Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Pete Dunk on May 13, 2008, 08:26:40 PM
-
Rather than go off topic in other threads or start many new threads to ask random questions I thought I would start a single thread for queries and progress updates (progress will be slow!) on my quest to turn a tired old three voice box into something playable and hopefully pleasing to the ear.
The box is a Hohner, possibly a Corsa from the 1930's or 1940's but certainly elderly in any event. Three voice MMM in C/C# finished in grey/mauve celluloid which is in less than perfect condition; the plating has worn off the mis-shapen treble grille and the melodeon looks generally old and tired.
So far I've made a new cover for the bass end because the old one had started to come apart and had chunks missing and I'm now in the process of removing the old tapes from the bellows. This job is proving to be quite long winded as they were just paper with a shiny side rather than cloth backed so I'm having to tear the shiny bits off and then soak the backing paper before gently scraping it away. The bellows papers were either white or pale cream originally but now they are stained and unsightly, removing the edge tape isn't doing them any favours either so I'll have to recover them before re-taping. So the first question is about the metal corners, is it possible to remove them and if I did so would I ever get them back on again? They have tiny crease marks on them and I'm not sure if that's from bending the corner during manufacture or if they are crimped onto the bellows.
While working on the bellows and generally making the thing airtight I'm contemplating the reed work and how best to approach it. The box is generally well flat which suits me as I'm going to retune it to B/C, which brings up the subject of the basses. There are two layouts on the melodeon.net main site, one for modern Hohners and most other makes and the other a 'Modern' bass layout that seems to be quite odd. Are there any B/C players out there who can comment on the best bass layout?
That's probably enough to be going on with, please feel free to jump in with answers and suggestions, or just to poke fun. ;)
-
Taking bellows corners off to replace them is not a fun job. I'd do everything possible to avoid that particular task.
-
Thanks for that Theo. Looks like many hours carefully trimming paper around the metal corners then, good job I'm blessed with infinite patience. :(
-
The box is generally well flat which suits me as I'm going to retune it to B/C, which brings up the subject of the basses. There are two layouts on the melodeon.net main site, one for modern Hohners and most other makes and the other a 'Modern' bass layout that seems to be quite odd. Are there any B/C players out there who can comment on the best bass layout?
The one "for modern Hohners and most other makes" has been called the Paolo Soprani layout. The one labelled "Modern" is simply the Paolo Soprani layout with the duplicated inner row push "C"s changed to "D"s, which only makes sense if you started with the Paolo Soprani layout and wanted the cheapest way of getting "D"s on the push. From scratch, a more logical arrangement is the "Joe Burke" system, which groups the "D"s and "G"s more sensibly. See all of these on Han Speek's Bass Layouts on Irish Boxes. (http://www.xs4all.nl/~hspeek/irishbox/basses.html)
I've had all three of these layouts, and the Joe Burke is the best for an 8-button layout. All are a poor substitute for a proper Stradella bass.
-
Many thanks for your information Bill, I'll spend a bit of time studying the Joe Burke layout to see what's involved then I'll probably use this system, advice from an experienced player is invaluable.
Here's a pic of the new bass cover complete with rubber feet.
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/Bassgrille.jpg)
The treble end.
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/TrebleKeyboard.jpg)
And the one that worries me, here are the bass end chord reeds and there doesn't seem to be any wax in the tiny gaps between them. Has this fallen out or was it never there - and if that's the case how does that work then? I have all of the bits to do away with the waxing and screw the reeds back in on leather gaskets but that doesn't seem possible with this set. ???
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/basschordreeds.jpg)
Larger (and extra) pictures are here (http://s279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/)
-
Any wax "between" the chord reeds will be underneath, on top of the partitions. I think you will be hard pushed to substitute leather because the walls are not thick enough for a nail or screw even if you were to reduce the width of the plate.
If you go for rewaxing I think the answer is to work fast, setting the plates one at a time onto the partitions while the wax is still fluid then float the ends down, unless anyone knows a better way?
Just out of interest - you call this a Corso and I have seen them referred to as Pre Corsos elsewhere. I thought they were just a "Zweireihers so is this Hohners designation or just peoples way of describing them?
Regards,
Bruce
-
Just out of interest - you call this a Corso and I have seen them referred to as Pre Corsos elsewhere. I thought they were just a "Zweireihers so is this Hohners designation or just peoples way of describing them?
Regards,
Bruce
More likely it's just my mistake, I described this melodeon to someone who suggested it might possibly be a Corso. From the pics I've seen of Corsos your reference to pre-Corso might be correct. 'Zwerireihers' is a term I've not come across before and means nothing to me but as a newbie to accordions - button or otherwise - that's hardly surprising. Any info you can give to explain this term and expand my knowledge would be gratefully received.
As for waxing underneath the reeds, that's yet another technique I've not come across before. Ho-hum!
-
"Zweireihers" just means two row.
-
And the one that worries me, here are the bass end chord reeds and there doesn't seem to be any wax in the tiny gaps between them.
It is tricky waxing such closely spaced reeds. I think you could screw these reeds down, but the screws would have to go at the end s of the reedplates, and you would need to ensure that the top edges of those thin chamber walls were nice and flat.
My technique for waxing closely spaced reedplates is:
- start at one end
- place the first plate
- run a bead of wax round it finishing with the side where the next plate will go
- before the wax has set place the next reed, pressing it into the melted wax
- run a bead of wax along the free edge and repeat.
- Finish by running wax along the tops and bases of the reeds
points to note:
too much wax will squeeze out and may obstruct the valve or reed on the lower side if the plate
not enough wax will leave air leaks
if you aren't quick enough to catch the wax still liquid the reedplate will not be secure
I don't bother with the nails. I've seen plenty of old reedblocks where the wax had failed, but the reeds plates were still able to vibrate despite the presence of nails.
If wax gets onto reed tongues or anywhere else you don't want it let it get cold before attempting to remove it.
-
.
It is tricky waxing such closely spaced reeds. I think you could screw these reeds down, but the screws would have to go at the end s of the reedplates, and you would need to ensure that the top edges of those thin chamber walls were nice and flat.
.You made a better of explaining the waxing than I could have hoped to!
I cannot quite see how screws at the ends would be effective though. Outer ends would not present a problem but how would you propose holding the "port" ends down? I have seen Klingenthal blocks with a groove to hold this end but a retro modification would not be as easy as the "arkward" rewaxing.
Anyway, once he has sussed the tricky blocks out the others will be a doddle?
Regards, Bruce
-
Also, the Hohner blocks are softwood so the screws won't hold too well. Hardwood is the norm in reedblocks with the plates screwed down.
-
Thanks for all of the feedback, everything has been noted and will be mulled over while I'm working on the bellows. Speaking of the bellows, everything about this part of the work is tedious beyond belief. I reckon it took about four and a half hours in total to strip off the old tapes and soak off the backing paper remnants. the folds are marked in numerous places when someone has touched up the damaged bits with paint. >:(
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/Bellows1.jpg)
Next bit of tedium is cutting strips for the new bellows papers, folding them and cutting the ends in a vee. work continues!
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/newbellowspapers-1.jpg)
-
The papers have now been put on but it's hardly worth posting pictures. Starting work (hopefully) fitting the new bellows tapes tomorrow and I'll get pics up when the bellows are finished. After that I'll be re-facing the pallets and making any mechanical adjustments needed to key height/stroke. The buttons do seem to have quite a long travel and disappear well into the holes in the fingerboard, what's the best method of limiting key travel while leaving sufficient lift on the pallets for the reeds to sound properly?
-
Surely your instrument has a removable "plate" that reveals felt buffer strips under the buttons/levers? Chances are that it has worn through/compressed/fed the moths.Easy to replace with whatever thickness stops the button going through the plate. If this should result in insufficient pallet lift (unlikely) adjust the levers.
Regards, Bruce
-
Yes, the keyboard cover plate is removable but I haven't delved inside yet. Thanks for the tips though Bruce, now filed away for future reference.
On the subject of the specific model name 'Corso' vs 'pre-Corso' I found this image on the net which is exactly like mine but in much finer condition. The gold motifs on the fingerboard have worn away although a faint outline is still visible. This melodeon was described by the vendor as a 'pre-Corso'
Pete.
Edit: The link to this image broke a long time ago and I've been unable to find a suitable replacement, sorry!
-
I was not disputing the aptness of the term "pre Corso"! That, and "pre Corona" are widely used but I just wondered if Hohner themselves had ever described these Old Timers as Corso/Corona. (If I can add the link, there is a page that might interest you and which suggests not, but who cares! http://www.websitetoolbox.com/tool/post/gilbert27/vpost?id=886286&trail= (http://www.websitetoolbox.com/tool/post/gilbert27/vpost?id=886286&trail=)
Just as Corso, Corona and even the defunct Double Ray DeLuxe shared a lot of components I think the early ones did as well - I suspect the gold embellishments you mention were to fill space on a keyboard capable of holding three rows?
Regards, Bruce
-
I suspect the gold embellishments you mention were to fill space on a keyboard capable of holding three rows?
Regards, Bruce
Very possibly, there's certainly enough room. :D
The bellows should be finished by the weekend; the front and top runs are now done, just the back and bottom to go. I have to say the papers look much brighter in the pics than they actually are. They're almost navy blue in real life.
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/Bellowsfinished1.jpg)
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/Bellowsfinished2.jpg)
-
Here's a pic of the paper I used, if you've never had blue snakeskin bellows you haven't lived!
Edit: Once again the image I linked to has been deleted from the website, enlarging the picture of the cut strips a few posts above gives you a good idea of the pattern anyway.
-
So if you hear a hissing noise its not necessarily an air leak :D
-
So if you hear a hissing noise its not necessarily an air leak :D
:P
Bellows sorted. I'm amazed at how much better the compression is.
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/FrNewbellows.jpg)
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/TFNewBellows.jpg)
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/bellowsopen.jpg)
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/open2.jpg)
-
The question now is what next? My instinct is to replace the pallet leather/felt facings as the next step but there are so many things to do that I'm spoilt for choice.
The celluloid is marked, scuffed, loose in places and has a few bits missing, did I read somewhere that it's possible to strip it off and stain/polish the wooden casework. Has anyone actually done this?
The treble grille is shot, the finish has gone and the flimsy metal is distorted. I'm considering making a completely new fret-worked wooden cover to replace the whole thing but did wonder if there is a source for replacement grilles, I've seen a new one for an Erica on ebay but nothing for the larger models.
So back to the pallets, if I do this job next what should I do about the rather odd lump of leather under the bass end pallets? It would be difficult to remove or replace it without taking the whole bass action out which is something I don't particularly relish.
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/bass2.jpg)
Any tips about getting the pallets off the levers without doing any damage would be greatly appreciated. :)
-
I've just realised that once I have the pallets off I don't know which is the most suitable glue to use when fitting the new felt/leather sandwich. I'm not sure if pva would soak into the felt and harden it, would contact adhesive (Evostick) be better?
-
I use a latex glue given to me by a concertina maker. Copydex may be similar, they sell it in Woolies.
-
Two good glues are Bostik Solvent Free and Hi Tack All Purpose (may be latex) both from Hobbycraft.
I doubt that the thick leather is original but, if it is working, why not leave it alone? If you do have to remove the bass mechanism it is not difficult, if you unhook the springs and detach the the rods first (gives the opportunity to refelt the buttons at the same time)
Unless pallets have been refixed they should be ready to fall off, try raising the lever and gently pushing one end of the wood.
I have a tidy grille off a "Viktoria " that might modify to fit one like yours. I will find it and compare. If it is compatible I will mail you and speak about PA block.
Regards, Bruce
-
I use a latex glue given to me by a concertina maker. Copydex may be similar, they sell it in Woolies.
I have Copydex in my toolbox but didn't know if a latex based adhesive was up to the job. Good thing is it's easy to remove and start again if it fails.
-
I have a tidy grille off a "Viktoria " that might modify to fit one like yours. I will find it and compare. If it is compatible I will mail you and speak about PA block.
Regards, Bruce
You're welcome to the reed block anyway Bruce, the offer wasn't conditional but t'would be nice if you have a grille to make the old girl look smart again. :)
-
The glue doesn't need to be particularly strong as the pallets are under pressure from the springs most of the time. There is no sideways movement so shear force is not an issue.
Flexibility is the main requirement. Bit like life I suppose.....................
As Bruce says, the pallets should come off with a gentle tug. Lightly sand the old glue off.
Glue leather and felt together in a sheet big enough to cover all pallets then lay the pallets one by one on the felt (PVA glue is OK for this bit but almost anything will do). Don't forget to glue the felt to the shiny side of the leather.
When the glue has set cut around the pallets with a sharp knife.
Mount the keyboard action back on the box and position the pallets in place.
Theo's tip of glueing the pallets to the steel levers with a hot glue gun works a treat. The glue remains slightly flexible so the pallets always land flat.
I've just re-padded a Double Ray. Someone had very kindly used Araldite to stick pallets to levers. Impossible to remove so I had to re-pad with the pallets still on the levers. Not good!
-
I've just re-padded a Double Ray. Someone had very kindly used Araldite to stick pallets to levers. Impossible to remove so I had to re-pad with the pallets still on the levers. Not good!
Heating the rods with a soldering iron will soften many glues. I've not tried it with araldite though.
-
Heat won't soften Araldite once it's cured, I'm afraid.
When I was a student I had the handlebars stolen off my bike, so when I replaced them I filled up the allen-key hole with araldite to stop it happening again. I mentioned it to a friend saying it was worth not being able to adjust it for the security. He was a Chemistry postgrad and said "don't worry, there are ways and means, let me know if you ever need to get it out.". But I never did.
-
Pallets out, cleaned up and stuck to new pad material. ;D
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/BassnoPallets.jpg)
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/TreblenoPallets.jpg)
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/Pallets.jpg)
-
All the pallets have been refitted but only the bass end has been glued up. I have an air leak at the treble end so I'm leaving it overnight to see if the pads bed in under spring pressure, if that doesn't work a little tweaking will be in order.
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/BassPallets.jpg)
-
I shall have to read this thread more closely as I have just bought THIS (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&rd=1&item=330239135763&ssPageName=STRK:MEWN:IT&ih=014)
-
Nice box Lester, I was watching it myself but I'm being good at the moment and not buying anything else. If you need any bits you should contact the ever helpful Theo, fast service and excellent prices coupled with deep knowledge and sage advice.
-
Oh bother, I was watching that one, and another finishing at the same time, but wrestling a small boy into his pyjamas kept me away from the computer until it was too late. Ah well, glad to see it's gone to a good home.
On the subject of pallets, I've found it useful to cut a short strip of paper, catch it between the pallet and the board and then pull it out. Doing this at each end (or each corner) of the pallet and seeing where the resistance is least indicates the part of the pallet that isn't making a good seal.
-
My patience has been rewarded. I was a little alarmed at the number of air leaks from the treble pallets, especially as the bass pallets sealed straight away. I decided to take a break from the repairs for a day or two after which the new pads had bedded in all on their own so I glued the pallets in last night.
I say I took a break but I did take the opportunity to clean and polish the celluloid with a specialist plastics polish after taking a hot air gun to the warped bits and smoothing them back into place. There's a small piece missing at the side of the front grille but there's not much I can do about that unless I can lay my hands on a fragment of matching material to graft in.
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/PolishandGrille.jpg)
Speaking of the treble grille, I got my panel bashing tools out and reblocked it to something resembling the original shape then cleaned it up. It looks much better than it did but the shiny coating has mostly worn away and I'm just wondering if I should mask off the end cheeks and spray it matt black (silver spray paint looks so naff!). On the other hand I could simply leave it as is, any thoughts?
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/Grille.jpg)
I intend to remove the treble keyboard, clean it up, put a thumb groove down the edge and repaint it black. This will also give me the opportunity to renew the felt under the levers and limit the key travel a bit more. What I haven't yet decided is whether I'll do that next or finally bite the bullet and get cracking with the tuning. :o
-
Speaking of the treble grille, I got my panel bashing tools out and reblocked it to something resembling the original shape then cleaned it up. It looks much better than it did but the shiny coating has mostly worn away and I'm just wondering if I should mask off the end cheeks and spray it matt black (silver spray paint looks so naff!). On the other hand I could simply leave it as is, any thoughts?
It used to be possible at one time to get things like that re chromium plated. Whether there are still small firms that can do that sort of thing I don't know.
-
I have sprayed grilles matt black and they do look good.
I once sprayed a Pokerwork silver with a matt black grille. Sexy!!
-
And a bit of metal polish on the original grill might just do the trick.
-
It used to be possible at one time to get things like that re chromium plated. Whether there are still small firms that can do that sort of thing I don't know.
It would be tricky getting the grille off the ends, it's nailed onto the edge of the wooden cheeks and then the lot is enveloped with celluloid. Even if I could get it off the cost of one off re-plating would be more than I could justify refurbishing an instrument of this quality. I've not investigated chrome plating but there are certainly people in Sheffield who would do it in EPNS.
I have sprayed grilles matt black and they do look good.
I once sprayed a Pokerwork silver with a matt black grille. Sexy!!
It's quite easy to get a decent finish with spray cans of matt black. Gloss finishes are a different story without proper spray equipment and suitable skills and I have neither. It's a pity you didn't take any pics of the pokerwork Rees.
And a bit of metal polish on the original grill might just do the trick.
Oh I did that and got odd silvery bits and large areas of the brass like base metal showing through the rest, not pretty.
I removed the treble fingerboard today so that's the next job. There were two strips of quite thick felt under the levers but this is now slotted where the levers have cut through it over the years, oh for the days when I worked in a bakery and had access to woven felt belting - soft but springy and as tough as old boots. I'm now pondering what to use as a replacement. I'll be needing a few more bits shortly anyway Theo (shoulder strap brackets, bellows straps etc), do you have a suitable material to go under levers? I'll also be looking for a bass strap adjuster kit from somewhere ...
-
I'll be needing a few more bits shortly anyway Theo (shoulder strap brackets, bellows straps etc), do you have a suitable material to go under levers? I'll also be looking for a bass strap adjuster kit from somewhere ...
All available!
-
All available!
An order is in the offing. ;D I'll have plenty to keep me busy with the reedwork in the meantime so I'll let you know what I want and then collect it in a couple of weeks time on the way up to Northumberland (or perhaps on the way back down a few days later depending how things pan out).
I tackled the treble keyboard last night and again today. The thumb groove on the edge was a twenty minute job with a half round wood rasp followed by a various grades of sandpaper wrapped around a 50mm o.d. socket. It's fairly shallow to be honest but it does the job without going too deeply into the relatively thin timber on the outer edge. A bit of black stain and a couple of coats of satin varnish rubbed down with 0000 grade wire wool dipped in beeswax and then lightly buffed to finish, job done and looking pretty good.
-
Tuning has started on the basses and after a bit of confusion (explained to me by ever patient Theo), continues. Now I'm thinking about the treble reeds and have a question about the order in which they are fitted. This is a three voice MMM box with three blocks of reeds in the treble end. The first block has eleven reeds on each side relating to the outer row, the second block has eleven on one side (outer row) and ten on the other (inner row) the third block has ten reeds on each side - inner row again.
Is there a conventional layout in the rows? ie 1st flat, 2nd even, 3rd sharp - 4th flat, 5th even, 6th sharp (or the reverse order within each set) or might they be in any old order?
Last question for this post; most three voice MMM boxes are musette tuned which is a bit too wet for my liking so how many cents flat and sharp should I go to have a lively vibrato with going into the realms of musette?
-
Is there a conventional layout in the rows? ie 1st flat, 2nd even, 3rd sharp - 4th flat, 5th even, 6th sharp (or the reverse order within each set) or might they be in any old order?
It only really matters if your box has stops or couplers. I usually mark the blocks before I take the reeds off.
Last question for this post; most three voice MMM boxes are musette tuned which is a bit too wet for my liking so how many cents flat and sharp should I go to have a lively vibrato with going into the realms of musette?
There is also the question of whether you have the reeds tuned an equal distance apart, or a different distance apart. Many Italian boxes have about twice the difference between mid an high as between mid and low. It makes a noticeable difference to the sound.
As to how much - well I think you need to do some trials and see what sound you like. Do the reeds for a few notes and listen to the sound they make together, adjust drier or wetter till you find what you like. That is the big advantage of doing your own tuning.
-
Any ideas how many man-hours (person-hours) you are up to on this project so far?
Guy
-
Hello Guy, it's a bit difficult to quantify to be honest due to the way I go about jobs like this, in bits and pieces here and there with occasional bursts of constant activity. I often spent a few minutes during tea breaks at work pealing off bindings etc and up to twenty minutes of my lunch breaks each day were also spent beavering away, much to the amusement of my colleagues.
The bellows alone occupied some sixteen hours or so, what I haven't mentioned earlier is that I cut out and fitted 76 pieces of very thin leather 51mm long and 20mm wide with radiused ends fitting inside the metal corners to reinforce the gussets; this took quite a long time!
The pallets took a couple of hours to remove, clean, fit new felt/leather pads and refit. Another couple of hours or so were spent tidying up and refinishing the woodwork of the fingerboard, fitting new padded strips under the levers to limit travel, leveling the keys, cleaning and spraying the front grille and sorting out the celluloid.
So far about four hours on the reeds with little to show for it because I spent much of the time scratching my head. ??? The project will slow down drastically now because I can only work at home and I need to have sufficient spare time to make it worthwhile dragging out the tuning rig and setting it up - so not less than a couple of hours at a stretch which is hard to come by through the week.
Best guess so far then is about 24 hours to get to this stage, which tends to suggest I'm either dedicated, very sad or stark staring mad; or indeed all of the above. ::)
Pete.
-
I bought some nice material to put inside the grilles but the pics look quite odd using embedded links. To see the pics properly view the whole album page here (http://s279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/)
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/BassGrille-1.jpg?t=1213467327)
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/TrebleGrille.jpg?t=1213467394)
-
There is also the question of whether you have the reeds tuned an equal distance apart, or a different distance apart. Many Italian boxes have about twice the difference between mid an high as between mid and low. It makes a noticeable difference to the sound.
As to how much - well I think you need to do some trials and see what sound you like. Do the reeds for a few notes and listen to the sound they make together, adjust drier or wetter till you find what you like. That is the big advantage of doing your own tuning.
I'm a bit confused as to how I achieve this. If, for arguments sake I decide to wax the reeds back in, does this mean I have to wax them in and then rebuild the melodeon just to listen to it and then if I don't like the sound dig the reed plates back out and try again? Isn't there a rough guide as to how many cents +/- will give a tremolo more pronounced than swing but less than musette? Oh, and I like the sound of my Italian box (albeit LMM) so the idea of weighting the offset tuning more on the sharp reed than the flat one is quite appealing.
Incidentally I've noted your comments about tuning the thirds -5 cents in the chord reed set so I'll be doing that. On the larger bass reeds should I have tuned them exactly an octave apart (which I have) or should the higher reed have been slightly sharp for tremolo?
-
I bought some nice material to put inside the grilles but the pics look quite odd using embedded links.
How did you fix the new cloth in place? - Just picked up my "new" Hohner Club which needs a new grille cloth :-)
-
How did you fix the new cloth in place? - Just picked up my "new" Hohner Club which needs a new grille cloth :-)
Not my favourite adhesive, but on this occasion I used Copydex. Latex is very forgiving so if you make a right mess of it you can just peal it off and start again.
As for the material I picked it up in a local art and craft shop. It's used as the base for cross stitching (whatever that is! ::) ). Sounds quite expensive, one metre wide and £12 per running metre. I bought half a running metre for £6 and that's enough for at least four melodeons with enough left in the offcuts for a concertina or two; a bargain I reckon.
PM me your address Lester and I'll send you enough for your new box. Do bear in mind it will cost you a pint of beer should we ever meet up... ;)
-
PM me your address Lester and I'll send you enough for your new box. Do bear in mind it will cost you a pint of beer should we ever meet up... ;)
Thanks for your kind offer but my wife is a v keen canvas embroiderer so already have a loft full.
Example of the Sainted Mrs Bailey's work (http://homepage.ntlworld.com/john.e.price/babc.htm)
-
Thanks for your kind offer but ...
Ah, closet Yorkshireman are you? As a proper Yorkshireman I can sympathise, damned expensive stuff, beer. :P
Example of the Sainted Mrs Bailey's work (http://homepage.ntlworld.com/john.e.price/babc.htm)
Great stuff! It's wonderful to see craft work that is made for love, goodness knows you could never make a profit from it. It's said that pride is a sin but I don't really believe that; if you create something that has beauty beyond price and derive pleasure from its' creation and revel in your own skill at making it is that so very bad?
-
T On the larger bass reeds should I have tuned them exactly an octave apart (which I have) or should the higher reed have been slightly sharp for tremolo?
The last thing you need is tremolo on your basses so tune them all to zero (or top dead centre as we say in Wales).
-
The last thing you need is tremolo on your basses so tune them all to zero (or top dead centre as we say in Wales).
Thanks Rees, I've done just that. The first eight plates (the lowest) are now done, two of the reeds had to be tuned down by five semitones which is quite a fundamental change. :o
I was a little concerned that the soldering iron might overheat the reeds and affect the tempering but my fears were unfounded and this part of the procedure was probably the easiest and quickest of all. Chord reeds next but it will be a fortnight at the earliest before I get around to starting those because I'm going off on holiday next weekend (hooray!). At this rate the box might be finished by September/October. ::)
-
Thanks for your kind offer but my wife is a v keen canvas embroiderer so already have a loft full.
Example of the Sainted Mrs Bailey's work (http://homepage.ntlworld.com/john.e.price/babc.htm)
[/quote]
Thanks for reminding me about the Betley Court window Lester. I remember seeing it in the V&A a number of years ago, long before I reacquainted myself with the Morris and the Pokerwork melodeon then in semi-retirement.
And as someone who has cross-stitched in the past, that's a great piece of work by your wife.
Andy
-
When applying solder to large reeds to lower the pitch you can make a heatsink by using a small crocodile clip with a lump of copper between the jaws.
-
I'm a bit confused as to how I achieve this. If, for arguments sake I decide to wax the reeds back in, does this mean I have to wax them in and then rebuild the melodeon just to listen to it and then if I don't like the sound dig the reed plates back out and try again?
You tune the reeds after they have been waxed in. The pitch can change by an appreciable amount once they are mounted, compared with on a tuning bench. You need some nifty tools to get access to the pull reeds.
-
You need some nifty tools to get access to the pull reeds.
:o Oh dear, I think I'm getting one of my headaches.
-
You need some nifty tools to get access to the pull reeds.
:o Oh dear, I think I'm getting one of my headaches.
If you can get to Whitby Folk Week I'll show you how its done.
-
I've sent you a PM Theo.
-
Well the holiday was great, not least because I got to call in on Theo to collect a few bits and watch in amazement as he demonstrated one or two of the black arts of tuning. Secret and coveted knowledge? not a bit of it! Buy one of these from here and use it like this, don't blink mind or you've missed it. Too slow? I'll show you again!
A visit to Theo is always a pleasure and a great education, you can't fail to be caught up in his enthusiasm for all things to do with free reeds; he even meddles with concertinas you know, poor man.
I should have been back at work on the Hohner this weekend but the tuning rig is a bit too large for the kitchen. Scraping wax off reed plates is messy too and the rain prevented me from working outside so I decided to start work on tuning an old anglo concertina for a bit of light relief. Not the best relaxation plan I've come up with!
-
Rain stopped play. >:( With just two reeds left to complete the bass end tuning I had to pack up and beat a hasty retreat indoors. So far everything is going pretty well although this part has been very long winded, firstly due to my lack of experience, secondly because of my broad streak of caution and determination not to make a complete mess of it, but mostly because of the drastic changes that have to be made on the bass end. The treble end has many more reeds but that's a straightforward case of every reed tuned a semitone lower.
Because this box isn't particularly valuable in itself or precious to me I've tried an experiment. :o I seem to remember reading somewhere that although weighting the tip of a reed to lower its pitch is a straightforward and common practice, it's not possible to weight (stiffen) the belly to raise the pitch. Well I've been and gone and done it and it worked!; raising the pitch of a reed from G3 to C4 seemed to me to be too much to take off the tip without ruining the reed so I beefed up the belly with a line of solder, job done. Time will tell if I've done something with a very short working life but it's entirely reversible and I'm all for learning from your own mistakes. I didn't have a suitable spare reed plate lying around which I could substitute and I was convinced that the reed would be either be ruined by the removal of so much metal from the tip or would have a thin, weak sound and probably suffer from poor response into the bargain.
I'm not a vain person so if the experiment fails in use I'll tell you all about it so you can have a good laugh and join in the chorus of 'I told you so'. ;D
Retuning the anglo concertina went well and quite quickly, brushing up tuning is much easier than making drastic changes!
Pete.
-
Week after week I've been prevented from continuing this project for one reason or another (mostly weather - must find somewhere to set up a permanent workshop), but now I've finally finished the bass end tuning. New valves will go on tomorrow and then there's the tricky matter of waxing the smaller plates back onto the block. Try as I might I could find no way to refit the sixteen smaller plates using screws, or even enough room to nail them back on gasket material.
Given the thin walls of the reed block I'm not particularly looking forward to the apparently delicate task of applying sufficient wax to the edge of a piece of wood that looks less than 3mm wide to both hold and seal the edges of two reed plates while not using enough for it to run off into the chamber and foul the reed on the other side of the plate. I also have to work fast enough to carefully fit two plates in place before the applied wax starts to set. This is the last hurdle for the bass side though and I'm hoping the treble end proves to be a little less fraught!
-
Valves all done, no excuse now to delay waxing them in!
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/Readytowax.jpg)
-
I used a single egg poacher as a double pan to melt the wax and made a waxing spoon rest from a wire coat-hanger ...
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/Waxing.jpg)
The result wasn't the tidiest waxing you'll ever see but it worked. ;D
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Corso/Waxed.jpg)
-
Of course when I put the melodeon back together I'd made my traditional error and forgotten to reverse two of the plates, the resultant chords were unpleasant to say the least. So in addition to learning how to wax reeds in I've now been able to take two plates off, clean them up and wax them back in without too much trouble.
That said the wax had set to a solid but very sticky gloop, not at all like the hard crumbly stuff that was on there originally. I'm now intrigued as to how accordion reed wax is made up, might be worth another thread to see if we can entice a few people to give up their secret recipes and explain how the individual ingredients affect the finished wax.
As predicted by the knowledgeable members of the forum, the pitch of the reeds has altered significantly now that they're back in the instrument with new valves. This will mean fine tuning them in situ, so I just placed an order with Hohner for some of their specialist tools. Not cheap I can tell you. >:(
-
Thank you Tallship for documenting all this work that you've done.It's a tremendous resource to have at hand for the day when I'll have to overhaul my Hohners(that day has come and gone a few decades ago for some of them).
Chris
-
Thank you Tallship for documenting all this work that you've done.It's a tremendous resource to have at hand for the day when I'll have to overhaul my Hohners(that day has come and gone a few decades ago for some of them).
Chris
I was just going to say, this has been a very informative thread, and I've been interested in following the progress of your project, with practical (humorous!) commentary also. I don't see anything else on the net quite like it, save for a few PA blogs found only after an hour's worth of blind link-following and left hand turns.. Watching it blossom to 5 pages, I think "Refurbishing an old Hohner" is turning into quite an "epic" thread. Perhaps you might want to rename it "Lord of the Reeds.." ? :D
...coat!
(But really, thank you for the document.)
-
That said the wax had set to a solid but very sticky gloop, not at all like the hard crumbly stuff that was on there originally. I'm now intrigued as to how accordion reed wax is made up, might be worth another thread to see if we can entice a few people to give up their secret recipes and explain how the individual ingredients affect the finished wax.
There have been various threads in the past on recipes for reed wax, probably on the old forum, because I couldn't find them on here. The one I remember was 50% beeswax, 50% rosin, and 5% olive oil. ??? I think that was Theo.
-
The one I remember was 50% beeswax, 50% rosin, and 5% olive oil.
Obviously, you'll need a bigger pot (as Clay Jones used to say).
Tallship I'm very impressed. And I didn't know Hohner sold tools to civilians, do they have an online catalogue I don't know about?
-
I'll reply in full later but I've attached the Hohner spare parts list for your perusal - if the file isn't too big that is!
-
Thank you Tallship for documenting all this work that you've done.It's a tremendous resource to have at hand for the day when I'll have to overhaul my Hohners(that day has come and gone a few decades ago for some of them).
Chris
Hello Chris, if you're a practical person overhauling your Hohners will be very straightforward until you reach the reed work which is trickier, but care and patience will be rewarded. I wouldn't advise anyone to do a complete key change as a first project as it makes the task seem endless. When the time comes I'm sure you'll find the forum members as helpful and supportive as I have.
I was just going to say, this has been a very informative thread, and I've been interested in following the progress of your project, with practical (humorous!) commentary also. I don't see anything else on the net quite like it, save for a few PA blogs found only after an hour's worth of blind link-following and left hand turns.. Watching it blossom to 5 pages, I think "Refurbishing an old Hohner" is turning into quite an "epic" thread. Perhaps you might want to rename it "Lord of the Reeds.." ? :D
Hello finnhorse, If the ups and downs I've had have proved both informative and occasionally amusing then I'm very pleased indeed, Thank you. ;D As to 'Lord of the Reeds', this is only my chapter, hopefully there will be more to come from others; then we'll have created 'The Melodeon Maintenance Manual' without realising it. ;)
There have been various threads in the past on recipes for reed wax, probably on the old forum, because I couldn't find them on here. The one I remember was 50% beeswax, 50% rosin, and 5% olive oil. ??? I think that was Theo.
Hello Bill, I'd only found one reference to the composition of reed wax and that was pretty similar except that the olive oil was substituted with 'add linseed oil to taste' which gave no real indication about quantity. I presume that the beeswax is mainly the carrier, the pine rosin gives it grip and the oil prevents it from drying out and crumbling
Obviously, you'll need a bigger pot (as Clay Jones used to say).
Tallship I'm very impressed. And I didn't know Hohner sold tools to civilians, do they have an online catalogue I don't know about?
Hello Waltham, I doubt I'll ever get around to making my own wax, I enjoy doing jobs like this and learning all of the ins and outs so that I thoroughly understand what I'm doing and why. I may pick up other boxes to add to the collection and if I can buy them cheap and fettle them myself that's all to the good but I have no ambitions to be a 'proper' repairer/restorer.
Hohner do sell spare parts and tools but they don't exactly make it easy. There is no online shop or catalogue. On Theo's advice I emailed them with an enquiry and received two .pdf catalogues attached to the reply, one for accordions and the other covering the rest of their range. To order, go to the website and click on the 'Service' tab, there you will find contact details for you to email your enquiry about servicing or spare parts. I've now email a short list of tools I require and requested information about postage costs, tax payable and method of payment. Two days later and I haven't yet had a reply, when I do I'll post the information here.
Thanks to all for replying, it's much appreciated. :) I'm attaching the other catalogue I received in case it's of interest to anyone.
Pete.
-
People interested in doing work on reeds may be interested to know that reed files, scrapers, test bellows, tuners, reed wax, are available from Charlie Watkins, Biggin Hill, London. His website is http://www.wemwatkins.co.uk/ . Click on the "Accordion Today" link (his on-line .pdf magazine), and go to page 20 for tools.
-
Some are also available from this site
http://freenet-homepage.de/pigini/PIGINI/index.htm
-
Regards ordering Hohner tools and spares.
Surprisingly there seems no mention in the links of Sutherland Trading Co. Bedwas, CF83 8QX
They are still virtually Hohner UK and, so long as time is not of the essence, their Steve Proctor will order anything from Germany along with his stock orders.
-
I've still heard nothing from Hohner so I contacted Steve Procter at Sutherland and the tools are now ordered. I've now stripped the reeds off two of the treble blocks ready to begin tuning the B row. I checked the existing layout and found that the first row was tuned even, the second 25 cents sharp (!!) and the row on the middle block almost 10 cents flat, no wonder the thing sounds wet to the point of being discordant.
The flat reeds for both rows being on the centre block is handy in case I want to try it as a two voice, I would have rearranged it like this anyway. In the absence of a proper reference guide for the tremolo I think I'll try 10 cents sharp and four cents flat unless anyone has a better suggestion. I want to achieve something more pronounced than 'swing' but well short of 'musette'.
-
I'm off on my hols again in the morning for a week and a half. I've spent so much time trying to find out what constitutes 'swing' tuning that I haven't yet started on the treble reeds. I found one site selling a box tuned to A=440 (+3), I assume this is a two voice with the sharp reeds tuned up 3 Hz. That didn't tell me a lot until I found this useful on-line tool (http://www.sengpielaudio.com/calculator-centsratio.htm) which means an offset of 3Hz is equal to 11.76 cents.
I'll ponder on this while I'm away and decide on a starting point for my tremolo tuning adventure when I get back.
Pete.
-
Well I'm back and hoping to start tuning the treble end this weekend but need to ask a question of the experienced tuners here.
When tuning the the bass end reeds I used a section of old reed block on the tuning rig for the largest plates but then tuned the smaller plates straight over the slot in the table. The largest reeds stayed pretty much as I tuned them but when waxed back in the smaller plates are noticeable flat. Is it common practice to use lumps of reedblock in a variety of sizes to match the plates when tuning or alternatively tune the reeds a couple of cents sharp to minimise fine tuning?
I do intend to chop up a few lumps of reedblock at some stage to enable me to sound 2/3 reeds together to check chords and tremolo; do I need to do this sooner rather than later? I did find it difficult to sound reed plates flat over the slot because the rivet tops make sealing the plate properly rather problematical. Perhaps I should spend more time 'jigging up' before proceeding, any thoughts?
Pete.
-
New reeds are usually supplied about 10 cents sharp.
Whatever method you use for the first tuning, you will still have to do a final tuning after waxing the plates in place.
-
Delays, delays, but I made a significant discovery today. I checked the first three reed plates laid flat over the slot on the tuning table and all were significantly sharp. So I finally got around to chopping up an old reed block to provide a proper 'chamber' to sound the reeds on, I then checked the same plates again and found that one was tuned even, one quite sharp and the last about 4 cents flat.
My conclusion from this experiment is that anyone doing a full reed overhaul would do well to buy an old clunker melodeon to scavenge or get a set of old PA reeds blocks off ebay (they turn up fairly often), use a few reed plates to practice tuning on and chop up the blocks for sounding the reeds during tuning. If the reeds were waxed on, clean up the blocks and stick a bit of chamois or bellows gasket around the apertures you'll be using. Simply holding the reed against the block gives quite a good seal, you'll still have to fine tune it after waxing the reeds back but I think it will tuned be much closer this way.
Speaking of fine tuning, my new Hohner tools arrived this week from Sutherland Trading. Somehow they managed to miss out the most important one, a 1mm reed scraper which I'm chasing up, but I did get the spare tip I ordered which is actually long enough to use without the proper handle. Now for the mystifying bit. I expected the tip to have a burr around it, a little like a cabinet scraper, but it is perfectly smooth and doesn't scratch anything! The tip is hollow too, like a tube, which surprised me; so how do I create the cutting burr? THEO! HELP! ???
-
New reeds are usually supplied about 10 cents sharp.
well Theo, the Binci reeds I got a month ago was just about all tuned -20 cents...
-
Speaking of fine tuning, my new Hohner tools arrived this week from Sutherland Trading. Somehow they managed to miss out the most important one, a 1mm reed scraper which I'm chasing up, but I did get the spare tip I ordered which is actually long enough to use without the proper handle. Now for the mystifying bit. I expected the tip to have a burr around it, a little like a cabinet scraper, but it is perfectly smooth and doesn't scratch anything! The tip is hollow too, like a tube, which surprised me; so how do I create the cutting burr? THEO! HELP! ???
It sounds as if the the thing you have is the handle. The tip is only about 10 or 15 mm long - you would have difficulty holding that. The hollow end is where you place the cutting tip. The tip is a plain cylinder 1mm in diameter, it should be ground flat at 90º to the axis of the cylinder, giving you a sharp right angle edge all round. It needs regular sharpening.
-
It's easy to make a reed scratcher by grinding the tip of a needle file flat and sharpening on an oilstone.
-
It sounds as if the the thing you have is the handle. The tip is only about 10 or 15 mm long - you would have difficulty holding that. The hollow end is where you place the cutting tip. The tip is a plain cylinder 1mm in diameter, it should be ground flat at 90º to the axis of the cylinder, giving you a sharp right angle edge all round. It needs regular sharpening.
As always you are of course correct Theo. I ordered a 'reed scraper' for around £25 or so and a 'reed scraper replacement part' for £6-7. Well, call me dumb if you like, but I thought I was buying a complete tool for £25 and a replacement tip for an extra few pounds. Now it seems that the £25 or so is for the cutting tip and the odd few quid is for a handle. One is actually useless without the other and I have to say I'm not to impressed with the way that Hohner presents this. There are no photographs to illustrate the items that are offered for sale. I can appreciate the language barrier but in an international marketplace it would perhaps be more helpful to offer pictures of the items offered for sale so that potential customers realise just what it is they are buying?
-
£25 for the cutting tip sounds excessive, I think that must be for the handle/holder. I think you could find something else to use as a cutting tip. 1mm tool steel (http://www.collegeengineering.co.uk/Materials/silversteel.htm)? You might need to harden it.
-
£25 for the cutting tip sounds excessive, I think that must be for the handle/holder.
I already have the handle, as confirmed by Sutherlands. The handle, two reed lifters and two types of reed support tool cost the princely sum of £14.99; apparently the big bucks are for the hardened (presumably carbide or tungsten) tip!
Tuning has now started in earnest. The first reed took me about 20 mins yesterday, after which I became disenchanted with filing the belly to lower the pitch of the the reed by a semitone, so out came the soldering iron to weight the tips. This lunchtime I tuned three full plates (six reeds) in a little under half an hour which is much better progress. Two buttons tuned, only 19 more to go. ::)
-
I now have five buttons tuned and one of the plates from the sixth. Events have overtaken me this week preventing me from achieving my goal of at least one button a day (Mon - Fri), hopefully the coming week will be a little quieter and more 'normal' - whatever that is.
I've ordered a couple of spare tips for the soldering iron as the one I'm using at the moment is going to be too big for the smaller reeds when I get to the top end.
A reed I tuned on Friday was 'one of those', I just couldn't get it right. I had to solder it three times in the end; first too much solder so it's way flat -*file,file,file*-, getting close now, -*file*- sod it, now it's sharp! >:( *Repeat* >:(. Third time around I got it right but I was glad to see the back of that one I can tell you.
-
At long last the B row is tuned and ready for re-valving. I haven't decided yet whether I'll wax them back on the blocks or use gasket and screws; the latter is favourite at the moment because I can't seem to get the hang of using a reed lifter so if the reeds are waxed in I'll struggle with the final tuning.
I wouldn't mind so much if I hadn't been watching over Theo's shoulder while he deftly flicked out the inner reeds. He did this several times and it looked fairly straightforward, if a little fiddly, but try as I might I can't get it to work. All I do is get the tool jammed and risk damaging the reed.
Next time I go up there I'm going to take the video camera and film him at work to remind myself of how things are done!
In the meantime work will commence on tuning the C row. ::)
-
At this rate the box might be finished by September/October. ::)
At the time I thought this was an impossibly pessimistic view. We're now well into November and I'm a long way from finished!
So Grasshopper, you want to learn to fix accordion? Tell me, what is the sound of one jackal laughing? ;D
-
£25 for the cutting tip sounds excessive, I think that must be for the handle/holder.
I already have the handle, as confirmed by Sutherlands. The handle, two reed lifters and two types of reed support tool cost the princely sum of £14.99; apparently the big bucks are for the hardened (presumably carbide or tungsten) tip!
Prompted by this sorry tale I've found what seems to be an excellent substitute for the Hohner scratcher tips. The shank of a 1mm twist drill in 5% cobalt HSS from Axminster Tools (http://www.axminster.co.uk/product-Axminster-Cobalt-HSS-Drill-Bits-21744.htm). Cost about £1 each, and the shank is long enough to break off a piece for the scratcher and still leave a useable drill bit. HSS is designed to remain hard even when red hot, so I may be able to speed up the tuning work!
-
Fascinating stuff Theo. I know if I put a twist drill in a vice and give it a sharp tap it will snap off but how do you then grind the broken stump flat and square?
Pete.
-
Fascinating stuff Theo. I know if I put a twist drill in a vice and give it a sharp tap it will snap off but how do you then grind the broken stump flat and square?
Pete.
With the same tool that you would need to use regularly to keep the Hohner bit sharp. You could use a grinding wheel, but I've discovered that a diamond file (http://www.axminster.co.uk/product.asp?pf_id=460561&name=diamond&user_search=1&sfile=1&jump=44) does a much better job and it saves me having to stand up and go next door to the grinder.
-
Looks like I'll be shopping at Axminster again in the near future, ho-hum. ::)
As I'd already stripped off the all of the reeds from two of the three reed blocks I decided to press on with the tuning and I've now tuned all of the 4 cent flat reeds for the C row so that I can refit two whole blocks rather than one and a half. That leaves just 40 of the 126 treble reeds left to tune. ;D
Looking at the narrow strip of wood between the apertures for the reed plates I've more or less decided to wax them back on rather than risk splitting the blocks. If I can't then get the knack of using the reed lifter to access the inner reeds for fine tuning it looks like I'll be dropping it in at Theo's sometime next year to get it finished off. ???
-
Two full blocks of reeds are now waxed back in place. Following a suggestion by Shy Talk I've only fitted valves to the backs of the plates (draw reeds), this will allow me to fine tune the push reeds without the valves complicating things and/or getting damaged in the process. Once they are done I can fit the remaining valves and fine tune the draw reeds.
Bruce also suggested that if I'm struggling to use the reed lifter to get at the inner reeds for fine tuning (which I am), I should go in through the port at the bottom of the block and gently push the reed tongue through to the front then slip the reed lifter behind it to keep it there. It made sense to me so that's what I'll try when the time comes.
I'll press on now and get the final two rows of plates for the C row tuned up. :)
-
Looks like I'll be shopping at Axminster again in the near future, ho-hum. ::)
I've now tuned all of the 4 cent flat reeds for the C row
I thought a double set of reeds was tuned on pitch for one set and slightly ABOVE pitch for the second set. Am I missing something here?
If your valve lifter is giving you trouble It may not be the right size. You can make a valve lifter out of an unwound guitar G string. Bend it to the size curve you want and attatch to a wood handle.
-
I thought a double set of reeds was tuned on pitch for one set and slightly ABOVE pitch for the second set. Am I missing something here?
This is an old pre-Corso and it's a three voice MMM so there's one reed tuned top dead centre, one fairly sharp (+10 cents) and a third one slightly flat (-4 cents). Originally the tremolo would have been more pronounced.
The reed lifter is from Hohner and it's pretty fine, I just can't seem to get the knack of using it!
Pete.
-
I've found what seems to be an excellent substitute for the Hohner scratcher tips. The shank of a 1mm twist drill in 5% cobalt HSS from Axminster Tools (http://www.axminster.co.uk/product-Axminster-Cobalt-HSS-Drill-Bits-21744.htm). Cost about £1 each, and the shank is long enough to break off a piece for the scratcher and still leave a useable drill bit. HSS is designed to remain hard even when red hot, so I may be able to speed up the tuning work!
As an experiment I tried this with a tungsten bit and it works fine, I will get a couple of the cobalt ones though. I was so pleased with the result that I took a short length of 4mm brass rod into work and drilled it on the lathe with a 1.5mm bit, so now I have two sizes of reed scratcher. ;D
-
I wasn't in the mood for stripping the reed plates from the last block today so I set too with fine tuning the first row and was surprised by my progress, more than half of the reeds tuned in about forty minutes. All but one were slightly sharp which is easier to deal with than slightly flat notes when the plates are in place, particularly with the inside reeds.
Feeling pleased with self. :)
-
Finished off fine tuning the B row and I've now tuned eight of the remaining twenty plates for the C row; when I've finished that row they will be ready to be re-valved and waxed back in, then fine tuned. The bass still has to be fine tuned too but a couple of chord buttons are making "you're an idiot and missed me entirely" discords - so I might be digging one or two plates back out. ::)
I'm pretty hopeful that the bulk of the work will be finished before Christmas with a bit of luck. Now I'm desperately unhappy that fitting an adjustable bass strap will probably involve remaking the bass end cover because the existing pattern of sound holes will be badly compromised by the slot I'll have to cut for it to fit.
Sometimes I despair at my own ineptitude and lack of foresight. :(
-
Just seven plates (fourteen reeds) left to tune now. I should finish those easily during the next week and be waxing them back in next weekend. That will leave the last forty plates on the treble side to fine tune which is fairly quick to do if I haven't done any howlers; The bass end is still to fine tune and there's one obvious mistake to rectify (a chord that is truly awful so I've probably missed a reed entirely and it's one of the inside ones. ::))
So I'm getting perilously close to actually finishing this mammoth project and it's been quite a journey. I've learned a lot, certainly enough to realise that there were many things I should have done differently. I fear I won't really learn much from some of my mistakes other than to swear I'll never undertake such a thing again!
When the whole task is finally finished I'll make a 'post mortem' summary of my experiences and do my best to explain why no sane human being would do what I've done in the way that I've done it!
-
Well I've been pretty silent about this project for some time. To be honest I became pretty disheartened and decided to take time out for a while, For a start off I don't have a workshop and prefer to work outdoors so the winter months are pretty off-putting to be honest. I also came to the conclusion that my decision to change the box from C/C# to B/C was flawed. It works for the treble end but the changes to the bass and chord reeds are too drastic, replacement reeds are needed for this to work properly.
That said I decided to move things along this week and I've now waxed in the last set of reeds on the C row. They still need to be fine tuned and have new valves fitted to the push notes but so far the results are pretty good.
Don't ask me about the bass notes though, and the chords are just a nightmare!
Pete.
-
The treble reeds have now all been fine tuned and the remaining valves have been fitted. The melodeon sounds pretty good on the treble end and is very responsive. Limiting the button travel has made the keyboard action light and fast, so now it's a very nice instrument to play.
The jury is still out on what I'll do about the bass end chords but I'm seriously considering new reeds to finish the box off properly. ::)
-
Here we go again, the nights are drawing in so it's time for box butchery again. This time it's a Hohner Club IIIB C/F which is in much better condition than my last project box. An couple of air leaks to sort out but new bellows gasket will probably take care of most of that, although I strongly suspect that the huge air valve isn't sealing properly either. The pallets may need refacing but we'll see.
The reeds are nice and clean but rather out of tune and the old leather valves (fitted throughout, no plastic ones in this box) are badly curled so I'll be replacing those. No pics to put up yet but I will post some when I get myself a bit more organised.
Here I am again with more questions about tuning having scoured through a couple of interesting threads. I'm unsure about trying 'dedic' tuning as the debate swings wildly back and forth but I am curious to know what it is that makes it a right royal PITA to do and would it be any easier to get right on a three voice box when at least one of the reeds is tuned tdc?
My schoolboy physics is screaming out at me telling me I already know the answer to the next question but I'll ask it nevertheless. Am I correct in assuming that if I tune the tremolo reeds using Hz instead of cents that the chosen tremolo will remain constant all the way up the box without compensating for the smaller reeds by reducing the difference as you need to do when using cents?
That's probably enough for now, I don't want to push my luck.
Pete. (:)
-
I'm unsure about trying 'dedic' tuning as the debate swings wildly back and forth but I am curious to know what it is that makes it a right royal PITA to do and would it be any easier to get right on a three voice box when at least one of the reeds is tuned tdc?
If your three voices are MMM then the conventional way is to tune -/0/+
What makes two voce tuning with one reed sharp and one flat is that there is no reed at the nominal pitch to act as a reference when making the crucial final adjustments to get a consistent beat rate.
My schoolboy physics is screaming out at me telling me I already know the answer to the next question but I'll ask it nevertheless. Am I correct in assuming that if I tune the tremolo reeds using Hz instead of cents that the chosen tremolo will remain constant all the way up the box without compensating for the smaller reeds by reducing the difference as you need to do when using cents?
That depends what you mean by "using Hz instead of cents".
If you set your tuner to say A=442, then you will have a 2Hz difference( = 2 bps tremolo) at that A, but an octave higher you will have double the frequency on your sharp reed eg 884Hz giving you 4bps difference from the reed at nominal pitch.
If you have a way of measuring a 2Hz difference from every note you tune then you will have the same beat rate across the board.
-
If your three voices are MMM then the conventional way is to tune -/0/+
What makes two voce tuning with one reed sharp and one flat is that there is no reed at the nominal pitch to act as a reference when making the crucial final adjustments to get a consistent beat rate.
Yes, the three voices are MMM so 'dedic' tuning might be an option? I'm aware that you're not entirely convinced about it so perhaps I'll stick to 'standard' accordion tuning until I have a bit more experience.
That depends what you mean by "using Hz instead of cents".
If you set your tuner to say A=442, then you will have a 2Hz difference( = 2 bps tremolo) at that A, but an octave higher you will have double the frequency on your sharp reed eg 884Hz giving you 4bps difference from the reed at nominal pitch.
If you have a way of measuring a 2Hz difference from every note you tune then you will have the same beat rate across the board.
My Peterson StroboFlip tuner can be set to either cents or Hertz and I can preset a +/- offset so yes I can measure a 2Hz difference from any note (with the meter set to A=440). That kind of takes away the guesswork of using cents then. (:)
One thing I've never thought to mention is that I have hearing damage, which means that in addition to slightly poor general hearing I have a built in bandpass filter that cuts out higher and lower frequencies so I'm more reliant on meters than most people as the upper and lower harmonics are inaudible to me. :'(
-
If your three voices are MMM then the conventional way is to tune -/0/+
What makes two voce tuning with one reed sharp and one flat is that there is no reed at the nominal pitch to act as a reference when making the crucial final adjustments to get a consistent beat rate.
Yes, the three voices are MMM so 'dedic' tuning might be an option? I'm aware that you're not entirely convinced about it so perhaps I'll stick to 'standard' accordion tuning until I have a bit more experience.
So with MMM configuration how would 'dedic' differ from the conventional?
-
If I understand the question
one reed low one reed 440 one reed high
-
Exactly, that would be the conventional tuning.
-
So with MMM configuration how would 'dedic' differ from the conventional?
The last box I tuned was (in cents) -4/0/+12 tapering off towards the squeaky end. As I understand it this leaves the note sounding very bright but slightly sharp to concert overall. Quoting suggested figures from another thread and using Hertz this time I take it that the ‘dedic’ tuning for MMM would be -4/0/+4 giving a beat rate of eight and a note sounding in concert. So the point is that the sharp and flat reeds are tuned equally away from the reference note rather than slightly flat and fairly sharp.
I don’t want to make a big thing out of this and annoy anyone, I was just curious to know if I’d properly understood the theory behind this tuning method.
Pete. (:)
-
So with MMM configuration how would 'dedic' differ from the conventional?
The last box I tuned was (in cents) -4/0/+12 tapering off towards the squeaky end. As I understand it this leaves the note sounding very bright but slightly sharp to concert overall. Quoting suggested figures from another thread and using Hertz this time I take it that the ‘dedic’ tuning for MMM would be -4/0/+4 giving a beat rate of eight and a note sounding in concert. So the point is that the sharp and flat reeds are tuned equally away from the reference note rather than slightly flat and fairly sharp.
I don’t want to make a big thing out of this and annoy anyone, I was just curious to know if I’d properly understood the theory behind this tuning method.
Pete. (:)
I use a Stroboflip tuner and I was never able to figure out an easy mathematical way to set the tremolo using cents or hertz. I think the reason is that the 'distance' between the reeds that determines the beat frequency varies continuously over the scale. So maybe it would be helpful to explain what makes standard tuning of a two voice instrument relativley easier than 'dedic'. With standard tuning you can tune one set of reeds exactly on pitch and the second set you can tune by ear to the amount of tremolo you like and make it roughly the same over the scale. To do this you only have to adjust the one 'wet' reed and you never have to worry about the pitch because it is 'anchored' by the other reed. With 'dedic' tuning on a two voice there is no reed anchoring the pitch so fine tuning the tremolo involves adjusting two reeds by exactly the same amount in the same direction or else you may throw off the pitch. The beauty of being able to tune your own instrument is that, after playing it awhile you will likely notice that one note may be a bit 'wetter' than the rest and you can pop open the box and adjust it. I never get it just right the first (or even second) time through.
By the way, I've found that the Stroboflip works best if you plug a good microphone into it. I use an SM57.
-
Thought Club III was MML - in which case Dedic doesn't work.
-
Thought Club III was MML - in which case Dedic doesn't work.
Perhaps there were different models, this is a IIIB and is definately MMM.
-
Thought Club III was MML - in which case Dedic doesn't work.
Yes there are many different versions of the Club III. Typically the ones with stops/couplers are LMM, the ones without usually MMM.
-
A couple of things about this box have surprised me over the last few days. First of all it was tuned A=435 so I've a bit more work to do on the tuning than I had anticipated. Secondly, having now finished tuning and re-valving the eight large bass reed plates I turned my attention to the high bass and chord reeds today only to discover that the chords are six voice rather than the four I had expected to find.
As the box doesn't have a bass end stop to take out the thirds I'm wondering whether to block off the ports (reversibly!) and just have two root and two fifth tuned reeds to make it less air hungry. I'll tune the thirds up anyway (5 cents flat) just in case I want to bring them into play at a later stage.
Anyone have any thoughts on this idea, will it make the chords too thin?
-
Six reeds in the chords in addition to the two bass reeds? I've not seen that before, usually its four chord reeds, I can't imagine they will sound thin if there are still four reeds sounding!
-
No, sorry Theo, it's two bass notes and four chord reeds, the pre-Corso three voice I did only had two chord reeds.
-
That's what I've seen on other early Club III, with the 'extra' reed being a higher tonic. Its often easier to stop the thirds on those boxes because sometimes the third for both push and pull are on the same reedplate. All you need then is to tape over the vent in the base of the block.
Incidentally even the tiny Preciosa has 4 chord reeds and two of them shared with the bass.
-
It seems as if this box may be slightly different from the norm, the six notes in the chords are: two root notes an octave apart (shared with the bass), two thirds an octave apart and two fifths an octave apart. I haven't finished investigating yet but so far it looks as if the thirds in each case are on plates together and easily blanked off.
The bass mechanism on this beastie is rather more complex than my other Hohner! Refacing the pallets looks like quite a task, as indeed does the treble end now I've had a good look around inside.
Looks like another steep learning curve. ::)
-
So it is six notes per chord after all?
The later Club III, such as the Club IIIM have a complicated mechanism which shares reeds between different chords, so for example the fifth of C/G (G/D) becomes the third of Eb/Bb, and the tonic of C/G becomes the fifth of F/C. Quite ingenious, but it it does rule out de-clubbing then chords.
-
So it is six notes per chord after all?
The later Club III, such as the Club IIIM have a complicated mechanism which shares reeds between different chords, so for example the fifth of C/G (G/D) becomes the third of Eb/Bb, and the tonic of C/G becomes the fifth of F/C. Quite ingenious, but it it does rule out de-clubbing then chords.
Yes there are six notes in total, that includes the two shared with the basses which give the root notes of the chord. I think there's a bit of confusion here with terminology! Here you were asking if there were six notes in addition to the borrowed bases:
Six reeds in the chords in addition to the two bass reeds? I've not seen that before, usually its four chord reeds, I can't imagine they will sound thin if there are still four reeds sounding!
I really must take some pics so you can have a good look at it. The basses do seem to work as you suggested with ports opening all over the shop to create the chords using shared notes. Good job I wasn't intending to de-Club it then!
edited for typo - must learn to spel proper ::)
-
I'm unsure about trying 'dedic' tuning as the debate swings wildly back and forth but I am curious to know what it is that makes it a right royal PITA to do and would it be any easier to get right on a three voice box when at least one of the reeds is tuned tdc?
If your three voices are MMM then the conventional way is to tune -/0/+
What makes two voce tuning with one reed sharp and one flat is that there is no reed at the nominal pitch to act as a reference when making the crucial final adjustments to get a consistent beat rate.
My schoolboy physics is screaming out at me telling me I already know the answer to the next question but I'll ask it nevertheless. Am I correct in assuming that if I tune the tremolo reeds using Hz instead of cents that the chosen tremolo will remain constant all the way up the box without compensating for the smaller reeds by reducing the difference as you need to do when using cents?
That depends what you mean by "using Hz instead of cents".
If you set your tuner to say A=442, then you will have a 2Hz difference( = 2 bps tremolo) at that A, but an octave higher you will have double the frequency on your sharp reed eg 884Hz giving you 4bps difference from the reed at nominal pitch.
If you have a way of measuring a 2Hz difference from every note you tune then you will have the same beat rate across the board.
It's a PITA to do if you don't have a tuner that can directly allow a frequency offset (eg. 2Hz) to be entered for that note.
If you do have one it's no more work or more difficult than normal tuning (for a 2-reed box -- with 3 reeds MMM there's no difference to "normal" tuning unless the offsets of the flat and sharp reeds are different)
Dirk's Tuner not only allows offsets (and simultaneous measurement of multiple reeds) but lets you do measurement in the box with tuning done outside it -- it measures the difference in frequency and allows for it.
http://www.dirksprojects.nl/index.php?Lan=english&Page=Tuner/accordion_tuner_22.php
It costs more than a cheap external tuner, but is capable of a lot more.
Ian
-
I've looked at Dirk's tuner several times but I can't do the tuning in the same room as the computer and I don't have a laptop. As an amateur I can't justify the expense of kitting myself out with that kind of gear to tune a box every so often. I tune concertinas as well and I recall reading somewhere that Dirk's tuner isn't too good for those.
The later Club III, such as the Club IIIM have a complicated mechanism which shares reeds between different chords, so for example the fifth of C/G (G/D) becomes the third of Eb/Bb, and the tonic of C/G becomes the fifth of F/C. Quite ingenious, but it it does rule out de-clubbing the chords.
Yes, I've since discovered that this is the case with the IIIB that I'm working on, so no blocking off the thirds or tuning them flat to sweeten the chords up. Bummer. :'(
-
I allowed myself to be distracted by a number of other things and only got as far as tuning a couple of the chord reeds before putting the old C/F Club 111 box in a corner for 18 months. It's now back out in the daylight and the basses and chords are all tuned, re-valved and back in the box, it's sounding quite good (on the bass end at least). I started on the treble end today, not difficult but pretty tedious.
I had no choice with the chords, they had to remain in Club tuning because of the reed sharing, but I'm wondering what to do about the gleichton. I find it cumbersome and really rather odd but the system does have its devotees so perhaps I should explore it more fully rather than just give up on it. In that case I'd rather have an extra three plates with C/D reeds in that I can swap about while I have a go at the Club tuning. Does anyone have three C4/D4 Hohner reed plates they would be willing to sell?
-
Does anyone have three C4/D4 Hohner reed plates they would be willing to sell?
A bit like rocking horse s**t, I would guess.
Your other option would be to try to get hold of three C#/C# reeds from a scrap accordion. You can tune one reed a semitone down to C and the other up to D. A semitone shift on each of them is not as drastic and scary as trying to tune the gleichton reeds from C/C to C/D.
-
Your other option would be to try to get hold of three C#/C# reeds from a scrap accordion. You can tune one reed a semitone down to C and the other up to D. A semitone shift on each of them is not as drastic and scary as trying to tune the gleichton reeds from C/C to C/D.
My other thought was to find three D/D reeds and get the soldering iron out ... ;D
-
I have de-clubbed two accordions now without any problems by tuning the C reeds up a whole tone. I used a conical dremel tool and removed a little 'dimple' of metal at the tip of the reed without involving the profile of the reed at the tip or sides. It worked well and seems very controllable to me and did not result in any funny harmonics that I could detect. So it can be done......
Michael
-
Does anyone have three C4/D4 Hohner reed plates they would be willing to sell?
A bit like rocking horse s**t, I would guess.
Your other option would be to try to get hold of three C#/C# reeds from a scrap accordion. You can tune one reed a semitone down to C and the other up to D. A semitone shift on each of them is not as drastic and scary as trying to tune the gleichton reeds from C/C to C/D.
That's what I did with my Club II, though of course I only needed to find 2 reeds; and of course, as it's in Bb/Eb I used B reeds.
-
Only six more reed plates to go and the C row tuning will be finished. Currently rooting through a pile of old PA reeds looking for the C# or D plates. I have to say I don't relish taking a power tool to the reeds so if I don't find the extra plates I need it will remain a Club box at least for the time being.
No more tuning now, it's Friday evening! :|glug
-
I agree about not wanting to rake a power tool to the reeds. I much prefer to use a nice sharp good quality file. Much more controllable.
-
I agree about not wanting to rake a power tool to the reeds. I much prefer to use a nice sharp good quality file. Much more controllable.
Or a garden tool for that matter >:E
-
Or a garden tool for that matter >:E
Arf, arf ;)
-
Or a garden tool for that matter >:E
Arf, arf ;)
Hoe Hoe ! ;D
-
The C row is now fully tuned and sounding good! In my rummaging around I found two D5 plates and 2 C#5 plates from a PA. Not sure if they'll match the apertures in the blocks but I'll check that out on Monday when I get a chance to look at the box again. I took some pics earlier and I'll try to put them up later this afternoon.
-
It's a bit red and erm, celluloid!
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Club%20111B/DSCN0584.jpg) (http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Club%20111B/DSCN0583.jpg) (http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Club%20111B/DSCN0581.jpg) (http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Club%20111B/DSCN0580.jpg) (http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Hohner%20Club%20111B/DSCN0582.jpg)
-
Joy of joys, my rummaging through various boxes of bits has yielded six D5/D5 six C#5/C#5 and six E5/E5 reed plates so I reckon I have enough to de-club the treble end of the box and retain the original C5/C5 plates provided the plates physically fit the Hohner blocks and allow the reeds to sound, the (Italian) reed plates are a tad longer, perhaps as much a 3mm. Fingers crossed! :|glug
-
Joy of joys, my rummaging through various boxes of bits has yielded six D5/D5 six C#5/C#5 and six E5/E5 reed plates so I reckon I have enough to de-club the treble end of the box and retain the original C5/C5 plates provided the plates physically fit the Hohner blocks and allow the reeds to sound, the (Italian) reed plates are a tad longer, perhaps as much a 3mm. Fingers crossed! :|glug
Hi Pete,
Please forgive me if I've misunderstood something or I have read something wrong (which is more than likely) but personally I would never mix German and Italian reeds unless it was for a seldom used accidental and even then it would be a last resort.
Martyn
-
Hi Pete,
Please forgive me if I've misunderstood something or I have read something wrong (which is more than likely) but personally I would never mix German and Italian reeds unless it was for a seldom used accidental and even then it would be a last resort.
Martyn
Hi Martyn,
You've not misunderstood anything or read anything wrong. I own both German made Hohners and Italian boxes and mixing the reeds from one to another wouldn't be my first choice but needs must as it were. A few PA reeds may suffer in the long run but I'll do my best to preserve the integrity of all parts involved in my experiments. The Hohner reeds will remain as they are apart from being re-tuned from A=435 to A=440, I hope that doesn't offend?
If you would like to donate a set of three Hohner C5/D5 reeds to the project they would be most welcome and may even buy you several strong beer tokens at a festival of your choice ...
-
Hi Pete,
Please forgive me if I've misunderstood something or I have read something wrong (which is more than likely) but personally I would never mix German and Italian reeds unless it was for a seldom used accidental and even then it would be a last resort.
Martyn
Hi Martyn,
You've not misunderstood anything or read anything wrong. I own both German made Hohners and Italian boxes and mixing the reeds from one to another wouldn't be my first choice but needs must as it were. A few PA reeds may suffer in the long run but I'll do my best to preserve the integrity of all parts involved in my experiments. The Hohner reeds will remain as they are apart from being re-tuned from A=435 to A=440, I hope that doesn't offend?
If you would like to donate a set of three Hohner C5/D5 reeds to the project they would be most welcome and may even buy you several strong beer tokens at a festival of your choice ...
A thought has just come to mind. Depending on your playing style - It would be possible to 'borrow' the Eb/C# from the accidental row, put a dab of solder on the tips to take them down to D/C, tune the C/C reed to B/C in the same way and put that in the accidental row giving a B on the push.
The tiny amount of solder used would have little or no effect on the reed response/sound.
Another option as suggested by Steve is to use C#/C# reeds from a Hohner PA of the same period tuning one a semitone up and one a semitone down. There are several options.
Martyn
www.melodeonrepairs.co.uk
-
Interesting suggestions there Martyn, I'll bear those in mind for further investigation but at the moment I'm going to use the Italian plates I have just to get the box playing. I'm almost half way through tuning the F row now and two of the gleichton plates have been tuned, re-valved and put away. They have been replaced using the PA D5 plates with one tongue on each tuned down to C with solder on the tips. I'm getting quite excited, I may have the whole thing finished in a week or so. :||:
-
I'm going great guns now and well into the third set of F row reeds, I've done the flat (-0.5 Hz) and the sharp (+3Hz) sets so this set is top dead centre. This set must have been the sharp set in A = 435 because they're almost on the button in tune at A = 440, just a slight tweak needed to get them up to scratch (geddit?) :|glug
I might be playing it by the weekend! ;D
-
Sounds like you are sailing through it now. I hope we are going to see a video or hear a soundclip when it's done.
Martyn
-
Sounds like you are sailing through it now. I hope we are going to see a video or hear a soundclip when it's done.
Martyn
Yes I can do that although I'm not a great player. Oddly enough I had a quick play yesterday with three voices on the C row and just one on the F row (amazing what a slip of paper under an unwanted reed block can do) and suddenly realised that the Club basses might be a bit of an obstacle. I thought I never used the lower two buttons nearest the bellows on the push (the ones that would be C in both directions on a D/G box) but now realise that I just might, now and again. This would mean my choice of tune to play might be pretty limited! ::)
-
The F row tuning is now finished so I have a fully functioning, playable two row. The hard thing now will to be to stop playing it long enough to tune the accidental row! I'm really surprised but it's obvious that I'm going to have to limit the travel of the treble keys, I thought that was a feature of the lower end Hohner models which this one obviously isn't. So with the row of seven to tune up, key travel to limit and another one or two minor jobs to do before it's allowed out in public (like adjusting a fixed bass end strap that cuts off the circulation to the left hand!) it will be a week or more before any recordings/videos will appear, if not a little longer ... :|glug
-
That's it then all done and dusted, fine tuning done, the treble action levelled and travel limited and I'm very pleased indeed with the results.
I'll try and put a video up sometime over the next week.
-
Two disappointingly brief sound files - I really must get to grips with my 'performance issues'. First up is the Club 111 C/F which has suddenly become very 'breathy' - I think I have a few gasket/pallet leaks to deal with now. ::)
Club C/F (http://soundcloud.com/peterdunk/club-3-cf)
Spurred on by my (perceived) success with this box I dragged out the original 'Old Hohner' box from this thread and spent a few more hours sorting out the remaining issues as best I could. Poor old lass I've treated her dreadfully but I think there's a year or two left in her yet. I normally play this across the rows but on a B/C box it's not an option so this is all on the C row and it sounds a lot wetter than I ever intended but I quite like it! :||:
Refurbishing an Old Hohner C/C# to B/C (http://soundcloud.com/peterdunk/hohner-bc)
Time to congratulate myself on a job half done methinks :|glug - oh, and yes, I do realise that I have to go over both boxes and pay a bit more attention to both the main tuning and the tremolo. :|bl
-
The old Club box is now out on loan to a morris dancing friend who is eager to add musical morbidity to his list of talents now that he's 69 and his two left feet keep colliding! >:E
-
Just bumping this back up to the top in light of recent discussions.
-
Bump! I'm sorry but I think there is so much accumulated knowledge in this one thread that it deserves to be dredged up from time to time!
-
Bump! I'm sorry but I think there is so much accumulated knowledge in this one thread that it deserves to be dredged up from time to time!
Quite! BUMP :)
-
*BUMP*
Back to the top again as a question has been raised in a new thread about this old thread by 911377brian. (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?action=profile;u=4920)Rather than clutter up that thread we'll continue here.
Just been following up your old post Pete.What paper did you use to re-cover the bellows?
It was a bookbinder's paper from a company called Shepherd's if I remember correctly, it had a textured finish rather like snakeskin. It's now deleted from the stock list I'm afraid but it is rather pretty and remains so to this day. The sound of the box is another matter though! (http://forum.melodeon.net/Smileys/classic/rolleyes.gif)
Thanks Pete.I'm experimenting with various types of paper at the moment; plenty of time for that as removing the old stuff is taking forever. Did you make a pattern for cutting or did you make each piece individually? (http://forum.melodeon.net/Smileys/classic/aemo_phewyellow.gif)
I used a rotary cutter in the Art Dept of the school where I work to quickly and accurately strip up the papers to the correct width, each strip was long enough for a long side and a short side. The vee cuts at the end were done with a scalpel on a cutting mat, all quick and easy.
-
Thanks Pete.
We have one of them there rotary cutters at work. I shall revisit it.
-
No problem Malcolm!
For those wondering what a rotary cutter is, there's one here. (http://www.amazon.co.uk/Avery-P1370-A0-Precision-Trimmer/dp/B000I2DUWU/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1458496371&sr=8-1&keywords=a0+paper+trimmer) The second picture gives a better idea how it's used.
-
Thanks, I was deeply embarrassed when I realised that I had unintentionally hijacked someone's thread Pete. I'm sure I can borrow a rotary cutter....
-
I'm sure I can borrow a rotary cutter....
No panic if you can't; I did my 2-row Koch entirely with a scalpel and steel rule. OK, a rotary trimmer is probably faster, but doing it by hand is at least as accurate - and somehow more satisfying!
Graham
-
OK, a rotary trimmer is probably faster, but doing it by hand is at least as accurate - and somehow more satisfying!
Graham
Agreed. I only used the rotary cutter for the long cuts, all of the angled cuts were made with a craft knife and steel rule against the markings on a cutting mat.
This post is also meant as a *bump* for a useful thread!