Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 [2] 3   Go Down

Author Topic: Why or why not D/C#?  (Read 8980 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

boxcall

  • You got to love it!!!
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1801
Re: Why or why not D/C#?
« Reply #20 on: January 08, 2012, 09:24:51 PM »

A couple more thoughts on D/C#. . .

Re: playing "outside-in," another issue with many 2 row boxes (or even some 1 row boxes) is that the outside row of buttons is too close to the keyboard edge for playing comfortably.  It's nice to have the outside row buttons located in a bit from the keyboard edge, although of course you can add a spacer there as many players do.*  The outside row of the O'Byrne DeWitt Paolo Soprani that I illustrated above is a little close to the edge for comfort!  The outside row of the grey Sonola shown below is a little better placed for using that as a main row, IMO, and this Sonola also has a nice crisp tone on the outside row for that style of playing . . . but on the other hand, the Sonola is fairly big and bass-side-heavy.  

PG

* See the article linked below for a photo of the late William Sullivan, RIP, one of many players who added a spacer to the keyboard edge of his accordion (in his case, a one-row Baldoni-Bartoli).  This article also illustrates some other D and  D/C# Irish-American boxes.:

http://www.nyfolklore.org/pubs/voic36-3-4/accordion.html





Nice article on irish accordions, love looking at boxes with so much craftsmanship and detail.
I find my thumb could use spacer as it sits more to back top corner which isn't comfortable and it wants to slip off when clammy.
William Sullivan had some big fingers ( looks like a good inch of wood as a spacer maybe a 2x4  (:) ) and a great big smile to boot.


I definitely would like to have D outside row.  Since I'am learning on a one row four stop in D (Silvetta brand) and think going to the inside row to get notes needed to play fully in forth and fifth away an maybe in other keys as well would work for me . But I don't know how well I would do crossing rows as I'am still trying to get the up and down part .


PGroff   I would love to get my arms on one of those  ( Baldoni or Walters) 15 / 19 key D /C# but I think I would have to give an arm to get
it. (wonder if the'll take a leg)
thanks for the info.

Michael

Logged
Hohner 1040 C, Beltuna one row four stop D, O'Byrne Dewitt/ Baldoni bros. D/C#, Paolo soprani "pepperpot" one row D

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Why or why not D/C#?
« Reply #21 on: January 08, 2012, 09:42:13 PM »

Hi Michael,

Well, unrestored but maybe playable D/C# boxes are sleeping in attics and closets around the Boston area.  A concertina student of mine brought one in one day -- friends of his had just bought a house and they found, abandoned in the basement,  an O'Byrne DeWitt Baldoni D/C# complete with the Jerry O'Brien tutor and tune book . . . a relic from the old Dudley St. days.  Ask around, and ask all your friends to ask around.  Even a fully overhauled one at full retail price, such as the very nice D/C# sold by the Button Box a year or two ago, seems a great value to me given the cost to make one today and its historical meaning.   The box you are playing on now may possibly be wasting some of the value of the time you are investing, if it is slowing your progress.  A good instrument to learn on is an item of lasting value that might give you more enjoyment over the years than many other purchases.  :-)

PG
Logged

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: Why or why not D/C#?
« Reply #22 on: January 08, 2012, 09:53:41 PM »

The part of the original question that is not being answered is "why not D/C#"? There must be some arguments, but never having had the opportunity to try a D/C# I can't imagine them.

A few years ago a (very proficient) D/C# player joined one of Jackie Daly's classes at the Catskills week. I remember him pointing out to her some of the things in his playing that she couldn't do on her box, but unfortunately that's all I can remember. Don't think it was just a question of rolls though.

Of course everyone tends to advocate his or her own system as the best, just as everyone in the world thinks of his or her language as the most expressive, poetic, precise, etc. just because they know that system or language well and are unaware of all the possibilities of all the others. As I get more proficient on an inside-out system (C#/D) I find the placement of the accidentals to be felicitous. Quite a few of the funkier, accidental-laden tunes I have attempted recently (in keys that are otherwise D-row centred) seem to involve lots of downward (and sometimes back upward again) semitone dips, and these are wonderfully simple to execute inside-out.

I have tried some of these tunes in D/D# style and the same facility isn't there because the downward dips usually involve a change of bellows direction. (I suppose there must be tunes that call for lots of upward semitone shifts, and these would suit D/D# better; but I haven't come across any.)

In D/C# the same facility for these downward dips ought to be there, although whether the finger movements are quite as easy I don't know.

Of no consequence if you aren't exploring funky, accidental-laden tunes, of course, but I'd be interested to hear Paul's and André's thoughts on the suitability of the D/C# system for these. Of course Joe Derrane does plenty of them, but how much, if anything, of his choppy sound (which I for one don't aspire too) is down to the mechanics of playing outside-in?

And what are the other possible arguments against having the C# row inside?

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Why or why not D/C#?
« Reply #23 on: January 08, 2012, 10:25:19 PM »

Hi Steve,

For whatever my opinion is worth, I like to hear Irish music played on all the accordion key systems.  However, Hasse, and then Michael (boxcall) both mentioned they are considering a semitone box to play from an outside row in D, and Michael likes the sound of the (1 row) melodeon. So for those guys, D/D# or D/C# would seem to make sense.  Those systems play from a D outside row, and D/C# boxes especially often tend to have a powerful, crisp, bright tone on the outside row.

Michael in particular is really lucky to have one of my favorite box players as a teacher, and this guy plays 1-row box and D/C#.  That's a great opportunity for Michael, if I were him I would get a D/C# just to make the most of it.  Also, despite the influence of Joe Derrane and some great younger players, I worry that the D/C# style is a "threatened if not endangered species" and for the sake of that tradition, I always try to encourage folks to give it a try!

No offense intended to the great players and boxes of other key systems!

PG
Logged

Andrel

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 246
Re: Why or why not D/C#?
« Reply #24 on: January 08, 2012, 11:11:58 PM »

Steve,
  The downward dips you are talking about would indeed require more work on a D/C#, but with practice they are no more difficult. I remember spending quite a bit of time on tunes in F, Dmin, Gmin and Cnat to get the hang of it, reaching down on the inside row for the low accidentals. Not the C#/D players' preferred keys, either.On balance, I still prefer the D/C# system, though. (Although I don't think there's a best system, and I have taken up the CBA, which allows you to do everything, but not quite with the same punch).
   Regarding Joe Derrane's playing, I wonder if he would sound quite the same on a C#/D. Playing those triplets unencumbered on the outside row does make a difference. You can try practicing a triplet-laden tune that's usually played in D on the C# row for instance. But then of course, it doesn't seem to bother Sharon Shannon one bit.

Andre
Logged
Bertrand Gaillard D/C#, Acadian in C, Castagnari Ciacy
B/C, Castagnari Sharon D/C#

ceemonster

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 108
Re: Why or why not D/C#?
« Reply #25 on: January 09, 2012, 06:37:07 AM »

[I definitely would like to have D outside row.]  why? given that basses usually match the inner row--do you have a desire for a black-key bass configuration? that's the only reason i can think of.

granting that i'm not enamored with "on the row" style right now, even so---why not c#/d if that's what you want? i'm with jackie daly on this. there is nothing about the outer row that facilitates ornaments, IMHO, and my experience is the same as the other poster---teetering on the outer edge can actually be awkward for intricate ornaments.....

i did spend much of the afternoon today learning "otter's holt" in flat keys on the c row and then on the b row of my b/c, and i will say it was really fun....the usual b-minor version is a "between the row" setting on b/c, and that is fun too....
 
Logged

mory

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 752
Re: Why or why not D/C#?
« Reply #26 on: January 09, 2012, 08:26:39 AM »

What you practice is what you get. Plain & simple.



Seems like there is a lot of wanting every thing defined before we start or needing to emulate particular players (not in this post but in general) I don't believe all these renowned players started this way, what about the voyage of discovery, its this needing to fit thing, pick up a box and go with it I'm sure that's how most of the spice gets into the playing.

Boxcall hope one falls in your lap but in the mean time your developing your art so good call. All the Best mory.
« Last Edit: January 09, 2012, 08:40:20 AM by mory »
Logged

boxcall

  • You got to love it!!!
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1801
Re: Why or why not D/C#?
« Reply #27 on: January 09, 2012, 04:36:15 PM »

What you practice is what you get. Plain & simple.

Boxcall hope one falls in your lap but in the mean time your developing your art so good call. All the Best mory.

I agree with that! 10,000 hours to get good at something for most of us no matter what the system is ! ( stay on topic )
thanks for the support Mory

[I definitely would like to have D outside row.]  why? given that basses usually match the inner row--do you have a desire for a black-key bass configuration? that's the only reason i can think of.


I thought most boxes have basses to match both rows ?  with variations in set up.
Having never played a two row system my reasons would be access to a good teacher and the ability to expand on some thing I already know. Finding I need C nat to often ,I can sometimes fake around it not sounding to bad and still maintaining rhythm. Am tunes and the like could be played on a one row in the right key but I would like to have a box that I could play most session tunes on with out having to fumble around during a set  to get the right melodeon.
Really haven't put time in to the bass end still getting comfortable with the melody side.

Squeeze Ya!
Michael
Logged
Hohner 1040 C, Beltuna one row four stop D, O'Byrne Dewitt/ Baldoni bros. D/C#, Paolo soprani "pepperpot" one row D

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: Why or why not D/C#?
« Reply #28 on: January 09, 2012, 07:35:20 PM »

Finding I need C nat to often .........t I would like to have a box that I could play most session tunes on with out having to fumble around during a set  to get the right melodeon.

Any system where you have two rows a semitone apart has all the notes to play in any key, it is as Mory says just a matter of learning to play the thing.
of is that push/pull boxes are limited instruments and usually there is range of keys where they work well and as you get further away from those keys the fingering gets less intuitive, and you begin to run out of basses.  So choosing a box is always going to involve some compromises and you have to work out which compromises you can live with.

I feel sure George will be along shortly to say that B/C/C# gives you the ability to play all notes and chords, which is true but at the expense of a bigger, heavier box, which is also the case if you go for piano accordion or CBA.   You pays your money and you takes your choice!
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: Why or why not D/C#?
« Reply #29 on: January 10, 2012, 12:04:08 PM »

[ ]I feel sure George will be along shortly to say that B/C/C# gives you the ability to play all notes and chords, which is true but at the expense of a bigger, heavier box, which is also the case if you go for piano accordion or CBA.   You pays your money and you takes your choice!
[/quote]



Here I am!  As Theo has said the B CC# is chromatic in a practical sense as opposed to most 2 row + row of accidental systems that get progressively less logical as one tries to find a way round all 12  major keys. I presume by 'all athe chords' Theo is refering to the stradella bass end. Some boxes such as the 12x4 Casali  do not haave 7th or diminished chords on the bass end and the lightweight hohner trichord only has major & minor chords  from F to E.  As to the treble end it is i;mpossible to plaay the range of chords that  can be done on a piano or continental box as this would at times require the ability to come and go at the same time!  This is however only a problem to dot readers who have a burning desire to play some odd arty farty right hand chord  that is notated - it is always possible to find a suitable alternative that may well sound as good or even better!


The problem with push/pull bass on a 2 row box is that it is mathematically impossible to provide  harmony for more than a few keys & it is for that reason that I am experimenting with 8 thirdless  ( & also am going to try 8 fifthless chords )same both ways Bb,F,C,G,D,A,E,B.  which would provide  a bit of accompanyment in keys FCGDAE


My contention is that whilst this set up  is far from perfect it will be a considerable improvement on bugger all!

george
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: Why or why not D/C#?
« Reply #30 on: January 10, 2012, 03:55:37 PM »

You took the bait, George... The man is asking about why or why not a left-hand drive minivan and you are recommending a (right-hand drive) London double-decker bus!  >:E 

Hasse

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 323
Re: Why or why not D/C#?
« Reply #31 on: January 10, 2012, 07:15:36 PM »

What you practice is what you get. Plain & simple.

Exactly!!! That is why I shouldn't keep on my unhealthy interested in the dark side of two-row playing.  ;)

The part of the original question that is not being answered is "why not D/C#"? There must be some arguments, but never having had the opportunity to try a D/C# I can't imagine them.

A few years ago a (very proficient) D/C# player joined one of Jackie Daly's classes at the Catskills week. I remember him pointing out to her some of the things in his playing that she couldn't do on her box, but unfortunately that's all I can remember. Don't think it was just a question of rolls though.

Of no consequence if you aren't exploring funky, accidental-laden tunes, of course, but I'd be interested to hear Paul's and André's thoughts on the suitability of the D/C# system for these. Of course Joe Derrane does plenty of them, but how much, if anything, of his choppy sound (which I for one don't aspire too) is down to the mechanics of playing outside-in?

And what are the other possible arguments against having the C# row inside?

My first thought was that the difference between C#/D and D/C# was marginal, and the choice of system was probably ruled by habits and local tradition. But then I wondered why there aren't more D/C# players around, (because I thought it most be more practical with the D on the outside)? Was it the accordion factories that stopped making D/C#boxes or does it all just come down to more people prefer playing inside-out than outside-in? 

When it comes to semitone boxes, (as indicated above), I'll have to keep the real playing to all you folks really dedicated to semitone boxes. But If I ever come across the right reeds or box, I would very much like to give the D/C# system a try. Unfortunately I thought I had the perfect reeds laying around, but much have been swapping too much lately, arrgh! ::) (New concertina and a flute!?!?)
Logged
Sweden, Skåne

mory

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 752
Re: Why or why not D/C#?
« Reply #32 on: January 10, 2012, 08:11:22 PM »

I think its all about markets as you say, there is a link around some where to Joe Deranne talking about the demise of the dance halls in Boston and the end of his early 2 row playing. I think being quite a specific market the "Irish American" DC#  layout came to more or less an end then, the "Irish" market being driven from differing directions BC DD# C#D and earlier CC# I think the real push with C#D comes into full swing a little later all driven by who was heard, what media was available, local custom, teaching, basically the influence of the day. We have some great historians on here and lots has already been posted, with lots more to come I hope. So I think the why is as a development from the one row the why not is purely the end of an era* and as a personal note, Why not indeed, if it was the box in your hands you'd learn it or not as the case may be, they are certainly good fun, I think they all have their merits and naturally push playing in certain directions the layouts are a large part of defining what comes out of them


*not quite 'cause Joe's been back for 16 years now and there's definatly been more made and old ones revived since, I realise your question is directed more to the technical side but I think this survival issue is very relevant , if it had survived on mass there would be no question of appropriate or inappropriateness it would just BE as the others are, AtB mory      [quote What you practice....


Incidently I walked into a music shop in Canada about 12 years ago and there were 4 of them 3 Paolos and a Walters all DC# and a couple of BC's at the time I was a one man one box type so no more than curiosity huh!
« Last Edit: January 10, 2012, 08:25:40 PM by mory »
Logged

Lars

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 797
Re: Why or why not D/C#?
« Reply #33 on: January 10, 2012, 11:24:56 PM »

A few point I think are interesting in this context:

1: As for playing, I have tried a handful of nice D/C#'s, and I have owned and played one myself (being mainly a C#/D player). I think it's great fun to play, especially since I tend to play with less ornamentation and more bounce. I don't think it's any harder going outside-in than inside-out, once you've gotten used to it. I don't see any reason why it should not be as versitile and cromatic as any other semitone system.

2: I think it's important to keep in mind that many of the old players who play D/C# play boxes much different than the boxes used nowadays. 4 voices or more, large buttons, wet tuning, and less basses. That naturally leads to a stronger, more melodeon-like style, lending itself towards the way they played in the old dancehalls, from which they probably got a lot of their material and inspiration. I, for one, think it's extremely hard to play as smooth and soft on a 5, 6 or even 8 voice box with huge buttons as I would play on a 3 voice paolo soprani.

Great clips shared by Paul there, showing some very nice playing on both old and new boxes.

I don't play D/C# anymore, since I sold the only box I had in that tuning. I just played way too loud and obnoxious for my surroundings!
Logged

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Why or why not D/C#?
« Reply #34 on: January 11, 2012, 02:48:54 AM »

Hi all,

Enjoying this discussion!

Lars, very good points.  But just to keep a friendly debate going:  my current goal in playing the Irish-American boxes is to learn to improve on controlling the volume - just instantaneous little pushes or pulls with lots of space between the notes.  Believe it or not, that's how my friend and mentor (Michael's teacher) plays.  Whether on a Walters  D/C# with 1.5 rows, or on a Martin melodeon, his style is understated.  Punchy but never overblown, very controlled, and supporting but never dominating a session, as I'm sure Michael will confirm.  The Walters itself has the potential to be loud as Michael wrote, and when I play on my own similar box it's a great challenge for me to keep it reined in, but I'm working on that style because I know it can be done!

I still think that the very forceful playing style on the Irish-American boxes that you mention (for example, of some of the musicians who recorded many years ago) is great too in the right context.

PG

« Last Edit: January 11, 2012, 03:31:32 AM by pgroff »
Logged

Andrel

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 246
Re: Why or why not D/C#?
« Reply #35 on: January 11, 2012, 04:17:25 AM »

But when Joe Derrane got his more modern box, the Gaillard, with arguably more sensitive reeds, it allowed him to take his playing to another level. He is now better than he has ever been, by all accounts. Now whether you care for his style (and the sound of his box) or not, is a different matter altogether. Like Steve, I don't aspire to play like him (assuming it would be remotely possible!), but I have been fascinated by his technique for years, Thank you Joe, indeed.
Logged
Bertrand Gaillard D/C#, Acadian in C, Castagnari Ciacy
B/C, Castagnari Sharon D/C#

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: Why or why not D/C#?
« Reply #36 on: January 11, 2012, 11:00:19 AM »

You took the bait, George..

Indeed! ;).


The man is asking about why or why not a left-hand drive minivan and you are recommending a (right-hand drive) London double-decker bus!  >:E 


yes & no! 
Yes the stradella bass BCC#'s  are on a par with similar size bass on a piano or continental box  but do offer the push pull enthusiast a lot of scope.

  No  there is absolutely no reason why BCC# 's cant be ultra compact & light (whilst being no better or worse than a BC etc as far as bass availablility). The smallest I have tried was a castagnari matty ( 3 row lilly!) tuned BCC# . Featherweight, very responsive and all 12 keys without changing box.  This was a special order by Hobgoblin & whilst I was making my mind up somebody else bought it! Does anybody know where it is now?

george
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

nfldbox

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 492
Re: Why or why not D/C#?
« Reply #37 on: January 11, 2012, 02:35:07 PM »

As a BC player who has no desire to switch I have nothing to add but this thread seems to me unusually informative, at least for me. People always complain about thread drift but this one seems to have "drifted" in tangents that twine back very nicely.
Logged
BC Cairdin
BC Hohner Double Ray
Bouchard en Ré

mory

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 752
Re: Why or why not D/C#?
« Reply #38 on: January 11, 2012, 04:49:15 PM »

But when Joe Derrane got his more modern box, the Gaillard, with arguably more sensitive reeds, it allowed him to take his playing to another level. He is now better than he has ever been, by all accounts. Now whether you care for his style (and the sound of his box) or not, is a different matter altogether. Like Steve, I don't aspire to play like him (assuming it would be remotely possible!), but I have been fascinated by his technique for years, Thank you Joe, indeed.

I think one important aspect of Joe Derranes DC# Galliard style is the ability to shut down to 2 banks of reeds, ie, LM this offers a completly different "streaming" affect to the flow of notes giving a very instant response and a lighter touch to playing I feel and is in his own words his prefered set up that he uses for most of his playing. I think it's the modern cut from the reeds that allows this as the box still has the "bite" if I do this on my old Saltarelle Nuage for instance, the quick fire is there but the sound is somewhat "woolly" in comparison the same selection LM on my new A Mano Tara has that "bite" similar to Joes, wether or not he would agree is another matter. That's aside from the obvious range of Basses and his pure brilliant musicianship. Joe says he had some tweaks done to the tuning on this his second Galliard but I guess Bertrand would be the source for that info, it would be intersting to know if there is any offset between the L and M reeds as its a subject that seems to get asked quite a bit when people are discusing Ian's (Dedic) tuning and there does I think appear to be more than just a dry tuning on Joes set up.

Paul any footage or sound clips of you or your mentor in the way you describe AtB mory
Lars (she's my wife now Lars) :||: ;)
« Last Edit: January 11, 2012, 04:55:17 PM by mory »
Logged

Andrel

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 246
Re: Why or why not D/C#?
« Reply #39 on: January 11, 2012, 05:34:04 PM »

True. The better response comes with a more metallic, dryish sound which I don't care for myself. I have the same box, and I never use that setting. It's either all on (with a box re-tuned on the swing side) or MM with my fiddler friends. I like the sound of Joe's box better on Return To  Inish Mor, when he had his first Gaillard than on the subsequent albums.
« Last Edit: January 11, 2012, 05:36:41 PM by Andrel »
Logged
Bertrand Gaillard D/C#, Acadian in C, Castagnari Ciacy
B/C, Castagnari Sharon D/C#
Pages: 1 [2] 3   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal