I received in the mail today a customer's old, pre-WWII 2-row Hohner for repairs. Given the age, I assumed it was going to be in very rough shape, but upon receiving the box I was surprised to discover it in almost unused condition! It is an absolute beauty of a box and has a wonderful, sweet tone that I would say is unrivaled by later Hohners. It's pretty airtight and decently in tune, considering the age, however it does need all new valves and a proper tuning. Instead of wax, I found that the individual zinc reedplates were screwed down onto a leather gasket. Would this have been original? I was also surprised to discover the tuning of the on-pitch reeds to be averaging around 440. Would this tuning have been used at the time? The owner says he acquired the instrument along with its original instruction booklet, and that it is from 1929. I can't confirm this, but I've attached a photo and maybe someone else can?
The customer sent the accordion for a tune-up and to fix any other issues that I could find. At the time I told him it was quite likely that it would need a full overhaul, but now I'm not so sure. What I am wondering is how much of it I should refurbish at this point...I would like to retain the tonal quality of the instrument, so I don't wish to replace the gasket material with wax. Currently, the leather material that is fitted on the blocks seems to be doing its job...is it necessary to replace this? Under normal circumstances I probably would anyway, but I haven't got any on hand and it would take several weeks at least to get some in, not to mention I've never used it before. In this case, if it's working, might it be OK to just leave it as it is? The reedplates pop off and the gasket material stays intact.
Given that the instrument appears to already by fairly airtight, would there be good reason to replace the leather/felt on all of the pallets? They are currently not leaking any air, so unless the owner of the instrument is interested in quietening the action, could it just be left as it is? Althought it's not leaking, the bellows gasket material looks worn and so I will replace this regardless.
I guess I'm wondering what best practice is in a case like this...it really is a wonderful instrument, and I'm hesitant to do any unnecessary work. Thoughts?