Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 [6]   Go Down

Author Topic: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...  (Read 34543 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Falseknight

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 449
    • False Knight
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #100 on: December 23, 2008, 07:19:05 PM »


I've never had a guitar or violin that is built of solid wood and has split open or warped. 

Then you're lucky.  Apart from the fact that acoustic instruments are cosetted in a way that melodeons are not, guitars and violins are depressingly prone to warping, distorting, cracking and breaking.  Look up "Dutch Belly" - a condition where the sound-table of an acoustic guitar develops a hump as the the material in the table creeps.  There is nothing you can do about it.  I've seen good violins implode as the temperature has changed.  I've seen longitudinal grain cracks run full length down the soundboard - none of this on cheap instruments.

If something is going to get hammered like a melodeon case, I want it to be robust, and bluntly, ply is going to keep me a working instrument for longer.
Logged

stillicidia

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 26
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #101 on: December 23, 2008, 08:28:22 PM »

usually guitars, violins harps etc are built from thin pieces of solid wood carefully matched so that the pieces are matched not only for looks but so that their parts expand and contract at the same rate in the same areas - if mismatched woods are used the instrument will warp badly - the soundboard itself needs careful bracing to stop the tension of the strings from warping the wood.
Better quality instruments have steel adjustable cores to their necks and adjustable bridges to allow strings to be kept at an optimal distance from fretboards etc.
plywood is designed to counteract the movement of one layer of wood by placing another - or several layers directionally opposed to the adjacent one so if layer 1 has grain travelling N/S the next layer will be E/W then N/S again - etc.
this is like layering fiberglass and is done for material stability but it does depend very much on the quality of the epoxy or other resin used for binding the layers.
So you can get stability from using designed structural stability in the material used or from the use of carefully matched materials - but you wouldn't build a lightweight stringed instrument using plywood because the layers and resin would weigh more than the thin soundboard material generally used (without even looking at the acoustic properties)
You can however build a robust instrument where you are not looking for acoustic quality.
I've seen some harps made from plywood and even the most expensive roudbacked harps utilise this form of manufacture - however the round back does alter the sound as it does not resonate due to having no flat flexible surfaces to resonate with. but round backs couldn't be made structurally stable or economically viable using solid wood -  its horses for courses or rather the correct selection of materials for the job that is being done.
Richard
Logged
Dyslexic fingers and deaf as a post!
member of accordions anonymous - I admit it I am an accordion addict!
it all started with just one! just a little one! then another, and another...

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #102 on: December 24, 2008, 11:35:41 AM »

Instead of the plywood used to construct so many boxes, why don't more builders opt for solid wood construction?  Is it to reduce costs?  I've never played a box that didn't have a laminated cabinet.  All materials absorb and diffuse sound waves differently, which together create the overall tone and volume of the box.  Wouldn't solid wood or even metal over a rigid frame allow more sound to escape from the box, or at least vibrate more consistently?  I understand how the instrument makes a sound is different, but I can't understand why the "sound box" characteristics of stringed instruments aren't experimented with when it comes to accordions.  It seems that with the exception of the cassotto and interior varnishing of some boxes, the principles of acoustic design are totally overlooked.

About reed block construction (something I know even less about..) -- what were the results of Hyde's experiments with foam and other materials?  I've always thought that making them out of metal would make the sound project more.




Given recent exchanges I'm going to resist answering this "soundboard" question -- any else want to have a go?

Ian

I wasn't referring to any "soundboard."  I was referring to the entire cabinet surrounding the reed blocks.  The effect of the "soundboard" on the overall sound is negligible almost by itself, but the cabinet through which all sound must pass is not.

I've never had a guitar or violin that is built of solid wood and has split open or warped. 

As I said earlier, very little sound travels *through* the cabinet material, it bounces round all the nooks and crannies inside and then makes its way out through the grill.

For anyone who still thinks otherwise, I encourage them to try the following.

Take a small tieclip microphone, connect it to something which will show sound level (a PC soundcard works fine), and while the box is being played move it all over the outside of the box keeping it just a couple of mm away from the surface so it picks up the sound from the surface and not the surrounding air.

You'll find out that almost all the sound comes from the grille, as expected. A small amount comes out through the bellows, which is what you'd expect given what they're made of and where the reeds are.

A negligible amount -- almost too small to measure, certainly so far below the sound from the grille that it's inaudible in comparison -- comes from the wooden ends of the box.

If sound doesn't pass through the box then it must be reflected back inside -- yes I know a very small amount will be absorbed, but a relatively rigid wooden box is a pretty good reflector of sound. So the shape and size of the box makes a difference because it forms a resonant chamber, but the material makes very little difference -- not zero, but *much* smaller than other things which dominate the sound.

On one of my visits to Castagnari they had several melodeons (Tommys I think) in their showroom (OK, front room of the house) made from different woods -- maple, walnut and some other reddish wood -- all presumably from the same manufacturing batch in the factory. I sat and played them all and couldn't tell any difference in the sound.

Ian

P.S. The Tommy body is made from solid wood, or certainly was then (mid 1980's) -- I should know, I bought one of them.
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #103 on: December 24, 2008, 11:42:35 AM »

Instead of the plywood used to construct so many boxes, why don't more builders opt for solid wood construction? 
Solid wood warps, checks and splits. Plywood is more stable. Also costs less!

Well that depends on the plywood -- Martyn Banks at Oakwood used veneered aircraft ply, which is many thin plies of birch with figured veneers on both surfaces (flamed birds-eye maple in my case), this is very strong and stable even when thin (a few mm).

What it certainly *isn't* is cheap -- when I asked him he pursed his lips and made that sucking-of-air sound that builders make when you ask them the same question, and said "If you need to ask, you can't afford it" :-)

Ian
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

Aaro

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 78
    • Luukinen Accordions
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #104 on: December 24, 2008, 12:08:36 PM »

    
Plywood is a good option.    
Good plywood is not easy to find, or else it needs to self-laminate.
   
I have done a couple of boxes of plywood and the experience is good.

Aaro
Logged
Luukinen Accordions offers a full line of fine handcrafted custom made accordions.

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #105 on: December 24, 2008, 01:06:04 PM »

   
Plywood is a good option.    
Good plywood is not easy to find, or else it needs to self-laminate.
   
I have done a couple of boxes of plywood and the experience is good.

Aaro

I see you used quite thick ply though (12mm?) so the box will be heavy since plywood is denser then most solid woods (glue is dense).

A much lighter construction (Oakwood used this) is to make all the edges of the box from strips of solid wood about the same thickness and then insert panels of much thinner ply to form the faces, the result is less than half the weight.

Ian
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

Aaro

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 78
    • Luukinen Accordions
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #106 on: December 24, 2008, 01:56:43 PM »



I see you used quite thick ply though (12mm?) so the box will be heavy since plywood is denser then most solid woods (glue is dense).

Ian

   
In fact, the box is made of about 3-4mm plywood.    
But the grill is a specified size so it needs to put the turnout strips of solid wood.
Therefore, it seems thick.
Logged
Luukinen Accordions offers a full line of fine handcrafted custom made accordions.

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #107 on: December 24, 2008, 02:01:33 PM »



I see you used quite thick ply though (12mm?) so the box will be heavy since plywood is denser then most solid woods (glue is dense).

Ian

   
In fact, the box is made of about 3-4mm plywood.    
But the grill is a specified size so it needs to put the turnout strips of solid wood.
Therefore, it seems thick.

Aaah, now I see -- your edge/panel construction looks very similar to my Oakwood, it's a very good way to make a light strong box.

Ian
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

Quebecois

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1206
  • Accordez-vous donc, c'est si beau, l'accordéon!
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #108 on: December 24, 2008, 04:52:21 PM »

I've never had a guitar or violin that is built of solid wood and has split open or warped. 
Lucky you!!! I know plenty of people who have expensive guitars and violins that eventually developed warping or splitting issues, due to the natural aging properties of the wood.
Logged
Hohner Morgane D/G, pre-Erica Hohner in C/F and G/C,
Hohner Erica A/D, Roland FR-18

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #109 on: December 24, 2008, 05:40:58 PM »

I've never had a guitar or violin that is built of solid wood and has split open or warped. 
Lucky you!!! I know plenty of people who have expensive guitars and violins that eventually developed warping or splitting issues, due to the natural aging properties of the wood.

And concertinas...

Ian
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

finnhorse

  • Guest
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #110 on: December 24, 2008, 08:29:43 PM »

I live in a very humid clime, not much danger from wood drying out, splitting, warping, etc... my concerns have been quite the opposite, actually.  That's probably the reason I've never been mutinied by a wooden instrument.  I often forget the rest of the world requires humidifiers in the winter, and more attention to some things.

In regard to other machinery, I'd trade year-round extreme operating conditions for an in-case humidifier any day!   ;D

But even in such a humid climate like England, is it very common for this to happen with flat panels of wood under little or no stress, such as those which would be used to construct a melodeon? 
Logged

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #111 on: December 25, 2008, 11:06:40 AM »

I live in a very humid clime, not much danger from wood drying out, splitting, warping, etc... my concerns have been quite the opposite, actually.  That's probably the reason I've never been mutinied by a wooden instrument.  I often forget the rest of the world requires humidifiers in the winter, and more attention to some things.

In regard to other machinery, I'd trade year-round extreme operating conditions for an in-case humidifier any day!   ;D

But even in such a humid climate like England, is it very common for this to happen with flat panels of wood under little or no stress, such as those which would be used to construct a melodeon? 

Simple answer -- no, not very common. But it all depends on how the box is built, how rigid the structure is, and how the joints are made -- it's nothing to do with the stress or age of the wood as such, just the change in humidity from when it was built or the wood was "seasoned" -- which just means drying it out to a known water content, usually about 15%.

Wood shrinks a surprising amount over changes in humidity (mainly) and temperature (much less so) -- solid wood shrinks and expands across the grain by about half the percentage change in humidity, so a 20% change in humidity causes 10% change in the width (this is similar for all woods) but almost no change in the length. This can either lead to the wood splitting or joints pulling apart. Plywood changes by less than half this amount but equally in all directions, so if you build a box out of this it grows and shrinks as a whole but doesn't pull itself apart.

I've seen concertinas which have suffered from warpage and shrinkage of the end plates and frames over a long period of time, but these are usually much older than most melodeons so maybe this is why we don't see such problems -- or melodeon ends are stronger structures, or the wood the concertina was made from was not properly seasoned, or glues are better nowadays. But strong glues won't stop the wood itself splitting.

Any change in humidity will take a long time to take effect, especially if the box is varnished, but will still happen eventually -- so if the box is made somewhere with medium humidity (Europe) and then taken to a place with either very low (desert) or very high (jungle) humidity and kept there for a long time (many years?) there will eventually be problems. If it stays in a similar climate (which may mean air conditioned, of course) then there won't be any problem.

Ian

P.S. I can't recommend this book highly enough for anyone interested in things like this, one of the best "popular science" (though definitely not "dumbed-down" as many are) books ever written IMHO -- even for non-engineers and non-scientists, I've lent my copy to friends who are a cabinetmaker and a guitarist and they both said the same (and then went and bought their own copies so they could re-read it):

The New Science of Strong Materials (or Why You Don't Fall Through the Floor)
J.E. Gordon
ISBN 0-14-013597-9
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

Aaro

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 78
    • Luukinen Accordions
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #112 on: December 25, 2008, 12:59:01 PM »

   
Personally, I have noticed a problem in the south of Europe accordion brought here to the north of Europe.
There has been much drier air, especially inside the country and Lapland.
So the problem comes to when the accordion begins to dry yet on what it is a country of origin.
Usually the problem is more chromatic accordion (5-row)
There will be leaks, reed blocks warped, sometimes becomes the body of the fault, treble the machinery behind the wood goes to cornering a treble on mechanical spring weighs. Often has had to build an aluminum back
These problems affect a lot of it is how dry the wood is in the country of origin where the accordion is made.

Of course, this dehydration / moisten can happen the other way around.

Plywood less to live in what is a relatively solid wood. Coating to reduce the living wood.

Good Instrument's  wood moisture needs to be really small. Wood needs to reclaim the outdoors for many years well protected around 5-10 years at least. After drying of the outer still recommend a couple of years, indoor drying.

Personally, I would like to reed block wood to be very dry. Sometimes, the above-mentioned manner. I still dry wood heat treatment. This measure, I have my own way which has produced a good experience.

    
When the box is glued, so the box would be good to give back to dry for some time. In fact, I give the box to dry for at least one month.
Then, the surface can do.
Even though today there are good glues.

When the new box will be the builder, so it lasts about two years before a box starts to unfold. So it starts to sound better.
   
In my view, wood, glue, varnish etc dehydration is one of the most important things Instrument Building
These have been my opinion in the field.

Aaro
« Last Edit: December 25, 2008, 01:12:56 PM by Aaro »
Logged
Luukinen Accordions offers a full line of fine handcrafted custom made accordions.

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #113 on: December 25, 2008, 02:53:02 PM »

   
Personally, I have noticed a problem in the south of Europe accordion brought here to the north of Europe.
There has been much drier air, especially inside the country and Lapland.
So the problem comes to when the accordion begins to dry yet on what it is a country of origin.
Usually the problem is more chromatic accordion (5-row)
There will be leaks, reed blocks warped, sometimes becomes the body of the fault, treble the machinery behind the wood goes to cornering a treble on mechanical spring weighs. Often has had to build an aluminum back
These problems affect a lot of it is how dry the wood is in the country of origin where the accordion is made.

Of course, this dehydration / moisten can happen the other way around.

Plywood less to live in what is a relatively solid wood. Coating to reduce the living wood.

Good Instrument's  wood moisture needs to be really small. Wood needs to reclaim the outdoors for many years well protected around 5-10 years at least. After drying of the outer still recommend a couple of years, indoor drying.

Personally, I would like to reed block wood to be very dry. Sometimes, the above-mentioned manner. I still dry wood heat treatment. This measure, I have my own way which has produced a good experience.

    
When the box is glued, so the box would be good to give back to dry for some time. In fact, I give the box to dry for at least one month.
Then, the surface can do.
Even though today there are good glues.

When the new box will be the builder, so it lasts about two years before a box starts to unfold. So it starts to sound better.
   
In my view, wood, glue, varnish etc dehydration is one of the most important things Instrument Building
These have been my opinion in the field.

Aaro

There's a lot of "folklore" about seasoning of wood, but all it comes down to in the end is removing moisture slowly enough that the wood doesn't crack or split, down to the same moisture level you want to use the wood at (maybe 15% humidity in central Europe, including UK). With "traditional" methods this can take a long time depending on thickness, a year or more for inch-thick (OK, 2.5cm :-) planks and much longer for thicker ones (2x thickness = 4x time).

Modern kiln drying *if done properly* will produce exactly equivalent wood (I believe this has been proved by musical instrument makers) much more quickly (days or weeks). The problem is it can't be done *by* instrument makers because of the equipment, and done by commercial wood suppliers there's always the temptation to save money by doing it too quickly or not waiting until the wood has stabilised to the final moisture content all the way through -- in this case I agree that the "traditional" method done with care is better, but this isn't due to any inherent superiority compared to kiln drying, the key is the care with which it's done.

I can see why the problem would be worse with a chromatic 5-row, it's just that the whole thing is bigger than a melodeon and so any shrinkage or swelling will be that much worse -- Lapland is dry (which is why you find that very dry wood is a good thing) so the wood will shrink. This will cause a problem anywhere that wood with grain in different directions is joined together, including reed blocks.

Varnish helps but no thin layer of varnish is impervious to water vapour, it just slows down the emergence of the problem rather than curing it. Modern glues are very strong and prevent the joints pulling apart because they're stronger than the wood, the problem then gets transferred to the wood which either splits or warps under the strain.

Using plywood "everywhere" would fix the problem, but this would have to include not just the case and "soundboard" but also the reed blocks and bellows frames. There might still be a problem with the mechanism if this is metal (I expect it always is on a 5-row chromatic?) and formed as normal in one piece (a single long metal frame with the levers mounted on it); the best way to fix this would be to break the mechanism up into sections each a few keys long which are individually screwed to the plywood body.

If all this was done I think there would be little or no problem with changes in humidity any more. But since most accordions and melodeons are made and played in regions with similar humidity (e.g. central Europe) I'm not sure that major manufacturers could be persuaded to make these changes just for the sake of the relatively few people in Lapland or the Far East who have these problems... :-)

Ian

P.S. For a small maker like yourself this is obviously not the case, you could build yourself a "climate-proof" melodeon :-)
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

Aaro

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 78
    • Luukinen Accordions
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #114 on: December 25, 2008, 08:33:45 PM »


Using plywood "everywhere" would fix the problem, but this would have to include not just the case and "soundboard" but also the reed blocks and bellows frames. There might still be a problem with the mechanism if this is metal (I expect it always is on a 5-row chromatic?) and formed as normal in one piece (a single long metal frame with the levers mounted on it); the best way to fix this would be to break the mechanism up into sections each a few keys long which are individually screwed to the plywood body.


   
After all, it is possible to make a plywood bellows frames, reed blocks and    
and all the parts the melodeon.    
Bass and treble mechanics to make of the metal.

Treble handle (keyboards), however, painted or in some way to the glued veneer. After all, some Hohner accordion made of plastic keyboars.

Quote
P.S. For a small maker like yourself this is obviously not the case, you could build yourself a "climate-proof" melodeon :-)
   
Yes, maybe I can do it sometimes ;D
Logged
Luukinen Accordions offers a full line of fine handcrafted custom made accordions.

finnhorse

  • Guest
Re: Melodeon construction -- some more radical thoughts...
« Reply #115 on: December 25, 2008, 08:44:23 PM »

Quote
If all this was done I think there would be little or no problem with changes in humidity any more. But since most accordions and melodeons are made and played in regions with similar humidity (e.g. central Europe) I'm not sure that major manufacturers could be persuaded to make these changes just for the sake of the relatively few people in Lapland or the Far East who have these problems... :-)

I remember someone on the forum commenting about the "stiffness" of the action in Weltmeister boxes.  After a visit to the factory in Klingenthal, he chalked up the problem to a difference in humidity; being far more humid in Ireland than in East Germany, the action would seize up after the wood swelled.  I'll look for the thread, I could be remembering this wrong.   
Logged
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 [6]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal