If done properly it will usually give a brighter sound.
Rees,
I have seen boxes where retuning from C/C# to C#/D was done by tuning up every reed tongue, leaving the reeds extremely thin at the tips. Although they were functioning well, my concern is that little metal was left for maintenance tuning as will always be necessary over the future life of that set of reeds.
I'm not much of an accordion tech, much more comfortable with concertina tuning. As a concertina tuner and player I strongly prefer reed tongues that are not too thin at the tips. So to carry this perspective over to the accordion question (perhaps inappropriately?) I tend to like the idea of moving the inside row reeds to the outside row and putting new reeds in for the inside row.
Always learning though, so I appreciate your different point of view that comes from more accordion experience.
PG