Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: 3-row 4th apart vs 2row + Acc row  (Read 933 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Ben

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 61
  • Hohner G/C, Pokerwork D/G, B/E, Club IIIB S C/F,
3-row 4th apart vs 2row + Acc row
« on: August 30, 2024, 02:28:58 PM »

I know that 3row (e.g. GCF, ADG, CFBb) is very common around the world - at least on the marketplaces! - but I am having a hard time understanding the advantage of having say GCF vs GCAcc.  It seems to me that the accidental row gives a lot more options in terms of reversals, new notes that you don't get on a 3row 4th apart.  Even in the chording style of play, it doesn't look to my eyes like the GCF layout offers many - if any - advantages.  But given the popularity of the system, I must be missing something.

Help me, Mel.net, you're my only hope!
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: 3-row 4th apart vs 2row + Acc row
« Reply #1 on: August 30, 2024, 04:06:24 PM »


    A 3 row 4th-apart "can" be played in "off piste" keys, but most people buy them to play in the main row keys, or their relative Minors. The left end is usually set up appropriately for that.

    An accidental row alliws you to reach a lot more base scales, at the price of having those scales follow a rather odd zig-zag pattern between the three rows.  Most of what you do ends up "on the pull" and you get a rich gamut of right-hand chords.   

     You want that "accidental"  3rd row to be as different from the other two rows as possible. e.g My kit is based on the C# D and G diatonic scales with C# just a semi-tone away from D, and a  "devils interval" (3-tones) away from G. That is as alien as you can get.

    It can play in virtually any key (with a bit of difficulty and a lot of practice). In one festival we played played tunes in every key apart from Ab (which it really hates)!  Its favourite is (surprisingly) Bb, be that major, minor, bebop or blues! And it's very, very fluent in C (major or minor).  Both of those keys suit my singing voice well 👍

    Accordion layouts should always reflect the way that you play. If you like playing on a row, then get the 4th-apart version. if you are into improvising, or play with other musicians who like to explore a lot of keys then you should get the one with full accidentals.
« Last Edit: August 30, 2024, 04:13:12 PM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: 3-row 4th apart vs 2row + Acc row
« Reply #2 on: August 30, 2024, 07:21:07 PM »

It all depends on the music you play, and on your approach to harmony.

A three row instrument in three keys if functional is you play mainly diatonic tunes in the home keys, or in the related modal scales. Of course you have more accidentals available than on a two row instrument. The three scales give you nine notes out of the twelve of the chromatic scale, and the number of the chin accidentals, assuming the outer row is the longer one (not the case with the Hohners), and considering you can use the push note on the stand second button of the outer row, that's usually too low in pitch to be of any melodic use, goes up to seven notes. Not bad at all, even if of course the melodic flexibility can't compare with the one offered by a fully chromatic two row + accidentals.

The advantage with those instrument is that the all the notes of the scale of the middle row are available both pushing and pulling the bellows, so with them you really can use all the available chords  -all the time - the way you want. The other two keys, that are just a whole tone apart, have both some limitations, yet different ones, then usually a tune that's hard to harmonize in one of them will work pretty well in the other. The harmonic flexibility of a three row instrument in three keys, once/if you've got the hang of it, is terrific, and no two row + accidentals instrument can match it.

The two row + accidentals are usually tailored to the competent players, and mainly they are meant to be played in some major keys outside the home ones and in the related tonal minor keys, although is worth considering than they remain melodeons, so they aren't really suited for music of a real chromatic nature. And yes, they offer more accidentals and in easier to reach positions, but that's not true for the reversals, even in the home keys. Which and how many other keys depends on both the the right hand and the left hand keyboard layouts. Unfortunately, most of those who buy those instruments simply choose the layout conceived by this or that popular player, but lacking  his competence, so they use them mainly as two row instruments using sparingly the accidentals and the reversals.

Another thing to consider: a three row instrument in three keys is based on the keyboard layout of the high pitched corresponding two row box. A G/C/F box  can be seen as a C/F instrument with an additional G row, but not as G/C instrument with an additional F row. On the G/C the unitonic chord – the C of the D/G – is the F chord, and is mainly played pulling the bellows, while in the G/C/F it is available just on the push. That's actually why the G/C/F was adopted, for instance, by the Norteno players, who had inherited the C/F and their repertoire from the German immigrants, but no French /continental G/C player would take it into serious consideration.

In the end, if you play English music on the D/G, go for an A/D/G, and you'll never egret it. You won't be able to play in A major in a session that's dominated by the two row d/G boxes, but you will make anyway your life easier, and if you had to team with a fiddler or an English concertina player they'll go bananas! If you play French music, and you like the musette standards, a G/C based two and ½ or three row instrument would be a far better choice. Or just play both the systems...

Logged

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: 3-row 4th apart vs 2row + Acc row
« Reply #3 on: August 30, 2024, 07:28:42 PM »

PS I forgot to add that a fourth button start layout on a three row instrument in three keys is a nonsense.  :(


« Last Edit: August 30, 2024, 10:07:48 PM by GBbox »
Logged
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal