Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1] 2   Go Down

Author Topic: B/C or C#/D?  (Read 9380 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

waltzman

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 943
B/C or C#/D?
« on: March 11, 2009, 01:26:10 AM »

I would like to try one of the semi-tone systems and I've learned a lot about them from this forum.  Unfortunatly there are no opportunities for me to 'try before I buy' around here.  I play english concertina so the concept of 'white keys and black keys' like a piano is familiar and appeals to me about the B/C system.  On the other hand the people I play music with around here seem to overwhelmingly play in the key of D.  Would it be accurate to say that a C#/D box would be a lot more flexible in the key of D than the B/C?
Logged

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: B/C or C#/D?
« Reply #1 on: March 11, 2009, 08:51:09 AM »

I'm sure this question will generate a great deal of debate, but I'll just give one bit of information as food for thought.

In Irish music by far the most popular tuning is B/C, and its predominantly used for playing in D.  So I don't think its a matter of flexibility, after all both systems are chromatic.  Its more a matter of style.  Because the pushes and pulls come in different places on the scale of D the music can have a different feel when played on each system.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

TomB-R

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 598
Logged

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: B/C or C#/D?
« Reply #3 on: March 11, 2009, 11:10:35 AM »

this is indeed an interesting debate.  I can't see much advantage in a C#D  over a DG & certainly not over a Dg with some accidentals on 1/2 row.   With a DG  you get the built in bounce when playing on the row but tend to lose it when row crossing. BUt many DG players of Irish music cross row all the time to smooth things out!  With a C#D  you only get the bounce ( and the Bass)in D  & if wanting to play in other keys you are virtualy playing two completely different sytems. This can be quite confusing!

The BC  is more logical  exept for the fairly useless 8 bass.  The rare double ray delux with 12 stradella is in a different league and Bruce Lindsey  has a double ray delux  onto which has been transplaanted 48 stradella bass ( & they look as if they belong!) he can be seen playing this on the  dvd the button box in scotland - www.thane.co.uk.  Forgetting the somewhat limited normal BC bass the keys of BCFGDAare readily available & the progression through the keys is entirely logical i.e C row is the main road (or white notes) for all keys  and each key    other than B&C requires a 'diversion' onto the B row for the requisite number of 'black' notes.

I also find it much easier to read music onto a BC than on either a DG or any  of the hybrid systems  as apart from the duplicated  B & E  the notes are always in the same place & direction.


george
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

Lester

  • MADman
  • Mods and volunteers
  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 9327
  • Hohners'R'me
    • Lester's Melodeon Emporium and Tune-a-Rama
Re: B/C or C#/D?
« Reply #4 on: March 11, 2009, 12:09:41 PM »

George

Have you not missed out the B/C/C# is better and you need two straps bit  ;D

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: B/C or C#/D?
« Reply #5 on: March 11, 2009, 12:12:17 PM »

But as Theo said, it's a question of style. You would do well to listen to a selection of B/C players and a selection of C#/D players and decide which appeals to you most.

If you can borrow a halfstep box in any tuning - even C/C# - you can easily experiment with the different fingering systems.

Don't pay too much attention to the white keys/black keys analogy - playing the piano doesn't involve ducking under the keyboard and pushing the keys up ;) By which I mean that piano and button box are very different - you have an entirely new keyboard to get wired into your brain and very soon you'll get to a stage where trying to map the piano keyboard onto the button box keyboard is of no help at all, and probably a hindrance.

On the specific question of playing in D: it will be considerably easier, at least in the early stages, on C#/D than on a B/C. I would also point out that I have heard many recordings of B/C players playing D major tunes in the key of C, the most notable example being Joe Burke's famous rendition of Bonnie Kate. A tune that is supposed to exemplify the way that B/C can emulate the fiddle -  and he plays it in C... Try the tune in both fingering systems and you'll understand why.



waltzman

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 943
Re: B/C or C#/D?
« Reply #6 on: March 11, 2009, 12:26:55 PM »

On the specific question of playing in D: it will be considerably easier, at least in the early stages, on C#/D than on a B/C. I would also point out that I have heard many recordings of B/C players playing D major tunes in the key of C, the most notable example being Joe Burke's famous rendition of Bonnie Kate. A tune that is supposed to exemplify the way that B/C can emulate the fiddle -  and he plays it in C... Try the tune in both fingering systems and you'll understand why.

My thought was that in the key of D you can play a C#/D either up and down the row or across the rows thus leading to greater flexibility in that specific key.  The bidirectional notes of C# and F# would seem to me to be more useful in the key of D than B and E (on a B/C). 

Logged

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: B/C or C#/D?
« Reply #7 on: March 11, 2009, 12:55:46 PM »

Well of course I agree with you. Playing "across the rows" in D on C#/D seems like a bit of an overstatement, but the pull F# is exceedingly useful for linear passages, and the push C# to a lesser extent.

To qualify what I said about Joe Burke and Bonnie Kate - I just tried the tune in B/C fingering again and I think the reason he must play it in C is that the Michael Coleman fiddle version he is so famously emulating makes very heavy use of rolls on F#. Rolls on F#, which is on the outer row, are a bit of a bugbear for B/C players. The tune does involve a lot of mini-arpeggios in D, which is another initial difficulty when learning B/C, but that would hardly be a problem for a player of Joe Burke's skill.

I tend to think that in Irish music the B/C comes into its own, not in D, but in keys with one sharp, G major and particularly A dorian, where its great fluidity come into play with long passages "on the draw". I have found a couple of tunes in A dorian where in one entire section of the tune G is the only note you need to play on the press!

C#/D is happy in those keys too, BTW but with a much choppier sound. Question of preference, again.
« Last Edit: March 11, 2009, 12:57:39 PM by Steve Jones »
Logged

TomB-R

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 598
Re: B/C or C#/D?
« Reply #8 on: March 11, 2009, 01:31:50 PM »

It's a fascinating topic!  ;D

Bear in mind that :
- on B/C your basic one-octave scale of D is pull, push-push-push,pull-pull-pull pull.
- on C#/D you've lost one of your "bellows reversals" (C#) as soon as you go into G. Therefore....

To my mind, the crucial thing is your attitude to push-pull, bellows reversals.  I don't play C#/D but it seems to me the ideal C#/D tune is one where you are working the bellows totally in time to the rhythm of the tune, so almost with a reversal between every note!  ;D

On B/C, you've got that smoothness (particularly in D) with fewer bellows changes, BUT the rhythm then has to come from your right hand fingers, (like a piano-box or CBA player.)

On C#/D you've got the "easy" and familiar push-pull start on the D row for D tunes. Then you start "dabbing" across the rows to get into other keys. (I suspect C#/D players aren't that bothered about the reversals.)
With B/C you have to get your head around two rows from the start, (either by the black key, white key analogy, or by "shapes", triangles etc which work for some people, but not George G!)

(I won't cause distraction by mentioning the "other system" which I play that I think gives the best of both worlds, because there are so few boxes in that system.)
Tom
« Last Edit: March 11, 2009, 01:36:22 PM by TomB-R »
Logged

TomB-R

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 598
Re: B/C or C#/D?
« Reply #9 on: March 11, 2009, 01:40:53 PM »

Just to throw a bit more mud in the water, it's possible to play wonderful Irish music on the D/G, (if you are Tim Edey)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CMZZgEtoBbQ
but most people don't, they use the systems discussed here, and I can understand why.
Tom
Logged

Clive Williams

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3936
    • Home Page
Re: B/C or C#/D?
« Reply #10 on: March 11, 2009, 01:53:49 PM »

Just to throw a bit more mud in the water, it's possible to play wonderful Irish music on the D/G, (if you are Tim Edey)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CMZZgEtoBbQ
but most people don't, they use the systems discussed here, and I can understand why.
Tom


Quite some playing, but he is just playing the D row of a D/G, so not really that different to playing a C#/D for this tune, I suppose...  :||:

Cheers,

Clive

Owen Woods

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3894
  • melodeonmusic.com
    • The website and blog of Owen Woods
Re: B/C or C#/D?
« Reply #11 on: March 11, 2009, 01:56:21 PM »

Just to throw a bit more mud in the water, it's possible to play wonderful Irish music on the D/G, (if you are Tim Edey)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CMZZgEtoBbQ
but most people don't, they use the systems discussed here, and I can understand why.
Tom


That depressed me so much when I first saw it. What he does is now more comprehensible to me, thankfully, although I'm still some way off.
Logged
Bergflodt D/G 4 voice, Saltarelle Bouebe D/G, Super Preciosa D/Em, Hohner Impiliput B/C+C#

Latest blog post: In Any Weather

http://melodeonmusic.com/blog

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: B/C or C#/D?
« Reply #12 on: March 11, 2009, 02:17:44 PM »

Good points Tom but I'd take issue with a couple:

- on B/C your basic one-octave scale of D is pull, push-push-push,pull-pull-pull pull.

True. But don't forget that an awful lot of tunes in D are based, not around scales, but around arpeggiated sequences and on these the C#/D is _much_ smoother, make no mistake about that.

Quote
I suspect C#/D players aren't that bothered about the reversals.

The lazy variety, maybe - and I know a few such people! But anybody who tackles the instrument seriously is going to be making very heavy use of the "magic notes".

The other point to bear in mind is that they are really the same instrument. A B/C player playing, say, the Foxhunter's reel in G and a C#/D playing the same tune in A will be using exactly the same fingerings and bellows changes.

Ultimately the goal should be to master all the remotely practicable fingerings and - like Sharon Shannon (who plays the Holly Bush and the Silver Spire in E on her  C#/D) and Dermot Byrne (who plays Bunker Hill in B major on C#/D) and Joe Burke, Billy McComiskey, Martin Mulhaire, Josephine Marsh et al. (who play in C and other strange keys on their B/Cs when the fancy takes them) - play in whatever key you feel suits the tune best.

waltzman

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 943
Re: B/C or C#/D?
« Reply #13 on: March 11, 2009, 02:27:17 PM »

It's interesting to hear the opinion that 'smoother is better' for irish music on melodeon.  I play english concertina and in the concertina world I'm used to hearing strongly expressed opinions that you can't play irish on an english concertina because 'you can't get that bounce' like you can on an anglo.
Logged

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: B/C or C#/D?
« Reply #14 on: March 11, 2009, 03:19:20 PM »

I don't think anybody has come out of the closet and said "smoother is better" ;D

But there are limits to choppiness, as anyone who has experimented with really remote keys on a halfstep box can testify. It's all a question of where you want to draw the line and where you want what George G once memorably described as "random bounce" (with respect to a BCC# of course, but the term is useful in this discussion too) to happen.

Theoretically at least anglo concertinas allow a lot more reversals and a lot less choppiness than halfstep boxes btw.

TomB-R

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 598
Re: B/C or C#/D?
« Reply #15 on: March 11, 2009, 05:50:43 PM »

Just to throw a bit more mud in the water, it's possible to play wonderful Irish music on the D/G, (if you are Tim Edey)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CMZZgEtoBbQ
but most people don't, they use the systems discussed here, and I can understand why.
Tom


Quite some playing, but he is just playing the D row of a D/G, so not really that different to playing a C#/D for this tune, I suppose...  :||:

Cheers,

Clive

You may well be right Clive, hard to tell at that speed but it looked to me as if he's taking a fair few notes from the inner row.
Tom
Logged

melodeon

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1732
Re: B/C or C#/D?
« Reply #16 on: March 14, 2009, 12:19:32 AM »

So,  TomB-R,

What "sytem" do you play?

To further the B/C  or C#/D  question

If given the choice of one or the other for music besides and including Irish Trad;   what would be the choice ?

Think  Mairtin O'Connor or John Whelan they seem to be fluent on their respective choices  and then of course there is Sharron Shannon who plays either and more .. or Tim Eady who has just ordered a 3 row C#/D/D# Saltarelle Laurentide.

Then there is that British "whiz kid" (older now)  who switched form D/G to B/C 2 1/2 row and called D/G boxes ( and any other 4th apart boxes) toys.....he seemed to get around uite well in a variety of styles

So for the universal accordion ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
Logged

TomB-R

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 598
Re: B/C or C#/D?
« Reply #17 on: March 14, 2009, 12:50:54 PM »

D/D# - at pitch - no transposing.
(But it's very difficult and completely unfriendly and no-one should get interested in the very few D/D# boxes that are out there, thank you very much!!!)  ;D
 
Give us a clue as to the "whiz kid"......

Tom
Logged

melodeon

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1732
Re: B/C or C#/D?
« Reply #18 on: March 14, 2009, 04:12:36 PM »

I know of, but have not met, 3 D/D#  players on the west coast (USA)    Mairtin O/Connor on " Perpetual Motion"  certainly rips on a D/D#.


I passed up a 4 reed  older Paolo in D/D# because iof the weight with its 9 switches.  The sound was fantastic.



Said whiz kid is no longer a kid and fancies himself as a composer/musical dierctor.

I phoned him years ago and was put off by his arrogance and elitism and generally bad attitude.  So much for idiolisation. Lost all interest immediately.
« Last Edit: March 14, 2009, 11:16:51 PM by melodeon »
Logged

EeeJay

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 642
  • Old Grey Paolo
Re: B/C or C#/D?
« Reply #19 on: March 14, 2009, 09:12:07 PM »

D/D# - at pitch - no transposing.
(But it's very difficult and completely unfriendly and no-one should get interested in the very few D/D# boxes that are out there, thank you very much!!!)  ;D

Oh yes indeed... or the G/G#s for that matter... don't want to go round confusing people now... ;)
(and there's one on eBay at the moment)


Said whiz kid is no longer a kid and fancies himself as a composer/musical dierctor.

I phoned him years ago and was put off by his arrogance and elitism and generally bad attitude.  So much for idiolisation. Lost all interest immediately.

Oh, now then... I think I know who you mean. This fella, right?

that British "whiz kid" (older now)  who switched form D/G to B/C 2 1/2 row and called D/G boxes ( and any other 4th apart boxes) toys.....

What a load of pretentious tripe. >:( I simply hate this kind of snobby system superiority.  >:( >:(

Stephane Milleret or Norbert Pignol might disagree just as strongly...

Ed J
Logged
Pages: [1] 2   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal