Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: stevejay on September 23, 2009, 03:13:57 AM

Title: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: stevejay on September 23, 2009, 03:13:57 AM
Hi-

How big a job to improve the button action and eliminate clacking? Any how-to's out there for me to peruse?

imo the Pokerwork has the raw material to be a GREAT sounding box, and although there are fancier looking ones out there and better constructed, they're still the best bang for the buck.

Thanks! ;D
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: melodeon on September 23, 2009, 04:29:55 AM
I agree


1st  pull the bellows pins on the treble side
next remove the 2 screws that hold the key board on
Next   wiggle the keyboard off
Next on the bottom of the keyboard where the levers clack   you will need to "pad" this

You can cut a piece of leather or cork or felt to the inside length of the cavity and about 1/8th inch thick  3mm
The pad should be about 1 1/4 inches wide...  just wide enough to touch the back of the cavity nearest where your thumb rests

you can glue this in .. I use contact cement....

Once fitted  and glue dried
CAREFULLY wiggle the keyboard back over the buttins..
the bladed levers will crease the material on the way but have faith.. once it is on  it will fit without interference

Screw the fingerboard back on and reassemble the bellows to the frame


Think this out and dry fit the [parts

Perhaps Theo and others will chime in here....

Good luck

I just did another one  last week....  30 minutes   start to finish

Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 23, 2009, 08:42:24 AM
I did it (a 1986 model) much the same as melodeon. It took me about an hour ('having to explore').

Keyboard came off easily enough, and I personally used cardboard. It both stopped the rattle and raised the action a bit - so my fingers didn't go down the holes.  I'd agree in retrospect that leather would be better.

It still bafffles me why Hohner don't do do this in the factory where it'd be a trivial add on. Or the dealers even "adds value". Once you have a template it might be a 10 minute job?

Not sure about that glue. Mine didn't need it and it seems a hostage to fortune ....

(http://www.cs.uml.edu/~stu/icons/arrows/arrow_down_tiny_icon.gif) Agree with George below that a lighter touch technique obviates the need for this, but I wasn't anywhere near that at the time. Arguably stuffing the keyboard may have held me back in developing it. So there's a counter argument. I love contradicting myself! (Actually I don't) C
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: george garside on September 23, 2009, 10:43:30 AM
why not just maximise the clacking - dont press the buttons far enough to 'clack' when you don't want it & press furthur down the hole when you want free percussion!

george :-\
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Sandy on September 23, 2009, 11:49:49 AM
I quite like the clacking on my pokerwork but would rather the buttons didn't go in so far. Not so sure about the bass buttons really clacking on my saltarelle though ???

cheers
Sandy
 (:)
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: mikesamwild on September 23, 2009, 12:14:00 PM
You can wedge a padded dowel across the levers at a position to get the right height Speeds you up too
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: waltzman on September 23, 2009, 01:23:41 PM
Most of the noise my pokerwork makes is the pallets whacking against the wood 'soundboard'....especially on the bass side.  I've never had problems with the button levers slamming against the fingerboard.
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: LJC on September 23, 2009, 01:29:48 PM
For pokerworks with the Hohner one layer leather surface on the palets there is very little to absorb the impact which makes the palets click. If you reface with felt+leather glued together it gives it more dampening and helps to stop some of the racket. The clicky buttons are best cured with layers of felt beneath them.

Cut one sheet of felt to size and use it as a template for others... you can then layer up as many as you like to limit the button depth to you needs. I prefer this to the bar behind the grille method as it provides a more positive feeling action.

It's the underside of the button and leaver which touches the Morris grip thumb side of the keyboard which clacks, as opposed to the arms touching elsewhere.
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: george garside on September 23, 2009, 01:49:52 PM
For 
 which touches the Morris grip thumb side of the keyboard 

? do all pokerworks have one of these & where is it! for that matter what is the Morris grip??
george ::)
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 23, 2009, 02:16:46 PM
You can wedge a padded dowel across the levers at a position to get the right height Speeds you up too

I did this. It worked OK pro tem

I decided to leave it out as 'advice' and it didn't help the clatter much, and might concevably knock the levers or pads out of balance. My box was OK over the 6 months I did this however. I felt the 'stuffing' solution worked better
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: stevejay on September 23, 2009, 03:06:03 PM
why not just maximise the clacking - dont press the buttons far enough to 'clack' when you don't want it & press furthur down the hole when you want free percussion!

george :-\

It's not just the clacking, it's aboout the speed. Triplets and rapid runs are not as easy as they might be.

I've got great advice, but I might have a better idea once I've opened it up. I've worked on concertina action (The Bastari fix) but not melodeons. 
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Quebecois on September 23, 2009, 04:06:18 PM
One great "feature" of the Pokerwork and many other Hohner boxes is their simple construction allowing for customizations. A bit like taking a car to a speedshop to upgrade and ajust its mechanical elements.

I did these kind of fixes to an old HA112, re-surfaced the pallets, etc and it's a completely different playing experience. Same with my Corona 2, putting felt under the keyboard.
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: stevejay on September 23, 2009, 04:43:02 PM
I didn't mean a better idea than your advice, I meant a better understanding of the mechanisms in play. My above post sounded pompous ::)
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: ACE on September 23, 2009, 04:57:47 PM
Teach your missus to accompany you on the spoons, or even better on the bones. You will not worry about clacking again after you hear those.
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Gandy on September 23, 2009, 08:04:08 PM
Most of the noise my pokerwork makes is the pallets whacking against the wood 'soundboard'....especially on the bass side.  I've never had problems with the button levers slamming against the fingerboard.

Coincidentally I was just thinking about exactly the same subject, and wondering whether to post a question.

On mine the buttons have to be pushed a good 1/4" below the surface of the fingerboard board before hitting anything, but the noise comes when the buttons are released.   I did try putting something under them to reduce the travel, trouble was that if was thick enough to stop the buttons depressing below the surface, I could get the action re-assembled.   I used the "dowel-across-the-action" method for a bit, but found the levers starting to bend although I wouldn't say I was rough on the instrument.   I did like the reduced travel, but started to come to the conclusion I'd either need to leave it as-is or make a new fingerboard.

Tony S
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: an bosca ceoil on September 23, 2009, 08:05:52 PM
You can wedge a padded dowel across the levers at a position to get the right height Speeds you up too

Even better place for such a "limiter" is underneath the levers, between them and the edge of the casing.  There it is nearer the fulcrum and you can even put more packing under alternate levers to compensate for the differing lengths/button heights on each row.
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Theo on September 23, 2009, 08:15:10 PM
I've tried/seen both methods, and I don't use either.  Packing under the buttons is limited by the requirement to be able to get the buttons back into the fingerboard.  The rod across the upper levers can lead to levers being bent by a player with heavy fingers, and you tend to get a softer effect in the centre of the fingerboard as the rod flexes.  You can also get noise if the rod contacts the grill.

I'm just about to do the business on an Erica, so I'll take some photos as I go.   The method I use is not my own idea, it came from the late Richard Morse of the Button Box.  This places a strip of soft wood under the levers beneath the fingerboard.  The pictures will make it clear.
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: HallelujahAl on September 23, 2009, 08:26:15 PM
Quote
I'm just about to do the business on an Erica, so I'll take some photos as I go.   The method I use is not my own idea, it came from the late Richard Morse of the Button Box.  This places a strip of soft wood under the levers beneath the fingerboard.  The pictures will make it clear.

Would really appreciate that Theo! Thanks, AL.
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: an bosca ceoil on September 23, 2009, 09:03:20 PM

I'm just about to do the business on an Erica, so I'll take some photos as I go.   The method I use is not my own idea, it came from the late Richard Morse of the Button Box.  This places a strip of soft wood under the levers beneath the fingerboard.  The pictures will make it clear.

I suspect that we are talking about the same method here.
I have not tried either of the other ideas, forseeing the problems you mention, but did hear that it was feasible to fit felt into the keyboard by removing it and the pallets together.
Mind you I have a lot to learn, still have to find out how to fit new bushes to the treble end?
 (Ebay item 270458363808)
Regards, Bruce
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Lester on September 23, 2009, 09:16:36 PM
I've tried/seen both methods, and I don't use either.  Packing under the buttons is limited by the requirement to be able to get the buttons back into the fingerboard.  The rod across the upper levers can lead to levers being bent by a player with heavy fingers, and you tend to get a softer effect in the centre of the fingerboard as the rod flexes.  You can also get noise if the rod contacts the grill.

I'm just about to do the business on an Erica, so I'll take some photos as I go.   The method I use is not my own idea, it came from the late Richard Morse of the Button Box.  This places a strip of soft wood under the levers beneath the fingerboard.  The pictures will make it clear.

I have a Theo modded Erica and it is all you could want on clackyness and button travel. Was going to take some photos next time I met up with it* but Theo wll do it better.

*Anyone want an Erica it's in the back of my car in Terminal 3 short stay 'til late Friday but you will have to workout which car - mind you it may be the only one with baldricks on the back seat
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: LJC on September 23, 2009, 09:28:03 PM
The Morris Grip is only standard on the English made pokers you see... normally all you see is a knackered Morris man gripping the keyboard with all his might just in case a stray wind were to pick the melodeon up and blow it away. (I was meaning the behind of the keyboard which usually has a players thumb attached to it... perhaps its a southern thing to call it the Morris grip)
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Theo on September 23, 2009, 10:25:33 PM
Here are the photos (http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=109685&id=709188166&l=c564b24e38) on my facebook page.  This is a public link please let me know if you can't see them.
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: stevejay on September 23, 2009, 10:27:08 PM
So fast! I am at work, will be studying this at home. This seems "sticky worthy"
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Theo on September 23, 2009, 10:34:01 PM
but did hear that it was feasible to fit felt into the keyboard by removing it and the pallets together.

It is possible, but doing it that way gives you a lot of extra work.  You have to release all the springs, remove the screws that hold the action in which is fairly straightforward.  But once you have the felt and buttons inserted the fingerboard gets in the way and its all but impossible to get the little tiny screws back that hold the mechanism, also harder to get the screws back.  You could leave the springs in position, but that risks the spring tension tearing the screws out enlarging their holes, and you have to devise some way to compress the springs while you put the whole thing back.  Its fun! ;D

Quote

Mind you I have a lot to learn, still have to find out how to fit new bushes to the treble end?
Regards, Bruce

New bushes?  There are no bushes that I know of in the treble end. ???
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Steve C. on September 24, 2009, 12:02:38 AM
I have seen some solutions on Irish Dancemasters site:  a custom pad and two custom replacement keyboards, one with removable top.  Seems reasonably priced.
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: RGF on September 24, 2009, 01:48:08 AM
And now for something completely different:

I have installed two of the keyboards from Irish Dancemaster -- one lyre-shaped on my pressed wood Pokerwork, and one of the more modern shape on my Erica. (Both painted black to duplicate the look of the original keyboards.) I like this modification quite a lot, and these are a very nice product.

Next project in line, though, was a another honey-colored Pokerwork for a friend of mine. The original pressed wood keyboard was in quite nice condition, and she wanted to keep that, but she really liked the improvements in playability of my Dancemaster keyboards. What to do?

I put a very narrow kerf blade in my bandsaw, and carefully set up a fence that allowed me to neatly slice off the top of the keyboard, with minimal loss in dimension.  Next, I lightly sanded the sawn faces to make a nice join between them again, then drilled and countersunk some holes for tiny flathead screws to re-secure the top.  This allows for easy removal/replacement of the keyboard top, and for installation and adjustment of the felt pads. Looks neat, works well, and keeps the original parts. (Although I must admit that my heart was in my throat just a bit, doing this to someone else's instrument.)

I have only one overall photo of it that I can attach here. When I return from holiday, I'll make some photos of it disassembled, if anyone is interested.

Bob
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: stevejay on September 24, 2009, 06:02:50 AM
Looks fantastic, the srews are not too intrusive. If not for the action on these pokerworks.. guess that's why the Morgane developed? I imagine it has better action than off the shelf Pokerwork.
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: HallelujahAl on September 24, 2009, 07:22:25 AM
Quote
Here are the photos


Theo thanks so much for the pictures and description of how you limit the button travel - superb stuff and extremely helpful to a raw amateur like me!
AL
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Theo on September 24, 2009, 08:44:49 AM
Looks fantastic, the srews are not too intrusive. If not for the action on these pokerworks.. guess that's why the Morgane developed? I imagine it has better action than off the shelf Pokerwork.

Bob,  did you consider taking the back off the fingerboard?  I can think of two possible advantages, 1 - screws are out of sight, 2- back could be removed while the fingerboard is in situ to adjust the thickness of the packing.
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Gandy on September 24, 2009, 08:47:23 AM
Here are the photos (http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=109685&id=709188166&l=c564b24e38) on my facebook page.  This is a public link please let me know if you can't see them.
Brilliant!   That does it, mine's coming apart tonight.    I think my action is held with nuts and bolts, so its actually not too difficult taking it on/off with the springs tensioned.

By the way, does anyone know how much a replacement fingerboard costs?  Just the ordinary black plastic one on the Pokerwork?
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Lester on September 24, 2009, 09:05:54 AM
Here are the photos (http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=109685&id=709188166&l=c564b24e38) on my facebook page.  This is a public link please let me know if you can't see them.
Brilliant!   That does it, mine's coming apart tonight.    I think my action is held with nuts and bolts, so its actually not too difficult taking it on/off with the springs tensioned.

By the way, does anyone know how much a replacement fingerboard costs?  Just the ordinary black plastic one on the Pokerwork?

Don't know about the plastic ones but you could look here for repalcement wooden ones

http://www.irishdancemaster.com/reedtuning.html (http://www.irishdancemaster.com/reedtuning.html)
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Theo on September 24, 2009, 09:16:47 AM

By the way, does anyone know how much a replacement fingerboard costs?  Just the ordinary black plastic one on the Pokerwork?

£21.99
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: an bosca ceoil on September 24, 2009, 10:38:13 AM
Here are the photos (http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=109685&id=709188166&l=c564b24e38) on my facebook page.  This is a public link please let me know if you can't see them.
Brilliant!   That does it, mine's coming apart tonight.    I think my action is held with nuts and bolts, so its actually not too difficult taking it on/off with the springs tensioned.

If you are going to attempt the modification shown there is no reason to remove the action anyway!
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: an bosca ceoil on September 24, 2009, 11:57:22 AM
Looks neat, works well, and keeps the original parts. (Although I must admit that my heart was in my throat just a bit, doing this to someone else's instrument.)

That is a really nice job if you have the tools and, perhaps more important, the nerve to attempt it!
Have to agree with Theo that, if modifying an existing keyboard, it might be even better to take the back off, rather than replicating the Dancemaster items. I suspect that these are somewhat easier to produce  this way than with a removable back, besides following the old Hohner style.
I see that Dancemaster also offer a "bi-level" pad to go into Erica keyboards, fitted for $35. I guess that to get this in they must have to remove the action and keyboard as one, together with the "fiddly"work it involves. What has previously put me off trying this idea is the trial and error of determining the correct thickness and type of material to use. Since they seem to have already done the "development", before I ask them, do you suppose they would be prepared to supply materials only? (They advertise the keyboards as a fitted service so were they happy to supply you with the ones you fitted?)
Regards, Bruce
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: juker on September 24, 2009, 12:04:00 PM
Most of the noise my pokerwork makes is the pallets whacking against the wood 'soundboard'....especially on the bass side.  I've never had problems with the button levers slamming against the fingerboard.

Coincidentally I was just thinking about exactly the same subject, and wondering whether to post a question.

On mine the buttons have to be pushed a good 1/4" below the surface of the fingerboard board before hitting anything, but the noise comes when the buttons are released.   I did try putting something under them to reduce the travel, trouble was that if was thick enough to stop the buttons depressing below the surface, I could get the action re-assembled.   I used the "dowel-across-the-action" method for a bit, but found the levers starting to bend although I wouldn't say I was rough on the instrument.   I did like the reduced travel, but started to come to the conclusion I'd either need to leave it as-is or make a new fingerboard.

Tony S

Yes, the noise on mine comes when the buttons are released too. I didn't notice it was 'clacky' until I listened to the video of myself I made for youtube - I don't know anyone else who plays a box, so nothing to compare my sound to. Do any of these ideas improve the clackiness that comes from the buttons hitting the fingerboard? Both treble and bass buttons make a noise on my Hohner.
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Theo on September 24, 2009, 02:16:01 PM
Yes, the noise on mine comes when the buttons are released too. I didn't notice it was 'clacky' until I listened to the video of myself I made for youtube - I don't know anyone else who plays a box, so nothing to compare my sound to. Do any of these ideas improve the clackiness that comes from the buttons hitting the fingerboard? Both treble and bass buttons make a noise on my Hohner.

That noise on releasing the buttons is caused by the pallets, with thin leather facing, hitting the base board.   The solution to this is to re-face the pallets with a softer material - leather with a layer of felt underneath.  I feel another set of photos may be needed.
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: RGF on September 24, 2009, 02:32:05 PM
Theo -- Thanks for the suggestion to remove the back rather than the front.  Although the screws are quite flush and I don't mind their appearance at all, it's pretty easy to see the adjustment advantages offered by the removeable back. I suppose I was just rather automatically following the method shown by Dancemaster and some of the Hohners I've seen. Next time, I'll definitely have a look at doing it on the backside.

Bruce -- The Dancemaster keyboards that I ordered are both very nice pieces. The first one came with the bi-level felting already installed, while the second was shipped without. When I inquired why, I was told that "professional installation is recommended", but if I wished to do it at home, I could just go buy some self-stick furniture felt. So that's what I did, and it worked just fine. The felt beneath the shorter levers was secured over a very thin strip of wood (perhaps 1/32"?) in order to have both rows come to rest at the same level relative to the top of the keyboard.

At the same time, I also renewed the pallet facings, replacing the old leather with 2mm felt+suede. Pallets were removed from the rods then, and reglued so as to assure that they were flat against the board.

The bass side pallets received the same treatment, and the button holes were enlarged enough to be bushed with some suede leather. One other noise maker I found on that side was the juncture where the button rods connect to the pallet levers -- the u-bend was rather loose around the levers, and produced a little clatter with sharp taps on the buttons. I used some needle-nose pliers to very gently squeeze these u-bends down a bit, making a tighter fit with the pallet levers, and placed one drop of silicone lube at that point.

All these things, taken together, have produced what I think is a relatively quiet instrument. (Although there's not much going on around these parts to which I can compare!)

Bob
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: waltzman on September 24, 2009, 03:12:47 PM
In my experience, all of the noises a pokerwork makes are quite variable depending on your technique.  It is possible to play a pokerwork without much noise at all if you have a light touch on the buttons and if you do not let them 'pop' back upon release.  Limiting the button travel by some physical means just makes it easier to accomplish this.
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Matthew B on September 24, 2009, 03:52:19 PM
This places a strip of soft wood under the levers beneath the fingerboard.  The pictures will make it clear.

Theo, very helpful.  Thanks.  From what I see you are suggesting that sometimes just the initial pressure on the button when the wooden strip is first positioned (Image 11) will make enough of an indentation to open the pallet, and limit the button travel, if you start with the strip flush against the lever?  If the wood is that soft, doesn't the dent get bigger over time, particularly in the busy bits of the key board? Or are you cutting out a deeper slot every time?
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: melodeon on September 24, 2009, 04:24:06 PM
RGF  ,

Is it possible to post pictures of these  retrofit keyboards ?

Specifically the "lyre" shaped one ?
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: HallelujahAl on September 24, 2009, 04:49:26 PM
Theo do you apply the same process to a three row (I'm thinking of my Trichord)?
AL
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: juker on September 24, 2009, 05:45:30 PM
Yes, the noise on mine comes when the buttons are released too. I didn't notice it was 'clacky' until I listened to the video of myself I made for youtube - I don't know anyone else who plays a box, so nothing to compare my sound to. Do any of these ideas improve the clackiness that comes from the buttons hitting the fingerboard? Both treble and bass buttons make a noise on my Hohner.

That noise on releasing the buttons is caused by the pallets, with thin leather facing, hitting the base board.   The solution to this is to re-face the pallets with a softer material - leather with a layer of felt underneath.  I feel another set of photos may be needed.

Thanks, that would be excellent, if it is not too much trouble  (:)
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: RGF on September 24, 2009, 05:49:24 PM
Here is a photo of the two fingerboards I purchased from Irish Dancemaster. Very nice products, I think, and fairly priced. As shipped, they are in a natural finish on teak. I opted to spray them with a gloss black urethane to match a litle more closely the the look of the original pieces -- one wood, one plastic, but both black.

There is a photo of one in the natural teak finish here: http://www.irishdancemaster.com/reedtuning.html

The only photo I have of my removeable top modification of the pressed wood fingerboard is found in an earlier post.

Bob
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: waltzman on September 24, 2009, 09:12:59 PM
Here is a photo of the two fingerboards I purchased from Irish Dancemaster. Very nice products, I think, and fairly priced. As shipped, they are in a natural finish on teak. I opted to spray them with a gloss black urethane to match a litle more closely the the look of the original pieces -- one wood, one plastic, but both black.

There is a photo of one in the natural teak finish here: http://www.irishdancemaster.com/reedtuning.html

The only photo I have of my removeable top modification of the pressed wood fingerboard is found in an earlier post.

Bob

Did you have to modify the wooden one much for your Erica?  I put one on a Pokerwork and all it required was a little shimming to get the angle right.
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: RGF on September 24, 2009, 10:26:42 PM
The piece for the Erica was a perfect fit, just like it came from the factory.  The lyre-shaped one for the Pokerwork took the smallest amount of shimming, just a bit of cardstock between the mating faces, in order to center the buttons in the length of the slightly oblong holes.

Don't know how well it shows up in the photos, but the buttons on both these boxes are white "pearl", obtained from CGM. Put each one in a fixture on the drill press, bored a 1/8" hole on the backside, and they were a perfect press fit onto the Hohner keyrods. I think they look smart in that black fingerboard!

Bob
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: melodeon on September 25, 2009, 02:40:37 AM
Thanks RGF

If I can figure out how to post a picture

I'll show you the prototype I sent to Dancemaster..  this was following a request that I explore the possibility of producing them

I was sent a couple keyboards that were made by someoene else...
poor design  materials and workmanship  

So I made an upgraded version that would be suitable for either Erica or Pokerwork  old or new
and a  prototype needed to be fitted and another pre-production model made.
I decided not to pursue this and am still waiting for the return of my prototype.

I did not give anyone  permission to make it or have  these fingerboards  made
I believe I posted somethiong to that effect on the yahoo box group some time ago...
following information I had received  about the possibility that my design was being used.

The original agreement was that I would provide products of my own design should we mutually agree to pursue this.
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: RGF on September 25, 2009, 05:02:07 AM
Hopefully that is an issue here, as I bought both of these several years ago.
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: melodeon on September 25, 2009, 05:26:21 AM
Good to know.

Thanks
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Gandy on September 25, 2009, 08:38:31 AM
Here are the photos (http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=109685&id=709188166&l=c564b24e38) on my facebook page.  This is a public link please let me know if you can't see them.

Did mine last night using this process.  Thanks a million for the step-by-step guide, which cuts out what could have been a lot of trial and error.  I used Ramin which is what I had to hand, already in 6mm, and that's probably harder than would be ideal so I will need to do a little more filing of slots because some of the keys don't quite travel as far as I'd like.

An unexpected side effect is that the "clack" on button release is reduced, since the pallets haven't lifted so high.

Question for Theo, if you wouldn't mind ... how far do the pallets need to lift to play properly?   

Thanks again.

Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Theo on September 25, 2009, 08:44:30 AM
Question for Theo, if you wouldn't mind ... how far do the pallets need to lift to play properly?   


Not as far as you might think.  4mm to 5mm of button travel is usually ok, you may be able to use less.  If the pallets don't open far enough the note will eventually be reduced in volume, end even go flat. 
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Scallyanglo on January 04, 2010, 01:59:32 PM
I am attempting the standard 'Theo fix' as demonstrated by the facebook photos. However, is there is a difference between the Erica shown and my pokerwork? The gap between case and the lowest part of the levers is closer to 5mm i.e. the levers have square-bottomed (or 'u'-shaped) bent parts that are lower than the levers themselves.

If I've done this right - here's a link to a photo which hopefully explains what I mean!
http://cid-cd8bb8c1128a63f5.skydrive.live.com/self.aspx/Everyone/jse%5E_Pokerwork%5E_treble%5E_levers.jpg (http://cid-cd8bb8c1128a63f5.skydrive.live.com/self.aspx/Everyone/jse%5E_Pokerwork%5E_treble%5E_levers.jpg)

My question - does the softwood go under the lowest part of the lever, or just the extended bit that holds the button?
Cheers, K.
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: RGF on January 04, 2010, 02:46:42 PM
If I understand you correctly, you're refering to the square bend just at the pivot point, right? I don't think that you could pad the travel there in any truly effective way, given the tiny amount of travel at that point, vs. the leverage you have way out there at the button end.

I installed hard felt padding at the points just beneath the buttons, so the stopping effect is quite immediate and precise.

Hope I'm explaining this in an understandable way!

Bob
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Theo on January 04, 2010, 04:47:33 PM
My question - does the softwood go under the lowest part of the lever, or just the extended bit that holds the button?
Cheers, K.

I usually position the softwood strip as far near the edge of the box as possible, but ensuring I leave sufficient space for the edge of the fingerboard to fit.
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Scallyanglo on January 04, 2010, 06:14:31 PM

By the way, does anyone know how much a replacement fingerboard costs?  Just the ordinary black plastic one on the Pokerwork?

£21.99

Does this include a replacement for those flippin' awful M3 screws used in the Chinese boxes? I think I've got the wood placed correctly, and wanted to try it out before permanently fixing. However, it's really difficult to fasten the fingerboard back on, as the screwheads are not a good fit for any of my Phillips screwdrivers, and are now getting quite damaged >:( I've been out looking for alternate screws to fit, but nothing seems to match. All ideas welcome!
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Theo on January 04, 2010, 11:22:19 PM
No it does not include the screws.   I have replacement screws if you need them.  They are an improvement on the Chinese ones that Hohner use, but you still have to be very careful putting them in to align them with the holes in the fingerboard which are not at right angles to the end of the box.
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Scallyanglo on January 05, 2010, 12:38:51 AM
No it does not include the screws.   I have replacement screws if you need them.  They are an improvement on the Chinese ones that Hohner use, but you still have to be very careful putting them in to align them with the holes in the fingerboard which are not at right angles to the end of the box.

Yes! The screw holes are not at right angles and I hadn't noticed before. I now have one fine pokerwork without disappearing buttons that still has a great clacky sound. ;) Ta very much to all for the advice.
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: John C on January 07, 2010, 12:20:41 AM
I've re-read this thread but I cannot see what you are using to glue(?) the small strip of wood under the levers to reduce buttons sinking into the holes.   Can you please clarify that for me.

Thanks
John
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 07, 2010, 07:20:55 AM
I've re-read this thread but I cannot see what you are using to glue(?) the small strip of wood under the levers to reduce buttons sinking into the holes.   Can you please clarify that for me.
According to Theo's photo presentation here....
http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=109685&id=709188166&l=c564b24e38
.... he does not use glue, but the strip of wood is screwed into place lightly, just enough to stop it moving. See photos 8, 9 and 10, and read the captions.
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: John C on January 07, 2010, 01:47:05 PM
I did read the caption but I assumed the screws were temporary to hold the wood in place so you could mark the place for the indents.   

I had thought that after cutting the grooves and being satfisfied with the fit, the wood needed to be held in position and it looked like the screws were too big.   I don't want to damage the box itself and was thinking about gluing the piece in place but I realize that would make it difficult to remove the piece afterward, if it was necessary.



Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Bill the Farmer on January 07, 2010, 02:22:00 PM
I used a small smear of Bostic each end to hold the wood on my 1140. It dries into clear rubbery stuff, so should come off reasonably easily if necessary (He hopes  ;D).  :||:
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Martyn on January 07, 2010, 03:16:15 PM
 I don't want to damage the box itself and was thinking about gluing the piece in place but I realize that would make it difficult to remove the piece afterward, if it was necessary.





A strip of double sided tape should do the job and is easily removed if need be.

Martyn
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Theo on January 07, 2010, 04:33:43 PM
Screws do allow the strip to be removed easily for adjustments.
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: dee.robot on April 16, 2014, 08:25:12 AM
Hi. Have been reading this thread as I am trying to upgrade my pokerwork 4 stop one row. It has the nasty plastic keyboard and  I'm checking that the principle for reducing the travel of the buttons is the same as for the 2 row. And wondered where I can find the photos Theo spoke of. Any help much appreciated.
Regards
Dee
Title: Re: Pokerwork clacking
Post by: Theo on April 16, 2014, 08:30:53 AM
No, the same method of limiting key travel can't be used on a 114 because the case does not form a lip behind the levers as it does on a pokerwork or Erica.
Limiting the key travel does not in itself reduce noise, to do that you could try re-facing the pallets. It can also help a lot to carefully centralise the buttons on the keyboard holes.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal