Why Frankenstein an Innocent Accordion?I've wanted a foot-powered shruti box for ages, to play drones while I play other instruments. Initially this was so I could make solo low whistle sound a bit more interesting, but this has expanded into various other combinations over time. I borrowed a cheap shruti box last year, but was unimpressed with it (it was so loud that you could barely hear the whistle). Maybe a more expensive shruti box would be better, but I didn't really fancy shelling out ~£400 to find out.
A while ago, I bought the cheapest Hohner Student piano accordion I could find on eBay so that I could use the bellows to build a tuning table. This left me with a bellows-less accordion sitting on the shelf as an ornament, until I recently decided to try and convert it into a drone box.
I came across
a video of someone using cheap blower fans to make a drone instrument using slide flutes, which gave me the idea of using an electric fan to power my drone box.
This is the fan I ended up buying. It's a 12V 97mm x 33mm Centrifugal Blower Fan with Adjustable Speed Controller.
Making the Accordion Air TightAir tightness is still important for this box, albeit slightly less important than if I were playing it as a traditonal accordion. The more leaks there are, the higher the fan speed needs to be to make the reeds sound, and the noisier the fan gets.
Given that my accordion had no bellows, I needed to find a way to attach the treble and bass ends together. I conveniently still had the original bellows frame for the treble end, so I used liquid hide glue (more reversible than PVA) to glue the treble bellows frame onto the bass end. This allows me to still use the original bellows pins to attach/detach the treble end to access the insides. If you still had the original bellows, you wouldn't need to do this step.
If I was going to play this accordion normally it would ideally need a new set of valves, but because the air supply only works on the push, I decided to tape off all of the pull reeds instead to reduce air leakage. Likewise the pallets would ideally be refaced, but because I'm not opening & closing them mid-tune I can get away with leaving them as is.
Connecting the Air SupplyThis was the most challenging part of the project. I've been trying to avoid making any irreversible changes to the accordion (other than the bellows changes I'd already done), so I decided to unscrew the air button mechanism and use the original air hole to connect my air supply.
For the initial prototype, I used a section of bike inner tube stretched over the fan output and then taped inside the air hole on the accordion. This was good enough to prove that the fan worked and that I liked the sound the box made. The biggest problem was that the inner tube had to be kept perfectly straight, because the fan wasn't powerful enough to straighten out any kinks in the hose. This meant I ended up with the fan dangling from the bottom of the accordion, which looks rubbish, is quite fragile, and can be heard when recording the drone box.
For a more long term solution, I bought 3 metres of 19mm braided PVC hose, a pack of miscellaneous hose barb connectors and some metal hose clamps. This works much better than inner tube and lets me get the fan further away from the box, and gives me better options for how to connect it all together. I chose a hose with a 19mm inner diameter because that matched the diameter of the air hole. I was hoping that I could just stick a hose barb through the hole and use a bit of hot glue to seal it up. This sort of worked, but the weight of the hose dangling from the connector caused the barb to loosen and break the seal.
My third (and hopefully final) hose connection idea was to glue a section of my PVC hose into a small wooden block (using Araldite epoxy), and then to glue the wooden block inside the accordion (using hide glue). This provides a lot more support to the hose connector than the hot glue did, and hopefully if I ever need to remove it then the hide glue should be water soluble. Because it uses the same PVC hose as the rest of the air supply, I can just use another plastic hose barb to connect my full air hose to the little adapter inside the air hole. This also means I can easily remove the hose connection and reattach the air button mechanism if I wanted to (while leaving my support block in place inside). It's still early days on this connection but it's looking promising so far (I'll update this post if I end up changing it again).
Playing Some DronesNow that I have an air supply, I need to have some reeds. Because my box has no bellows, the interior space is limited. This means I can either have 2 treble reed blocks, or 1 treble reed block and 1 bass reed block. By sheer luck, it works out that the 1 treble reed block plays all the white notes on the keyboard (except F), and the bass block gives me D, G, C, F basses. This seems like a good combination allowing some good options.
It was conveniently easy to tune the reeds. No need to tune the pull reeds on the inside of the block, which are always a bit fiddlier than the push reeds, and no need for a tuning table because I can just leave the air supply running and lift the whole treble end off to tune the reeds without removing the blocks. I went for approximately a 2hz tremolo which is generally my preference, but it does sound a bit too similar to my melodeon. In future I'd like to add a stop to take out the tremolo reeds for more sound options.
For now, I'm using some small clamps to hold the keys down. I haven't worked out a good way to hold the bass buttons down yet.
DemosHere's a little video showing the box in action. It was made before my recent air connection improvements, the hot glue connection has been replaced now.
And here's a video of me playing a tune with it. This was before I added the tremolo reeds back in and upgraded the air supply.