have been balanced during the sound check I don't touch the faders either.

We too have now gone digital (Behringer X-32 - lots of pretty lights!) and I can now do this wirelessly with a tablet, as well as having full control over my own foldback.

I quite agree that musicians should have at least some understanding of mic placements for their instruments.  However in my experience the good sound engineers already know more about this than I do, while the bad ones think they do and won't be told.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 19, 2016, 01:39:06 PM
Can I just pick up on some earlier comments, because they may be crucial to understanding the technical background to this whole interface thing?

Ian preferred the use of hypercardioid microphones.  These do respond to sounds that are directly from the rear of the mic, but they have dead spots at other angles.  (Nulls at 109.5 degrees, eg.)  It would seem to me then that if you use these types of mics, it's crucial if you want to avoid feedback to make sure they are aligned so that the instrument when played coincides these dead spots with the monitor position.  What's more, as a musician you need to know this, and how to position your box and your close mics (if you use them) to avoid feedback.  Ian, you may have some recommendations on this subject, which might be good for advocates of close mic systems?

In my case, my Samson Q1's are cardioid condenser mics, and these have the dead spot directly to the rear, which makes aligning them easy - you just point them directly away from the sound source (the monitor), and you really don't then get feedback.  Ian, you mentioned the biggest feedback problem as being distance from the mic.  I agree with this being a big issue, but I feel it also depends on the mic, and if you have a Q1 or similar the biggest issue in practice is alignment, and proximity is then the issue you want to experiment with.

There is another issue here, and that concerns interference.  We've had discussions before on this forum about this, and basically the issue is that at certain frequencies, two mics coinciding can give rise to weird interference effects as those frequencies cancel each other out.  For recording purposes, most people use stereo mics on 'X-Y' axes, 90 degrees apart.  Having this in mind, for many years I used to set my mics at this angle, when playing box. This meant that the rear dead spot wasn't as effective, though it still worked pretty well.  However, one of the things I've learned from my experiment is that with my mics, and my positions, this interference effect is for some reason very minor, and the feedback suppression issue seems more important.

Just a last comment - it seems that many close mic advocates accept sound compromises for other good reasons.  Nothing wrong with this - but I'd still suggest that the 'brutal' acid-test experiment is worth while.  If you're in a band with no separate auditorium sound engineer, the sound the audience is hearing could be very different from what you'd hoped, and let's face it, we need to check that out - the audience won't ever tell us, and therefore you may never know.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: IanD on September 19, 2016, 04:19:26 PM
Can I just pick up on some earlier comments, because they may be crucial to understanding the technical background to this whole interface thing?

Ian preferred the use of hypercardioid microphones.  These do respond to sounds that are directly from the rear of the mic, but they have dead spots at other angles.  (Nulls at 109.5 degrees, eg.)  It would seem to me then that if you use these types of mics, it's crucial if you want to avoid feedback to make sure they are aligned so that the instrument when played coincides these dead spots with the monitor position.  What's more, as a musician you need to know this, and how to position your box and your close mics (if you use them) to avoid feedback.  Ian, you may have some recommendations on this subject, which might be good for advocates of close mic systems?

In my case, my Samson Q1's are cardioid condenser mics, and these have the dead spot directly to the rear, which makes aligning them easy - you just point them directly away from the sound source (the monitor), and you really don't then get feedback.  Ian, you mentioned the biggest feedback problem as being distance from the mic.  I agree with this being a big issue, but I feel it also depends on the mic, and if you have a Q1 or similar the biggest issue in practice is alignment, and proximity is then the issue you want to experiment with.

There is another issue here, and that concerns interference.  We've had discussions before on this forum about this, and basically the issue is that at certain frequencies, two mics coinciding can give rise to weird interference effects as those frequencies cancel each other out.  For recording purposes, most people use stereo mics on 'X-Y' axes, 90 degrees apart.  Having this in mind, for many years I used to set my mics at this angle, when playing box. This meant that the rear dead spot wasn't as effective, though it still worked pretty well.  However, one of the things I've learned from my experiment is that with my mics, and my positions, this interference effect is for some reason very minor, and the feedback suppression issue seems more important.

Just a last comment - it seems that many close mic advocates accept sound compromises for other good reasons.  Nothing wrong with this - but I'd still suggest that the 'brutal' acid-test experiment is worth while.  If you're in a band with no separate auditorium sound engineer, the sound the audience is hearing could be very different from what you'd hoped, and let's face it, we need to check that out - the audience won't ever tell us, and therefore you may never know.

The reason for preferring hypercardioid stand mics is partly that they pick up less ambient noise because of the tighter pattern, but also that there's much more chance of getting the monitor near a pattern null and having the mic pointing at the instrument. Monitors are normally on the floor so with a cardioid you'd ideally want the rear of the mic pointing at the monitor which is rarely possible, hypercardioids have a much bigger rear "dead zone" and with the null at an angle to the mic rear you can often point the null at a monitor. Also if you use the rule-of-thumb of keeping the mic as far away from the grille as the length of the grille, there's very little extra loss at the top and bottom notes of the box with the tighter pattern.

For recording purposes in studios, every one I've been in hasn't used a crossed pair for recording a box, they've used mics each pointing at the two ends, the treble end mic from the right and the bass end mic from the left, at least a couple of feet away -- this gives less bleed between the channels than a crossed pair, which is what you want if you're doing multitrack recording.

As I said, close-micing -- especially with clip-ons -- does *not* give the same sound as listening to the instrument even with a perfect microphone, significant EQ is always needed to get a more natural sound. If you do this (and the mics are positioned correctly) there's no reason the quality should be inherently worse than a stand mic, but it does take more work to get the right sound and if you don't do it the sound will be worse.

As far as FOH sound is concerned you're entirely in the hands of the sound engineer, and if you're using monitors you haven't got a clue what it sounds like anyway -- if the monitor sound is good the band will be happy even if the audience isn't, and vice versa...
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 20, 2016, 10:44:34 AM
Ian, for those using hypercardiod mics, would you like to recommend a good set-up position, in relation to a monitor?  (I accept that this will probably depend on the actual mics in use.)

Just to reiterate a point on eq'ing close mics:  a player shouldn't imagine that you can just 'eq out' the proximity effect issue, because you can't deal with the different distances to the multiple sound sources that way.  So for example, if your close mic is over the mid-range reeds, and you want to reduce the proximity effect by reducing the bass frequencies, you will also be reducing those frequencies on the lower reeds which are further away, but which you actually want to boost.  I've heard people say: 'The trouble with close mic system X is that no matter what you do to it, it just doesn't sound like a melodeon.'  This is probably the main reason.  (There are also lots of more complex reasons to do with the many sound sources and the differences in the ways they are heard by the mic and by an ear.) 

I find I also notice when a LH has a close mic, because the very fact that it is moving with the sound source seems different from a natural sound - it's somehow more even.  Whether this has something to do with the Doppler effect rather than proximity, I really don't know.  Also I'm not saying it's a bad thing, it is often used very effectively by players, in the same way that bass guitarists will use compression to create an even sound with more sustain (though of course compression uses a different principle.)

I was talking the other day about this thread with a friend of mine, who is a 'proper' sound engineer (and who originally suggested the Q1's for my needs many years ago.)  He says that he has gone through similar thought processes with regard to the mic'ing up of drum kits, over the years.  He used to use lots of different mics, so that you could pick up the perfect rim shot, or whatever, but now he just relies on the triangular system of one bass drum mic and two overheads pointing down, for the best and most natural sound.  I guess a drum kit has the same issues of multiple sound sources, but they're even worse to deal with!
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 20, 2016, 10:50:25 AM
Oh, I forgot: 
Quote
with a cardioid you'd ideally want the rear of the mic pointing at the monitor which is rarely possible

Not sure why not, Ian, that's exactly what I do, and I find it's very easy.  With the LH one I set it so that it points to the middle-open bellows position.  Because the bellows are moving perpendicularly to the mic's axis, it gives a very even signal - one of the things I was testing with my experiment.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: IanD on September 20, 2016, 02:20:35 PM
Oh, I forgot: 
Quote
with a cardioid you'd ideally want the rear of the mic pointing at the monitor which is rarely possible

Not sure why not, Ian, that's exactly what I do, and I find it's very easy.  With the LH one I set it so that it points to the middle-open bellows position.  Because the bellows are moving perpendicularly to the mic's axis, it gives a very even signal - one of the things I was testing with my experiment.

If the monitor is a floor wedge in front of you (most common position)  and you're using stand mics on one (or both) ends, to get this in the pickup null cardioids ideally need to below the box (i.e. closer to the monitor) and pointing upwards and outwards. Hypercardioids can be placed higher up level with the box and pointing horizontally and parallel with each other, this gets them further from the monitor and also gives more even pickup of all the reeds. If you're using a side-fill at ear height instead of a floor monitor (which is what I do) the reverse applies.

Your comment about proximity effect being the problem with close micing isn't normally true, this depends on the size of the mic capsule but usually only gets significant if you get within a few inches -- proximity effect is caused by the fact that the wavefront at the mic is no longer planar, and is worse for bigger mic capsules, and also worse in the order (figure8 -- hypercardioid -- cardioid) -- omnidirectional mics don't suffer from it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proximity_effect_(audio)

The problem you're referring to is with tonal quality, either because the high frequencies are directional so the mic picks up what the ear doesn't (e.g. melodeon treble end), or the sound close to the instrument is very different to far away (e.g. fiddle, guitar, double bass), or the pickup of different notes differs because they're different distances away from the mic (e.g. piano accordion with a relatively close single mic) -- if this is what you mean it's not proximity effect, that has a specific and different meaning with microphones (see above).
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Anahata on September 20, 2016, 02:26:44 PM
for those using hypercardiod mics, would you like to recommend a good set-up position, in relation to a monitor?
Trial and error advisable of course, but as a starting point, in theory the null of a hypercardiod is a cone at 120 degrees off axis.

Quote
I guess a drum kit has the same issues of multiple sound sources, but they're even worse to deal with!
In recording studios anything from one to over twenty mics have been used on drum kits.
There's a classic 4 mic setup, which as you described with the addition of a 4th mic on snare.
After that it escalates rapidly because if you want to close-mic one extra drum you end up wanting to do all the others to match...
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: IanD on September 20, 2016, 02:35:07 PM
for those using hypercardiod mics, would you like to recommend a good set-up position, in relation to a monitor?
Trial and error advisable of course, but as a starting point, in theory the null of a hypercardiod is a cone at 120 degrees off axis.

Quote
I guess a drum kit has the same issues of multiple sound sources, but they're even worse to deal with!
In recording studios anything from one to over twenty mics have been used on drum kits.
There's a classic 4 mic setup, which as you described with the addition of a 4th mic on snare.
After that it escalates rapidly because if you want to close-mic one extra drum you end up wanting to do all the others to match...

Don't forget two mics on the bass drum as well, one front/inside, one rear pointing at the beater with phase reversed...
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 20, 2016, 03:25:51 PM
Quote
Your comment about proximity effect being the problem with close micing isn't normally true, this depends on the size of the mic capsule but usually only gets significant if you get within a few inches

Which I think many such systems are, because they are trying to cut down feedback problems?

Regarding proximity effect, I don't think I was saying it's the problem per se, I was saying that compensating for it simply by eq'ing won't resolve the whole issue - are we in agreement on that point, Ian? 

I've always thought of 'proximity' effect purely as a sound phenomenon caused by the greater ability of low frequency sound waves to bend round corners and thus cancel each other out, rather than some problem with the microphone.  For example, put your ear near a cymbal!

I'm interested in your 'upwards and outwards' comment - can you explain what the 'upwards' alignment is about?  Is it something to do with keeping the sound sources well-aligned in relation to the mic axis?

Anahata, thanks for your 120 deg comment - how does this translate to a good mic'ing system, in practice?





 
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: penn on September 20, 2016, 04:01:11 PM
Quote
..........
I've always thought of 'proximity' effect purely as a sound phenomenon caused by the greater ability of low frequency sound waves to bend round corners and thus cancel each other out, rather than some problem with the microphone.  ........
 
not all microphones exhibit proximity effect - omnis don't
Steve
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: dave t on September 20, 2016, 04:33:00 PM
Quote
..........
I've always thought of 'proximity' effect purely as a sound phenomenon caused by the greater ability of low frequency sound waves to bend round corners and thus cancel each other out, rather than some problem with the microphone.  ........
 
not all microphones exhibit proximity effect - omnis don't
Steve

Right. The proximity effect is a function of mic design and is inherent to some degree to all directional mics and mics with switchable polar patterns. Not that you'd really want to use an omni in live sound as it's far more likely to give you problems with feedback.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 20, 2016, 04:42:48 PM
But if the ear exhibits proximity effect, it's difficult to say that one or other mic is being 'unrealistic' - it's just that you need to use different ones for different applications.  I suspect (but haven't tried it) that if I put an omni-directional mic near a cymbal, it would sound much the same as it would to an ear?
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: dave t on September 20, 2016, 05:24:01 PM
But if the ear exhibits proximity effect

What makes you say that the ear exhibits proximity effect?
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 20, 2016, 06:13:34 PM
Well I don't know, but from the definition of proximity effect, the surprising huge bass effect you get from putting your ear close to a cymbal would seem to qualify.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: dave t on September 20, 2016, 07:54:21 PM
Well I don't know, but from the definition of proximity effect, the surprising huge bass effect you get from putting your ear close to a cymbal would seem to qualify.

No, that's not the same thing at all. The proximity effect that has been talked about in this thread is specific to the way that mikes are designed and is not comparable to the way that our ears work.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 20, 2016, 09:24:54 PM
Well, if so, are you also saying that the cymbal effect doesn't exist, or that baffles have no effect?
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: dave t on September 20, 2016, 10:29:31 PM
No. I'm just saying that you are equating two things that are completely different.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 21, 2016, 08:36:27 AM
Well, it may well be a nomenclature matter, but that does not mean that the source effect I thought I was referring to doesn't exist.  Put an ear next to a cymbal, and the dominant frequencies you hear are considerably different, and surely have a straightforward physical explanation to do with the baffle effect (or lack of it), nothing to do with a microphone.  Melodeons have imperfect baffles too, and are therefore bound to exhibit this effect.

Something has always troubled me about the usual explanation of the overall effect as being caused by microphone design:

Take a single low frequency sound wave, in air at atmospheric pressure.  At any one point, it can have only two features in that sound wave which a microphone (any microphone) can sense - direction of travel, and amplitude.  The microphone is not intelligent, and has no other senses.  There is therefore absolutely no way that it can tell how far away the sound source is.  It cannot possibly distinguish between two sounds with the same frequency, same direction of travel, same amplitude, at its point of location, and will therefore produce the same electrical signal for each.  One source could be a loudspeaker 2m. away, the other could be a small source 2cm away.  How can the microphone (indeed any microphone) possibly boost the latter signal, but not the former, if it can't tell which is which?  Yet that is what the theory would require.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: dave t on September 21, 2016, 09:31:27 AM
Chris, you're making lots of incorrect assumptions. There are plenty of resources out there that clearly explain what causes the proximity effect when it comes to microphones (IanD has already posted a link to Wikipedia). If you take a look at these then it should be clear that on a directional mic the proximity of a sound source to the transducer has a direct effect on the frequency response of the output of the mic. I don't think that it's productive to keep going over this ground as it's already been well covered by previous posters on the thread.

Thanks, Dave
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Anahata on September 21, 2016, 10:03:00 AM
Take a single low frequency sound wave, in air at atmospheric pressure.  At any one point, it can have only two features in that sound wave which a microphone (any microphone) can sense - direction of travel, and amplitude.

A better way to characterise this would be pressure and velocity, and then it starts making more sense.
Microphones do respond differently to these depending on pattern.
An omnidirectional mic responds purely to pressure.
A figure-of-eight mic responds purely to velocity (note important difference: waveform is precisely inverted when you turn the mic round so you are playing into the "back" of it)
Cardioid mics respond to both and are designed so that from behind the mic, the pressure and velocity components are equal and opposite, so they cancel.
Hypercardioid are like cardioid with the velocity component having slightly more influence.

Now, the balance between pressure and velocity components starts changing with frequency when you get close to a sound source, in such a way that a pressure-responding mic (omni) retains a reasonably flat response, while a velocity mic (fig-8 or cardiod) gets that bass boost we call proximity effect.

IanD hinted at the physics behind this when he mentioned that the sound waves close to a point source are spherical, while further away they become more planar. I'd struggle to remember the exact maths now, it's over 40 years since I last wrote formulas with div, grad and curl in them...
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: IanD on September 21, 2016, 11:20:19 AM
Well, it may well be a nomenclature matter, but that does not mean that the source effect I thought I was referring to doesn't exist.  Put an ear next to a cymbal, and the dominant frequencies you hear are considerably different, and surely have a straightforward physical explanation to do with the baffle effect (or lack of it), nothing to do with a microphone.  Melodeons have imperfect baffles too, and are therefore bound to exhibit this effect.

Something has always troubled me about the usual explanation of the overall effect as being caused by microphone design:

Take a single low frequency sound wave, in air at atmospheric pressure.  At any one point, it can have only two features in that sound wave which a microphone (any microphone) can sense - direction of travel, and amplitude.  The microphone is not intelligent, and has no other senses.  There is therefore absolutely no way that it can tell how far away the sound source is.  It cannot possibly distinguish between two sounds with the same frequency, same direction of travel, same amplitude, at its point of location, and will therefore produce the same electrical signal for each.  One source could be a loudspeaker 2m. away, the other could be a small source 2cm away.  How can the microphone (indeed any microphone) possibly boost the latter signal, but not the former, if it can't tell which is which?  Yet that is what the theory would require.

Chris, the effect you're talking about here is the "close-mic" one I referred to earlier where the sound close to some instruments (where different parts radiate different sounds) is not the same as the sound far away -- when you hit a cymbal it has a low-frequency "wobble" that you can see, which means different parts of the cymbal (across each surface, and top and bottom) generate low-frequency sounds in and out of phase with each other, but across the cymbal as a whole they all cancel out if you're a significant distance away because there's nothing to stop air moving from one side of the cymbal to the other. If you put a mic (any pattern including omni) or your ear very close to the cymbal you hear the sound radiated by one local part of it which can have bass content, as you move further away cancellation from the other parts comes in and the bass disappears.

But this is not proximity effect which has a specific and different meaning and relates to microphones. As Anahata says, the microphone *can* tell how far away the sound is by the curvature of the sound wave (pressure gradient) which is what causes proximity effect. Suggest you read up on this if you're interested, because a lot of the assertions you keep stating are wrong ;-)
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: IanD on September 21, 2016, 11:50:54 AM
Quote
Your comment about proximity effect being the problem with close micing isn't normally true, this depends on the size of the mic capsule but usually only gets significant if you get within a few inches

Which I think many such systems are, because they are trying to cut down feedback problems?

Regarding proximity effect, I don't think I was saying it's the problem per se, I was saying that compensating for it simply by eq'ing won't resolve the whole issue - are we in agreement on that point, Ian? 

I've always thought of 'proximity' effect purely as a sound phenomenon caused by the greater ability of low frequency sound waves to bend round corners and thus cancel each other out, rather than some problem with the microphone.  For example, put your ear near a cymbal!

I'm interested in your 'upwards and outwards' comment - can you explain what the 'upwards' alignment is about?  Is it something to do with keeping the sound sources well-aligned in relation to the mic axis?

Anahata, thanks for your 120 deg comment - how does this translate to a good mic'ing system, in practice?

http://www.harmonycentral.com/articles/what-you-need-to-know-about-microphone-polar-patterns

If the monitor is on the floor a few feet in front of you and you want it to be in the pattern null of a cardioid mic, you need to point the rear of the mic (the connector) at the monitor, which means the mic has to be tilted down at the connector and up at the capsule. For example, a melodeon played standing up is about 4 feet off the ground, if the the monitor is 3 feet behind the microphone, a cardioid mic a foot from the box would need to be on a low stand (about 3 foot) and tilted (about 45 degrees) to put the monitor in the pattern null and be pointing at the box. If you have a mic for each end spaced a couple of feet apart then these ideally need splaying outwards to reject the monitor, which is exactly what you don't want to pick up the instrument sound.

http://www.harmonycentral.com/articles/what-you-need-to-know-about-microphone-polar-patterns

In the same case, a supercardioid/hypercardioid (rear off-axis nulls are in different places) can be placed level on a 4 foot high stand, so the monitor is further from the mic and in the pattern null, both of which make feedback much less likely. If you have two (one for each end) maybe 3 feet apart they can still be roughly parallel to each other and keep the monitor near the null for both of them.

The same applied with a side fill (monitor on stand at ear level) -- with a super/hypercardioid it's easy to get the mic pointing at the box with the monitor around 60 degrees off-axis at the rear, it's much harder with a cardioid -- basically, the mic needs to be in a straight line between monitor and box.

Even if you're not too fussy about exact positioning, the super/hypercardioid has a much bigger rear zone with good noise rejection than the cardioid and the tighter pattern reduces wash from other instruments on the stage. The disadvantage (apart from being less common) is that proximity effect is bigger than a cardioid, so the variation in bass tip-up with distance is bigger -- this means it's more important (especially for a singer) to keep a consistent distance from the mic, either right on the windshield or a constant distance from it, and also to keep reasonably on-axis.

All this is why cardioids are usually used for vocals, and super/hypercardioids are often preferred for instruments -- though many sound guys just use the same mics for everything because it's easier...
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 22, 2016, 12:47:43 PM
I’m grateful to everyone for the advice I’ve received about microphone proximity effects.  As a result I now believe the (brief) answer to my paradox is this:  Directional microphones can indeed distinguish between a far and a very near source.  This is because they should not be considered as being located at a single point as I suggested earlier, they involve comparing the sound pressures at two points along the path of the sound wave.  As Ian (and Anahata) observe, the path of that wave between these points is not planar at close distances to the source, and this difference affects low frequencies particularly.  There isn’t just a phase change in the wave as it travels between the two points, there’s an amplitude change as well, if it’s close to the source.  This affects the microphone’s response by ‘tipping up’ the bass.

There still seems to me to be a different issue regarding the 'cymbal' effect, but the point of this technical discussion for the purposes of this thread was originally that there are potential issues to do with siting microphones close to sources, and I think everyone agrees on that, so hopefully that's the main point?

I thought it might be helpful to move on, and to try to get to the stage of us agreeing a sort of guide of useful things to consider?  I don’t expect this to be easy, but can I throw this out for comments, with some trepidation?:

1.   When considering how to mic up a box to play live, a player or sound engineer is faced with various difficulties.  These difficulties result from the multiple sources of the sound, and from the fact that the sources on the LH side are constantly moving from side to side.

2.   It is well worth while as a player experimenting with your equipment, and discussing the issues with your sound engineer if you have a regular arrangement with one.

3.   The aim of the experiments should be to achieve a compromise that suits you as a player, and achieves a strong enough and realistic signal through the system covering the whole box evenly, without being prone to feedback problems.

4.   The first thing to decide is whether you as a player want to move around onstage while playing, as free-standing mics will not be an option if so.

5.   Different types of microphones exhibit very different characteristics.  Although microphones need to be of sufficient intrinsic quality to deliver a realistic and even full-range sound, that is by no means the end of the story.  Buying an expensive microphone but not using it appropriately will not work.

6.   The options available for you to try are:

a.   Mic up the RHS only.  This cuts down the spread of sound sources used, which reduces the mic’ing problems.  Some players (for example some semitone box players) do not use the LHS, or feel that in a band where other members  are providing the accompaniment, ‘RH only’ gives the best sound overall.  For players of smaller accordions, it can also avoid the clash of accompaniments which are an inevitable result of playing an intrinsically limited instrument.

b.   Try a full close-mic’ing system with two or more mics.  The main issues to experiment with here are:

i.   Microphone positioning, to achieve reasonably even coverage of the sound sources, but without unacceptable loss of signal.
ii.   The evenness in response of small mics.
iii.   Assessment of the effect of sources at different distances, off-axis to different extents.
iv.   Orientation of the close mics so that a ‘null’ region (for all frequencies) is presented to the monitor by all mics (where using floor monitors).
v.   Appropriate eq’ing if ‘proximity’ effects occur.
vi.   Balance between the LH and RH sides.
vii.   Stability, weight and fixing of the mics.
viii.   Easy and quiet changeover between boxes if necessary.
ix.   Consideration of what happens to mic positions and orientation when you put the box down.

c.   Try a two-mic free-standing system.  This can offer cost savings over specialist close-mic’ing systems, and you can use larger high quality mics with more specific ‘null’ areas.  Because they are static, the null area does not need to be as wide, provided the mics are appropriately positioned in relation to the floor monitor.   Changing instruments is not a problem.  Experiment with the following:

i.   Microphone positioning, to achieve reasonably even coverage of the sound sources over the normal bellows extensions you use, but without unacceptable loss of signal.
ii.   Assessment of the effect of sources at different distances, off-axis to different extents.  It should be possible to site the mics further away than with the close mic system without feedback problems arising, so these effects may be less.
iii.   Appropriate eq’ing if ‘proximity’ effects occur (less likely than with close-mic’ing).
iv.   Balance between the LH and RH sides.
v.   For free-standing cardioid mics, first try aligning them both pointing diametrically away from the monitor, pointing to the mid-point of the RH side, and the mid-point of normal bellows travel on the LHS, with both mics around 20cm away.  Check that the LH movement is such that the sound is even for your playing style (This is a potential benefit of this system, since the bellows movement is likely to be across the front of the microphone.)
vi.   For free-standing supercardioid or hypercardioid mikes, try aligning them level on a stand at 1.2m height, so the monitor is further from the mic and in the pattern null, both of which make feedback much less likely. Try them maybe 0.9m feet apart they can still be roughly parallel to each other and keep the monitor near the null for both of them (120 degrees off axis).  (Suggested displacement from box, anyone? And is it a good idea to sit a bit sideways?)

d.   Try a combination of b) and c), using the close mic on the LHS.  This will have a combination of the same considerations as above.  This has the potential benefit of the LH microphone’s distance from the source being constant, though that may not be a completely natural sound.

Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on September 22, 2016, 03:31:44 PM
OK, interesting discussion here. You were never alone, I have been following it :-)

You can experiment and play around with PA equipment in your front room/basement/garage/co-op hall or whatever but in the end it is practical application that wins. You will familiarise yourself with the equipment and maybe learn some stupid things not to do, which are both very good, but you will absolutely not come up with a solution that fits all (or even most) situations.

This summer we played at the "Other Place" theatre in Stratford-upon-Avon. We had a really weird feedback, it wasn't making any sense. The Theatre is one of those that they call a "black box" space, and with the seats packed away it was resonating like anything. Then, I realised that the floor was wooden and it was the bass bins sending vibrations through the floor and up the microphone stands. Turned the bass bins right down, and hey presto, no bass bins to speak of but also no feedback. We then removed the crossover and ran on the top speakers.

If you are playing out in a marquee in the middle of a field, the PA setup is different again. EQing is different, the bass requirements are different, foldback sounds quite different to being in a room. Playing with a proscenium arch in a "proper theatre" is a very different experience to a noisy club, large pub room or hotel function room.

Familiarity with your PA equipment will give you a good chance to deal with these different situations, but in the end, it's also why we employ a sound engineer for many gigs where we use our own PA.

I've experimented with my own stage setup over the years. With the wise words of people like Ian Dedic, I've tried over several periods to use clipons on the left hand end. However, I've always come back to a two stand microphone setup for mainly practical reasons.

I use at least two, lately three, melodeons on stage, and also a whistle microphone. My main problems with clipons have been - keeping them on the instrument, mechanical and movement noise, transferring them between instruments.

Keeping them on the instrument. The only practical place has been to clip them onto the left hand strap. However, none of the clips that I have used have been particularly good at this. The solution is a bit of gaffer tape, but this in also increases the problem of transferring the microphone to another instrument.

Mechanical and movement noise. Whatever I've done, I've not solved mechanical noise. I've found that some microphones are better than others, but they all exhibit this issue. Movement noise happens with them waving around and, even with gaffer tape, not being all that well seated. Other movement noise include putting down the instrument, picking up the instrument and when sliping your hand into the left hand strap.

Transferring them between instruments. Getting more clipons would seem to be a solution here. However, it brings its own problems. Who is responsible for turning microphones off and on? I'm likely to have two instruments at my feet, both with live microphones. I could try with silent switches, but, quite honestly, three boxes, three clipon microphones and their wires (and melodeon treble mic and a whistle mic), then three silent switches ... good grief. I've enough to think about with the tunes, which box to play etc without being constantly distracted by thinking about and dealing with microphones and their switches.

OK, so have only one clipon and a silent switch. Well, I'm still faffing around changing over the microphone at least six times in a 40 minute set. Sorry, but that's just not a thing to endure, for me, the other musicians or the audience.

So, what do I use and what impact does it have on the sound? Recently I've been using two Shure Beta 57A microphones on short stands. These are super-cardioid, so they have very good side rejection of noise. Oh, and I always sit down.

The right-hand mic points straight at the centre of the grill (ie. across stage), about 6 to 8 inches away.

The left-hand mic I place slightly lower, about 30 degrees from straight (see above), pointing slightly upwards a bit forward of the other mic. It sits about 6 to 8 inches away (to the left) from my usual starting point with the bellows. Theoretically I could hit the left-hand mic with my bass end, but never have.

This is a nice simple arrangement, fewer things to go wrong, and no constant fiddling and resetting.

Do I get enough bass? The answer is definitely yes.

The only "control" I take over sound engineers is that I bring my own stands and microphones. This prevents me having strange drums mics waved at me (will this be alright?), tall wobbly vocal stands used, bass drum mic and stand pulled out and proffered to me or the variety of other strange things purporting to be microphones. On two occasions has this been any sort of issue (both at the same venue), where they preferred to use their own rather expensive condenser microphones. These were eminently suitable, so I was very happy to use them.

With sound engineers who have less experience of melodeons, the issue has often been getting them to turn the bass end down.

One interesting experience this summer was playing at the Beautiful Days Festival, where they gave me my own personal monitor wedge, with my own mix (oh, the luxury). It was just in front of me to the left and angled towards me. This put my left-hand mic right in the firing line (2 or three feet away), but angled with monitor to its side and slightly behind. It also meant my right-hand mic wasn't exactly facing away from the monitor, though not pointing anything like straight at it.

None of this was an issue. I could hear myself clearly and got a great mix, no feedback, and plenty of bass. This was a highly experienced sound crew (lead by a woman; I only mention this because it is so unusual and there should be more) who work with the Levellers. They were confident and knew what they were doing, we had a good long setup time in the morning (another luxury in itself), and we trusted them to get it right. The sound crew make more than technical differences to how a performance goes.

Micing in studios is a very different proposition. I'd never take stage microphones to a studio, it would be pointless. My experience has been a couple of nice  condenser mics placed further away than you'd use on a stage. Say, 2 or three feet away at each end, pointing in at about a 45 or so degree angle from a foot or so above the instrument. I wouldn't ever expect to see a crossed pair in a studio for a multi-track recording.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 22, 2016, 04:25:32 PM
Andrew, what an excellent and frank contribution! - I'm indebted to you.

The Shure 57A supercardioid mic polar diagrams seem to indicate that the 120 deg off-axis alignment would be best for your requirements, and it sounds like you've reached much the same conclusion?  I hoped that people would add their experiences to the idea of a guidance document - are there words you would like to add to it, or amend?  It sounds like you've had particular experience of the practical issues of close mic'ing solutions, and could usefully add some guidance on supercardioid double free-standers.

I related particularly to your discussion about 'faffing around', because I've found just the same issues.  It's so important to have a system that doesn't make demands on your time onstage, because there's so little of it available.  On that point, I've recently taken to bringing along an adjustable office chair to gigs.  The reasons are three-fold: It's adjustable to exactly the right height to play comfortably, I can lean back between playing and relax my back muscles, and when I want to change boxes or whatever, I simply slide back on the rubber castors, which avoids mechanical noises.  (Sorry, I digress!)
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: IanD on September 23, 2016, 04:43:40 PM
There's a lot of excellent advice in all the last few posts :-)

The choice between stand mics and clip-ons is a personal one, both can work well when used properly under the right circumstances. Personally I haven't had any problems swapping bass-end clip-ons between boxes, but then I don't need to do it very often -- and also I move the bellows around a lot when playing and like a fair bit of bass end in the monitors, so for me it's a better solution than a stand mic. Chris prefers a stand mic because he swaps a lot more often, has had problems keeping a clip-on attached, and (maybe...) doesn't move so much as I do or want as much bass end in the monitors -- again, it's horses for courses. When mixing I've had more feedback and varying volume problems (not always!) with bass end stand mics, which is why I prefer a clip-on.

Andrew's studio experience agrees with mine, except the bass end mic was placed below the level of the box and the treble one above it because that's the way the box points when I play it (with one strap, standing up -- Chris, do you play sitting down?) -- again, different positions may suit other people, that's the job of the sound engineer to decide.

Andrew, I'd say that if you're using a stand mic 6-8 inches is a bit close for a normal-sized melodeon, especially with a supercardioid mic with a tighter pattern, because this puts the top and bottom notes well off-axis and also further from the microphone -- you might not notice so much when playing, but when mixing and listening to FOH this makes for quite a big volume difference across the keyboard. I normally put the mic 10-12 inches away -- you might think this doesn't make much difference but it does, and I've never had feedback problems doing this since a melodeon is a pretty loud instrument. Or mine is, anyway...
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 24, 2016, 09:37:16 AM
Ian, you're right about my playing style, I always sit down (though I once experimented with standing with my right leg on a stack of cases), and I think that I probably don't expand the bellows so much as most people I've seen.  This is not because I play more quietly, it's because the playing style I've developed with my big boxes uses reversals of RH notes and LH chords extensively, not only for variety in dynamic effect, but to cut down on bellows extensions deliberately.  There's various benefits from this, I find: a) this microphone location issue; b) having a smaller volume of air to compress and expand requires less pronounced changes in direction to generate the necessary pressure to drive the reeds, so it tends to give more attack when playing;  c) it's easier on the arms.  An example of this for me is the Atholl Highlanders tune in A (on a DGAcc box) - I used to find that almost unplayable until I learned to re-finger my playing to use the push LH bass A chord to bring those bellows back in.

I found when I did my sub-mixer experiment that the LH mic positioning issue was probably the most instructive part of it.  I was listening closely to the effect of normal bellows extension on LH sound level, and was relieved to note that with my system it really didn't vary noticeably over my normal range of bellows extensions. (And there's a little trick - when you do need to open them a lot, you can afford to lean over to the right a bit without losing RH mic signal much.)  I agree that a useful starting point for such an experiment with my type of mics would be to have the LH mic (possibly RH too) in the range 20-30cm away. Would anyone like to suggest a good figure for other types of mic? 

Something else I've learned is to make sure to resist the temptation to approach the microphone to 'compensate' when the audience noise gets loud - that just makes it worse for everyone!
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Hasse on September 25, 2016, 08:00:23 PM
Really interesting thread! Thanks!! (:)

I quite agree that musicians should have at least some understanding of mic placements for their instruments.  However in my experience the good sound engineers already know more about this than I do, while the bad ones think they do and won't be told.
True! Though too often I end up using the sound techs knowledge as an "excuse" when I have not prepare myself enough before an amplified gig. :-[ I know with one sound-tech that after  initial short sound check everything seemed perfect, but after two tunes in the program I go 2-voice, and you should see his surprised face...

I also remember the sound tech at work once mentioned to me, (when I inquired about strap-on swan neck microphones), that he didn't always find them appropriate on certain instruments, especially if the musician couldn't set them up properly because the mechanic noise from the instrument came through to powerful and was hard to eliminate. Though I think he probably was adressing one of my older tubas with Hohner like sound coming from the valves... this made me thinking about certain melodeons. Maybe Chris’ idea in the beginning of this thread could help the sound tech and musician eliminate that aspect better? Or am I misunderstanding somethings?
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Hasse on September 26, 2016, 06:52:00 PM
I just reread my post and see I desperately need to clarify a thing or two to make it understandable!!!  :P

So I just tried something else.  I've bought myself a sub-mixer for my personal use.  They're ridiculously cheap these days, about £70 in my case for a Behringer Xenyx 1202.  Most people would only need a cheaper mixer with few channels, but I play various instruments, so I bought a 12 channel model.  I plugged my (Samson Q1) mics in, turned on the phantom power to make them work and used some noise-cancelling headphones into the mixer output to listen directly to the sound the audience would hear.

I was really only wondering if Chris’ idea with the sub-mixer would be a way to reduce the mechanical noise many instruments produce - before the sound reaches the sound technician/engineer. Or are Chris’ idea with the sub-mixer a way of excluding the sound engineers tangling with the sound?  ???

EDIT: removed more unnecessary text!!!
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 26, 2016, 07:24:48 PM
Quote
Or are Chris’ idea with the sub-mixer a way of excluding the sound engineers tangling with the sound?  ???

Actually, not at all, in fact as Ian has pointed out, that is a disadvantage of the idea!  I see this as a way of helping sound engineers who are suddenly confronted with a complex set of problems when a box player arrives, but my original idea was simply to allow you to experiment.  There's a tendency nowadays at open mic sessions for singer/guitarists performers to arrive with their own total station, so they can sing with harmonies, play all sorts of guitar effects, use looping and so on, and yes, this can cut down set-up time and problems considerably if they know a bit about what they are doing (and most do, or they probably wouldn't be using the concept).  I don't see this direction as a bad one, I think it encourages people to think more about the sound they are giving the sound engineer, and this is all part of being a performer. 
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Hasse on September 26, 2016, 07:45:14 PM
OK, Thanks! Now I actually think I get it  (:)

But would this kind of sub-mixer be flexible enough when playing several different melodeon and maybe even a concertina on the same mic, or is this concept more suited for one melodeon only? I really got to look into this!!

Thanks for bringing new interesting sound technicalities up to the attention for slow ones like me!  ;D
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 27, 2016, 12:36:08 AM
Well, the sub mixer is just a tool to combine your signals.  I'm not sure what question you're asking, but it seems to me that learning by experimentation might be just what you are after.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Howard Jones on September 27, 2016, 02:04:49 PM
As I mentioned above, I play melodeon, anglo concertina, vocal/recorder mic and hammered dulcimer. I don't find stand mics work well for both the melodeon and anglo.  For this and other reasons I prefer to use clip-on mics through a sub-mixer.  The instruments all have separate mics, which are combined into 2 channels to send to the main mixer. 

The reason for this is not so much to reduce the number of channels I use on the main desk but so I can mute the channels I'm not using - as I often change instruments mid-set this puts me in control, rather than putting the burden on the sound engineer who has other things to think about (including playing an instrument himself or calling the dances). I don't mess about with the EQ or levels unless the soundie tells me to.

Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 27, 2016, 03:06:25 PM
I realise that in the guide, we haven't really covered the use of a sub-mixer.  I wondered Howard if you'd like to contribute some words, for comments?  I'm guessing you've preset the various channel pairs for each instrument on the sub-mixer - do you have LH and RH on each box as separate LH and RH channels, or do you pan both of them to both LH and RH to get a more realistic sound?
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on September 28, 2016, 12:23:40 AM
Andrew, I'd say that if you're using a stand mic 6-8 inches is a bit close for a normal-sized melodeon, especially with a supercardioid mic with a tighter pattern, because this puts the top and bottom notes well off-axis and also further from the microphone -- you might not notice so much when playing, but when mixing and listening to FOH this makes for quite a big volume difference across the keyboard. I normally put the mic 10-12 inches away -- you might think this doesn't make much difference but it does, and I've never had feedback problems doing this since a melodeon is a pretty loud instrument. Or mine is, anyway...

With that in mind I checked last night where I normally set the microphone whilst playing live, and it was about 8 1/2 inches away. Now, Shure say what they refer to as the "polar response pattern coverage" or "coverage angle" on the Supercardioid microphones is 115°. I did an easy check using a 90° angle and it easily covers much more than the end of my 2 row boxes (they're both little, ie. Baffetti "Black Pearl" and an Excelsior 3 voice hardly any bigger). I do back off a bit with the one row since it is louder and bigger. I sit down and keep the right hand end of the box very steady.

I could back off a bit more, but it's always a trade off with other factors and I don't think there's a problem.

However ... interestingly, Shure says that its cardioid microphones have a coverage angle of 131°, how's this for microphone technique .

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yk5ErIW4r4c

Sharron Shannon always seems to be right up against the microphone (in fact so close that it's actually bumping against the grill in that video). When I've seen her live I've wondered about this, but it doesn't appear to be an issue. Looking at various videos she also seems to use two standard vocal mics, often an SM58s by the looks of it but it varies to the extent that I'd suspect that she just asks for vocal mics. and uses whatever is there. Also the left-hand mic is quite a long way off; which also seems to be standard. eg.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QtPx_TwgGsc

Maybe let's not worry so much, stick the mics where they feel comfortable and don't feed back, forget them and get on with playing  :-)
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 28, 2016, 10:34:51 AM
Yes, in the second clip that RH mic does seem quite close, and also on the first clip its alignment in relation to the monitor is only just into the null area if it's an SM58 - and looking at Shure's polar diagram, watch out for 125Hz feedback!  I'm also a bit surprised about the LH position, because if that's the same mic, placing it so that the bellows movement crosses the axis rather than being in line with it would appear to offer a more even sound, particularly with that 131 deg. coverage.

However, I guess the answers lie in Sharon's (phenomenal!) playing style, with her very much leading the sound of the band with the treble, and mainly RH end.  She probably doesn't really need much in the monitor, and maybe the LH mic perhaps doesn't get a lot to do?
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Howard Jones on September 28, 2016, 11:03:07 PM
I realise that in the guide, we haven't really covered the use of a sub-mixer.  I wondered Howard if you'd like to contribute some words, for comments?  I'm guessing you've preset the various channel pairs for each instrument on the sub-mixer - do you have LH and RH on each box as separate LH and RH channels, or do you pan both of them to both LH and RH to get a more realistic sound?

Both melodeon channels are panned hard one way while anglo, dulcimer and vocal are all panned the other, so one channel is "melodeon" and the other is "everything else".  EQ is already set on the sub-mixer for each channel, and I leave that alone unless instructed otherwise by the sound engineer during the sound check (I know my place).

It works well for the way we work. Admittedly the soundie doesn't have full control over the individual instruments, but levels and EQ can still be adjusted at the sub-mixer (and if necessary he can just lean over and reach it himself).  On the plus side, it gives him one less thing to worry about when I change instruments (as well as sound he will probably either be playing bass or keyboard, or calling the dance) as I can mute or turn on channels myself.

I don't use it much now we've gone digital, it's all done through a tablet instead, and I don't use it when we have the luxury of a dedicated sound engineer, but I still get it out whenever we use a self-drive analogue desk.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 29, 2016, 12:55:47 PM
That sounds like a very good plan, Howard.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Rob2Hook on September 29, 2016, 04:52:57 PM
I've never seen Ms Shannon touch a bass button - and that's not a criticism, just an observation.  I suspect the "LH mic" just happened to be there for another turn!  In the second link you might notice there is only one mic.

Rob.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Theo on September 29, 2016, 05:35:58 PM
I've never seen Ms Shannon touch a bass button - and that's not a criticism, just an observation.  I suspect the "LH mic" just happened to be there for another turn!  In the second link you might notice there is only one mic.

Rob.

If this is the one you mean by the second link https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QtPx_TwgGsc  then there are two mic's and she does clearly play the bass.   There is a close shot if fingers playing the bass, and the bass sound is just audible.  For example between 1.00 and 1.10
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Rob2Hook on September 30, 2016, 06:19:05 PM
Yep, you're right Theo!  I had another two goes before I managed to get rid of obstructive adverts over the picture and lo - there was the mic and the momentary bass.  Must admit, I'm glad you corrected me.  I've long admired Ms Shannon and her playing, but rarely see her without a large band backing her - or maybe they feel just as honoured to be invited to play along as we would be...

Rob.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: IanD on October 01, 2016, 04:39:36 PM
I realise that in the guide, we haven't really covered the use of a sub-mixer.  I wondered Howard if you'd like to contribute some words, for comments?  I'm guessing you've preset the various channel pairs for each instrument on the sub-mixer - do you have LH and RH on each box as separate LH and RH channels, or do you pan both of them to both LH and RH to get a more realistic sound?

If you do a stereo sub-mix with all the RH panned into one channel and all the LH panned into another and give a two-channel output to the PA, then at least the sound engineer can deal with the two hands separately, which is the big problem with a single channel output.

How he then pans them into FOH is his choice -- some engineers put everything centre stage (effectively mono FOH) so at least the balance is consistent across the hall even if you're close to one speaker, other pan instruments apart to separate them at the cost of an unbalanced sound if you're near to one speaker.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: IanD on October 01, 2016, 04:51:52 PM
Ian, you're right about my playing style, I always sit down (though I once experimented with standing with my right leg on a stack of cases), and I think that I probably don't expand the bellows so much as most people I've seen.  This is not because I play more quietly, it's because the playing style I've developed with my big boxes uses reversals of RH notes and LH chords extensively, not only for variety in dynamic effect, but to cut down on bellows extensions deliberately.  There's various benefits from this, I find: a) this microphone location issue; b) having a smaller volume of air to compress and expand requires less pronounced changes in direction to generate the necessary pressure to drive the reeds, so it tends to give more attack when playing;  c) it's easier on the arms.  An example of this for me is the Atholl Highlanders tune in A (on a DGAcc box) - I used to find that almost unplayable until I learned to re-finger my playing to use the push LH bass A chord to bring those bellows back in.

I found when I did my sub-mixer experiment that the LH mic positioning issue was probably the most instructive part of it.  I was listening closely to the effect of normal bellows extension on LH sound level, and was relieved to note that with my system it really didn't vary noticeably over my normal range of bellows extensions. (And there's a little trick - when you do need to open them a lot, you can afford to lean over to the right a bit without losing RH mic signal much.)  I agree that a useful starting point for such an experiment with my type of mics would be to have the LH mic (possibly RH too) in the range 20-30cm away. Would anyone like to suggest a good figure for other types of mic? 

Something else I've learned is to make sure to resist the temptation to approach the microphone to 'compensate' when the audience noise gets loud - that just makes it worse for everyone!

All of which explains why you find a LH stand mic works for you, and I say it often doesn't -- most box players nowadays play standing up and move the left hand end around a lot more than you do, both side to side and back to front, which makes for big volume changes unless the mic is a lot further away than you suggest, which means feedback problems. Of course if the box player doesn't use the bass end much this is much less important, but to me it seems a waste not to use what the instrument has...

For any type of mic with any instrument, the best rough "rule of thumb" (if possible) is to make the spacing from mic to instrument about the same as the size/width of the bits of the instrument that radiate sound -- this is roughly where the sound changes from "near-field" (different sound from different bits of the instrument) to "far-field" (blended sound from all the bits which is what you hear acoustically as an audience), and also where the pickup pattern of the microphone will be reasonably even.

If you move the box closer to the mic to get more volume then the middle notes get louder more than the low and high notes, which is not helpful -- the correct response is either to play harder or to turn up the box (or the whole band) in the mix.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: IanD on October 01, 2016, 05:05:03 PM
Andrew, I'd say that if you're using a stand mic 6-8 inches is a bit close for a normal-sized melodeon, especially with a supercardioid mic with a tighter pattern, because this puts the top and bottom notes well off-axis and also further from the microphone -- you might not notice so much when playing, but when mixing and listening to FOH this makes for quite a big volume difference across the keyboard. I normally put the mic 10-12 inches away -- you might think this doesn't make much difference but it does, and I've never had feedback problems doing this since a melodeon is a pretty loud instrument. Or mine is, anyway...

With that in mind I checked last night where I normally set the microphone whilst playing live, and it was about 8 1/2 inches away. Now, Shure say what they refer to as the "polar response pattern coverage" or "coverage angle" on the Supercardioid microphones is 115°. I did an easy check using a 90° angle and it easily covers much more than the end of my 2 row boxes (they're both little, ie. Baffetti "Black Pearl" and an Excelsior 3 voice hardly any bigger). I do back off a bit with the one row since it is louder and bigger. I sit down and keep the right hand end of the box very steady.

I could back off a bit more, but it's always a trade off with other factors and I don't think there's a problem.

However ... interestingly, Shure says that its cardioid microphones have a coverage angle of 131°, how's this for microphone technique .

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yk5ErIW4r4c

Sharron Shannon always seems to be right up against the microphone (in fact so close that it's actually bumping against the grill in that video). When I've seen her live I've wondered about this, but it doesn't appear to be an issue. Looking at various videos she also seems to use two standard vocal mics, often an SM58s by the looks of it but it varies to the extent that I'd suspect that she just asks for vocal mics. and uses whatever is there. Also the left-hand mic is quite a long way off; which also seems to be standard. eg.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QtPx_TwgGsc

Maybe let's not worry so much, stick the mics where they feel comfortable and don't feed back, forget them and get on with playing  :-)

All the "coverage angle" numbers for microphones are just that, they're where the response falls off noticeably, I expect by 3dB -- which doesn't sound a lot but it's noticeable, moving an instrument up in the mix by 3dB makes a big difference to the balance. Also remember that this is for sound sources at a constant distance, which is not the case with a melodeon unless it's curved into a circle. If you follow the "coverage angle" advice the high and low notes are also significantly further away from the mic than the middle notes, which makes another 3dB or so difference. Now the mid notes are 6dB louder than the high and low notes, which is a huge difference, and they disappear under the sound of the rest of the band.

So if you stick the mics where they feel comfortable (probably too close...) and carry on playing, don't be surprised if you get frowns from the sound guy (assuming he knows what a melodeon is supposed to sound like), or even complaints from the audience (if they're listening...) that they can't always hear the tune you're playing.

If you and/or the sound guy don't really care about getting the best sound from your box, please feel free to put the mic too close and stop worrying about it. Speaking as a box player and sound guy who does care (and understands the acoustics of musical instruments), I wouldn't do this ;-)

Don't forget that even famous box players maybe haven't thought about this, or been told about it by a sound guy brave enough to tell them otherwise -- and if you listen to those videos, the tune drops considerably in volume when she moves away from the middle of the keyboard, and I'm sure the box doesn't do that. Not so bad if you're solo or playing with one other instrument like she is, do that in a band when you're leading the tune and it disappears...

If you don't believe me there's a simple way to prove it. Put one mic as close to the RH end as you think is good (say 6 inches) and another identical one at least a couple of feet away, preferably three -- like they do in a studio. Pan one hard left and the other hard right in the mixer, and set the channel gains so the levels are the same in both channels for the middle notes. Now put on a pair of headphones and play up and down the keyboard and listen how much the low and high notes move towards the distant mic channel, and watch how much the meter levels differ by.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on October 02, 2016, 08:19:29 AM
Ian, I'd agree with pretty much everything you've said here.  I think your implication that a lot of players are not getting the best sounds is important.   Do you want to translate your wise words into additions or amendments to my suggested guidance note?
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: IanD on October 02, 2016, 01:47:37 PM
Ian, I'd agree with pretty much everything you've said here.  I think your implication that a lot of players are not getting the best sounds is important.   Do you want to translate your wise words into additions or amendments to my suggested guidance note?

Just not to put the mic too close :-)

If anyone wants the numbers, for a cardioid mic the loss in level at the ends of the box compared to the middle due to inverse square law (this is the bigger effect) and mic pattern vs. distance are as follows (box height=1 e.g. 10" for a typical 2-row -- more exactly, the length of the row of pallets) -- since this is the distance from the pallets to the mic capsule, the mic touching the grille probably means about an inch effective spacing.

Also bear in mind that nobody keeps a box completely stationary, you need to assume it'll move at least an inch or so either way while being played -- for example with the mic 6" from the grille this gives another 1.3dB variation in level (for all reeds), and this increase rapidly as distance decreases. The figures in brackets have this variation added to the along-the-box variation.

0.1 : 18.6dB -- mic touching grille
0.2 : 11.9dB (22.3dB with +/-0.1 movement)
0.3 : 8.2dB (14.2dB)
0.4 : 5.9dB (9.7dB) -- mic 3" away from grille
0.5 : 4.4dB (7.1dB)
0.5 : 3.4dB (5.2dB)
0.7 : 2.6dB (3.9dB) -- mic 6" away from grille
0.8 : 2.1dB (3.0dB)
0.9 : 1.7dB (2.4dB)
1.0 : 1.4dB (1.9dB) -- mic 9" away from grille <== recommended minimum distance for a treble end stand mic on a melodeon
1.1 : 1.2dB (1.6dB)
1.2 : 1.0dB (1.3dB)
1.3 : 0.9dB (1.1dB) -- mic 1 foot away from grille

When mixing and trying to balance the volume of pairs of instruments (e.g two boxes, two fiddles, fiddle and box) playing simultaneously, I find that a 2dB change in level makes a noticeable difference, moving one from being the quieter of the two to the louder. All this suggests that it's best not to have the mic closer than about 9" from the grille of a normal-sized melodeon, and a little further wouldn't hurt if using a closer pattern mic than a cardioid -- though this doesn't make so much difference, the mic pattern accounts for about 1/3 of the level difference and inverse square law about 2/3, which is why just looking at the mic pattern doesn't give the right answer.

Having never actually calculated these numbers before, I'm glad to find that they agree very closely with my earlier "rule-of-thumb" suggestion ;-)




Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Jack Humphreys on October 23, 2016, 11:29:29 AM
Thank you to all the experienced and expert contributors to this thread.  I  have a ancient microvox set and now looking to find a better alternative. Looks like Bernard Loffet's advice may be a helpful addition to the melnet discussion. 
http://www.cadb.org/res/articles/pa48micro.pdf 
http://www.cadb.org/res/articles/pa56micro.pdf

I did notice at a Leveret concert that Andy Cutting  was using two clip-on mikes.  So was Rob Harbron on his concertina. So that decision by such fine musicians can't help but influence me!
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Jack Humphreys on October 23, 2016, 12:21:52 PM
ADVICE REQUESTED on miking up....... for total novice.

I'd be grateful for advice on basics. Supposing I use  one or two AKG C156  gooseneck mikes,  what else would I need, if anything,  in order to plug in successfully to typical mixing desks? ( I've heard about  "Phantom" but no idea what this means).  On my microvox bass mike there is a battery box clipped to my belt. Anything like that needed?   Thanks in advance.

Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 23, 2016, 01:16:44 PM
ADVICE REQUESTED on miking up....... for total novice.

I'd be grateful for advice on basics. Supposing I use  one or two AKG C156  gooseneck mikes,  what else would I need, if anything,  in order to plug in successfully to typical mixing desks? ( I've heard about  "Phantom" but no idea what this means).  On my microvox bass mike there is a battery box clipped to my belt. Anything like that needed?   Thanks in advance.

If using the AKG 516 mics you will also need a B23L battery box. The mics have mini-XLR cables and plugs which plug into the mini input sockets on the battery box which also has a belt clip. The box also has separate gain controls for each input channel. The battery box has a full size XLR output socket for a cable to a mixing desk/amp.

The box contains a 9v battery to power the mics or it can be switched to phantom power mode to take power from the mixing desk/amp. Phantom power is an alternative to battery power and is supplied via the XLR cable from the mixing desk.

http://www.akg.com/pro/p/c516ml
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Jack Humphreys on October 23, 2016, 04:06:37 PM
Many thanks Steve. I've put the orders in!
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: JohnAndy on October 23, 2016, 05:23:05 PM
The AKG website says that the output from the B23L box is a 3.5mm stereo jack socket rather than an XLR output:  http://www.akg.com/pro/p/b23l (http://www.akg.com/pro/p/b23l)

As far as I understand it (which isn't very far!), a jack cable is a less desirable way of connecting to the PA than an XLR cable because the jack cable is more liable to suffer from interference.

Steve - is this correct, and if so, do you think it's a significant drawback?

Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 23, 2016, 05:58:32 PM
The AKG website says that the output from the B23L box is a 3.5mm stereo jack socket rather than an XLR output:  http://www.akg.com/pro/p/b23l (http://www.akg.com/pro/p/b23l)

As far as I understand it (which isn't very far!), a jack cable is a less desirable way of connecting to the PA than an XLR cable because the jack cable is more liable to suffer from interference.

Steve - is this correct, and if so, do you think it's a significant drawback?

Hmm... I see they must have changed the spec from the battery box I use. Not only does it now have a 3.5 mm jack output, it is now powered by 2 x AA batteries, instead of the previous 9v battery.

I will bow to others' expertise regarding the desirability or not of the jack cable vs the XLR cable, but all I can say is that I've used both on different setups and never had any problems with the jack cable. I can't imagine a prestigious manufacturer like AKG selling a duff product.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on October 23, 2016, 06:59:56 PM
According to its user manual

http://cloud.akg.com/8259/c516_manual.pdf

the C516 uses a B23L pack or a MPA V L phantom power adapter for plugging straight into a standard XLR microphone cable coming from a desk with phantom power.

http://www.akg.com/pro/p/mpavl2

To be honest, I wouldn't find the battery pack with its stereo jack connector very appealing for stage work.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Bill Young on October 23, 2016, 09:47:53 PM
It is the AKG B29L battery pack which has the XLR outputs and 9v battery. It seems to have been discontinued and replaced by B23L.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: sticky fingers on October 23, 2016, 10:44:06 PM
S-it, I think I have done 4 gigs since I started to read this thread!, keep going boys, I've not lost the will to live just yet!, still waiting for the words," Trans directional diffusion!"," sub harmonic coherence!"," Anechoic resonance!" and," fractured time alignment", I thought it was hard enough to play the box!, SF.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on October 23, 2016, 11:54:24 PM
I played at a recent gig and took Ian's advice by increasing the mic distance from around 20 cm to 23 cm or so, both ends.  Yes, it works - after compensating by slightly adjusting the volume level, I found it was indeed noticeable that the box sound was more even, and more in keeping with the other instruments, particularly the violin.  As I run our sound desk onstage, and am very used to the balance of instruments in the mix, I am well-placed to appreciate the effect of these changes.  I can only say that I am very grateful to you, Ian, for your work on this.

For those using close mic'ing systems who are querying power supply issues, don't most mixers these days allow phantom power anyway?  The unit shown doesn't seem to allow eq'ing of each channel, just relative balancing.  I notice that the DC voltage is 9 volts, which may perhaps suit these particular mics - the usual level from a desk is around 48 volts, isn't it?  Looking at the description, I noticed this:  'an ideal way to mic up an accordion'.  It seems to me that that is quite an optimistic claim!
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 24, 2016, 01:01:30 AM
It is the AKG B29L battery pack which has the XLR outputs and 9v battery. It seems to have been discontinued and replaced by B23L.
Thanks Bill, it is the B29L which I have.

I notice that the DC voltage is 9 volts, which may perhaps suit these particular mics - the usual level from a desk is around 48 volts, isn't it?
On the B29L I assume the switch for phantom power use brings in a suitable resistor to drop the voltage down to around 9v.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: IanD on October 24, 2016, 11:55:25 AM
I played at a recent gig and took Ian's advice by increasing the mic distance from around 20 cm to 23 cm or so, both ends.  Yes, it works - after compensating by slightly adjusting the volume level, I found it was indeed noticeable that the box sound was more even, and more in keeping with the other instruments, particularly the violin.  As I run our sound desk onstage, and am very used to the balance of instruments in the mix, I am well-placed to appreciate the effect of these changes.  I can only say that I am very grateful to you, Ian, for your work on this.

For those using close mic'ing systems who are querying power supply issues, don't most mixers these days allow phantom power anyway?  The unit shown doesn't seem to allow eq'ing of each channel, just relative balancing.  I notice that the DC voltage is 9 volts, which may perhaps suit these particular mics - the usual level from a desk is around 48 volts, isn't it?  Looking at the description, I noticed this:  'an ideal way to mic up an accordion'.  It seems to me that that is quite an optimistic claim!

Glad that my advice helped :-)

Most decent mixers do supply 48V phantom power, and for most good ones it's switchable individually for each channel -- if it isn't, some electret mics (e.g. clip-ons) which aren't designed to have 48V shoved up them object by dying permanently. Go on, ask me how I now this...

If the new AKG B23L battery boxes have a stereo jack output, this is better than the old B29L ones in one way (keeps the bass and treble channels separate, sound guy will be happy) but worse in another (unbalanced non-XLR output on the old ones) -- but this is easily fixed. To go into a desk with balanced XLR inputs you need a stereo-3.5mm-jack to dual-1/4"-mono-jack lead (cheap) and a dual-channel DI box (relatively cheap) -- or where PA is provided just request 2 DI boxes for inputs.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: IanD on October 24, 2016, 12:05:12 PM
Many thanks Steve. I've put the orders in!

If you're using the C516, the best position for the mounting plates is on the outer edge of the top face of the box (not the front face), with the mics aimed downwards and slightly inwards so they point at the highest-pitched reeds towards the bottom of the box (same position for bass end).

This gives good even pickup across the range; the lowest notes are closer to the mic (louder) but also off-axis (quieter) which compensates for this. On the bass end the same happens to equalise the volume from sound holes at the top and bottom of the end plate.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on October 24, 2016, 01:17:41 PM
Quote
Go on, ask me how I now this...

All right, Ian - how do you know this?
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on October 24, 2016, 01:21:01 PM
It seems to me Ian that you are suggesting a new idea here, that you can use the reduced off-axis sensitivity positively, by making the mic closer to the off-axis sound source.  So how does this work?
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: IanD on October 25, 2016, 10:55:28 AM
Quote
Go on, ask me how I now this...

All right, Ian - how do you know this?

Hilda's concertina mics... :-(
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: IanD on October 25, 2016, 11:00:05 AM
It seems to me Ian that you are suggesting a new idea here, that you can use the reduced off-axis sensitivity positively, by making the mic closer to the off-axis sound source.  So how does this work?

I don't think it's a new idea, it's kind of obvious -- at least, to me. A cardioid mic is 6dB down 90 degrees off axis, so if it's positioned so the closest reeds are 90 degrees off axis and half the distance to the mic compared to the furthest reeds which are on-axis, the volume will be the same.

Coincidentally, this is pretty much what you end up with using a mic like the C516 with a reasonably long gooseneck mounted on the top of the box -- in practice it might not be perfect, but it's *far* better than having it mounted on the front on the box and re-introducing the "close-mic" problem we discussed earlier.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on October 25, 2016, 11:15:03 AM
Quote
I don't think it's a new idea, it's kind of obvious -- at least, to me.

Well it's still a useful and interesting contribution to the debate!  Have you looked at the C516 polar diagrams?  I have to say that I'm unconvinced their solution actually works, but I'd be very interested to hear your thoughts on this.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Theo on October 25, 2016, 11:31:48 AM
I can confirm it's not a new idea I've used a mic mounted like this for about 15 years.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on October 25, 2016, 11:45:45 AM
OK, so how does it actually work?  I'm guessing that you're using one side of the mic, relying on the drop-off in sensitivity off-axis to try to extend the 'even response' length of the mic over the sound sources.  But surely, if you have a mic with that pattern of response, it's going to be equally responsive to sound from the other side of the mic, and therefore give you feedback problems?
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Theo on October 25, 2016, 11:46:33 AM
In practice it works well for me.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: IanD on October 25, 2016, 12:48:49 PM
Quote
I don't think it's a new idea, it's kind of obvious -- at least, to me.

Well it's still a useful and interesting contribution to the debate!  Have you looked at the C516 polar diagrams?  I have to say that I'm unconvinced their solution actually works, but I'd be very interested to hear your thoughts on this.

Yes I've looked at the polar diagram, and it's "economical with the truth" -- it looks like the curves are hand-drawn, and no mic can have a pattern with 0dB loss out to 60 degrees and 6dB at 90 degrees, it's not physically possible...
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: IanD on October 25, 2016, 12:50:28 PM
OK, so how does it actually work?  I'm guessing that you're using one side of the mic, relying on the drop-off in sensitivity off-axis to try to extend the 'even response' length of the mic over the sound sources.  But surely, if you have a mic with that pattern of response, it's going to be equally responsive to sound from the other side of the mic, and therefore give you feedback problems?

Indeed, so you have to be careful about monitor placement as discussed earlier. There's no such think as a perfect solution...
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on October 25, 2016, 02:24:21 PM
Well, where exactly is the null area supposed to be?  The high frequency 180 deg off-axis attenuation is not good.  So is careful monitor placement going to help you much?  I suspect the only answer with this system is going to be to turn down the foldback level for the box in the monitor, and just rely on the player hearing it acoustically.  All very well if you have the luxury of separate mixes for different monitors, and the time to set them up.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Anahata on October 25, 2016, 05:56:57 PM
The 180° off axis attenuation should be best at mid-high frequencies; it's low frequencies where mics tend to become unidirectional (because it's hard to construct them otherwise).
That said, you are never going to get a perfect null pointing at the monitor anyway. You need to keep the amount of sound from the monitor getting in to the mic low enough to avoid feedback howls, and for best sound it should be well below that threshold. Knowing the mic's pattern helps with this, but it's not an exact science and you can't isolate the stage mics completely. The best you can do is understand all the possible paths between speaker and mic (bouncing of the wall behind the stage, or transmitted though floor vibrations, for example) and get the best compromise. In some situations you might have to turn the foldback level down to less than ideal for the player, but it entirely depends on the room acoustics, size of the stage, other instruments in the band etc. whether it will come to that.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on October 25, 2016, 06:57:44 PM
Sure, all good advice, but it was just their 'ideal' claim that raised my eyebrow.
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Anahata on October 25, 2016, 09:00:11 PM
Sure, all good advice, but it was just their 'ideal' claim that raised my eyebrow.

You're expecting too much from sales "literature"  ;)
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: Chris Brimley on October 26, 2016, 09:30:32 AM
You're right, there, Anahata!
Title: Re: The all-important interface between box and PA system
Post by: IanD on October 26, 2016, 10:22:39 PM
The 180° off axis attenuation should be best at mid-high frequencies; it's low frequencies where mics tend to become unidirectional (because it's hard to construct them otherwise).
That said, you are never going to get a perfect null pointing at the monitor anyway. You need to keep the amount of sound from the monitor getting in to the mic low enough to avoid feedback howls, and for best sound it should be well below that threshold. Knowing the mic's pattern helps with this, but it's not an exact science and you can't isolate the stage mics completely. The best you can do is understand all the possible paths between speaker and mic (bouncing of the wall behind the stage, or transmitted though floor vibrations, for example) and get the best compromise. In some situations you might have to turn the foldback level down to less than ideal for the player, but it entirely depends on the room acoustics, size of the stage, other instruments in the band etc. whether it will come to that.

Actually most cardioid mics maintain pretty good off-axis rejection down to low frequencies; if you think of them as an omni pattern superimposed on a figure-8 you can see why this should be. But as Anahata says, playing on a stage isn't an ideal acoustic situation anyway, you're not playing in an anechoic chamber -- it does help to try and get the monitor somewhere near a pattern null, but once you have reflections this isn't so clear -- and this is another reason a mic with a tighter pattern than cardioid helps, the ratio between the peak signal on-axis and the average signal from every direction (Q) is bigger, so they tend to pick up more of the instrument and less background mush.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal