Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Pearse Rossa on January 29, 2019, 08:28:20 PM
-
The project I have in mind is to convert a Hohner Erica to a one row, 4-voice LMMH melodeon.
In order to minimize alterations, I intend to pair the levers so that each button operates two pallets.
This approach will obviate the necessity to alter or replace the soundboard. Another plus is the fact that it will
not be necessary to extend the pallet levers or replace the existing pallets.
One reed block will hold the MM reeds. The second block will need to be modified to accommodate
the H and L reeds.
All the buttons will be removed from the outside row, and the holes will be closed off.
The main task is to couple or bridge the pallet levers. My instinct tells me that this would work
best if done behind the fingerboard rather than closer to the pallets.
I expect that the springs may need to be adjusted to compensate for the additional load.
Otherwise, the action would be sluggish or heavy.
At this stage I am not planning to incorporate slides and stops, but I have not ruled it out completely.
The connection between the levers will need to be rigid if it is to work properly.
I would appreciate advice on what might be a good method of bridging a pair of pallet levers.
Would soldering work? Or possibly an adhesive of some kind?
-
That is an intriguing idea :)
Definitely couple the pallets at the fingerboard.
Firstly, I would try a small piece of hardwood glued between the levers with Araldite.
-
Hi Pearse Rossa,
Some of the early Walters and Baldonis were made with two pallets linked to one button. Those usually involve a linkage near the pallets.
I mentioned this to Laurent Jarry who works on accordions in his Paris shop, La Boite D'accordéon. He wanted a 6 voice 1-row box and I mentioned that he could convert a 3-voice 2-row Saltarelle to a 6 voice 1-row. I sent him photos of the early Baldonis & Walters with paired, staggered pallets to achieve a 6 voice or 8 voice box.
And he actually did it! Laurent converted a 3 voice 2 row Saltarelle to a 1 row 6 voice box. I think he linked the button levers by pairs under the keyboard plate. Maybe he would send you pics?
Best,
PG
-
Firstly, I would try a small piece of hardwood glued between the levers with Araldite.
Worth a shot. Thanks.
La Boite D'accordéon..... Laurent converted a 3 voice 2 row Saltarelle to a 1 row 6 voice box. I think he linked the button levers by pairs under the keyboard plate. Maybe he would send you pics?
I've found his website (https://www.laboitedaccordeon.fr/). I might contact him for photos. Thanks.
Do you happen to know how he managed to secure the linkage?
-
Firstly, I would try a small piece of hardwood glued between the levers with Araldite.
Worth a shot. Thanks.
La Boite D'accordéon..... Laurent converted a 3 voice 2 row Saltarelle to a 1 row 6 voice box. I think he linked the button levers by pairs under the keyboard plate. Maybe he would send you pics?
I've found his website (https://www.laboitedaccordeon.fr/). I might contact him for photos. Thanks.
Do you happen to know how he managed to secure the linkage?
No, Laurent sent me a photo of the completed conversion but not of the mechanics under the keyboard. But, he's a very skilled and experienced accordion mechanic and also builds accordinas.
I can send or post photos of the 1930s Baldonis and Walters boxes that have 2 pallets linked to one button. There were several different ways that this was tried! But some of the early ones really do remind me of converted 2 row boxes, because the pallets are staggered (although the same number of pallets in each row, rather than 11 + 10 as on your Erica). Some of the later ones have the paired pallets and airways "in line."
I think a couple of years ago Theo Gibb had for sale a Delicia (?) box with one row of buttons and 4 voices that appeared to be a converted 2 row MM box. Maybe he will recall this or even have photos.
Let us know how you get on!
PG
-
An easier bet would be to couple an 8 bass left end to a 4 stop treble end, surely? I've been busy collecting the parts to accomplish just this, but won't be able to get any further with it till the summer, as my Liliputs are stealing most of my time at the moment, plus I'll be missing for the next five weeks.
-
I can send or post photos of the 1930s Baldonis and Walters boxes that have 2 pallets linked to one button.
Please post them here. That would be very much appreciated.
I think a couple of years ago Theo Gibb had for sale a Delicia (?) box with one row of buttons and 4 voices that appeared to be a converted 2 row MM box. Maybe he will recall this or even have photos.
Sounds interesting.
An easier bet would be to couple an 8 bass left end to a 4 stop treble end, surely?
I like a challenge!... and I've already done that.
-
Firstly, I would try a small piece of hardwood glued between the levers with Araldite.
The more I think about this, the better I like the idea.
Maybe even a double link for maximum rigidity?
And the process can easily be reversed.
-
I can send or post photos of the 1930s Baldonis and Walters boxes that have 2 pallets linked to one button.
Please post them here. That would be very much appreciated.
See below photos of the pallets of two instruments with "staggered" design for their 2 pallets per button:
1) the F. Likely 10 key 1-row 6 voice Baldoni, and
2) an early Walters 15 key 1.5-row 8 voice box.
PG
-
And here are two instruments with two different lever mechanisms but each with an "in-line" design for their 2 pallets / button:
1) a 10-key 8-voice Walters 1-row, and
2) a 13 key 8 voice Baldoni.
The Walters is fully described here:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,11281.0.html
-
I worked on a VERY old Paolo Soprani chromatic that had a slave row of buttons that operated the arms by a bend that caught the arm of the valve it wanted to lift. It was very simple and worked well.
You would do the reverse where the button you were pressing would have a tab soldered on sticking off to the side where it would either press or lift the arm next to it depending on weather the link was near the pads or under the keyboard.
Use zinc chloride flux and you will have no trouble soldering to the steel arms.
-
See below photos...
Thanks Paul. Very useful.
Use zinc chloride flux and you will have no trouble soldering to the steel arms.
Thanks for the tip.
-
I expect that the springs may need to be adjusted to compensate for the additional load.
Otherwise, the action would be sluggish or heavy.
Having investigated this aspect of the task more thoroughly, I don't think adjustments will be necessary after all.
Releasing the springs on the redundant button levers, and probably removing them from the rod/axle entirely, should work.
-
Are you sure? A spring strong enough to keep 1 pallet closed is not necessarily strong enough to keep 2 pallets closed.
-
Not entirely sure, but I think it might work. It will be very easy to test in any event.
I think there is plenty of tension on one spring to operate two pallets.
The pallet is extremely light.
-
Not entirely sure, but I think it might work. It will be very easy to test in any event.
I think there is plenty of tension on one spring to operate two pallets.
The pallet is extremely light.
It is not the weight of the pallet that the spring is there for, it is to resist the pallets being opened by air pressure on blow notes. So I'm not sure that a single spring will have sufficient tension to hold two pallets closed when playing with enthusiasm.
-
Of course. As I say, it is easy to experiment with it.
If this works, then it is a better remedy than having 2 springs per button, which would be heavy and need
fine adjustment.
-
How about using single springs from a 4 stop, they seem to manage to seal off 4 holes OK? Or are they entirely different?
-
That's an idea. I don't anticipate that sorting it out will be a major problem.
-
How about using single springs from a 4 stop, they seem to manage to seal off 4 holes OK? Or are they entirely different?
Not entirely different but possibly significantly different as the 1 row only has one pivot for arm rather than the proposed double arm, so more mechanical friction.
-
Assuming that both rows of keys share a common axle, is it possible simply to leave the key levers of the redundant row in place beneath the finger board with the springs still in situ?
If both sets of keys are on a common axle the centre of rotation of the two sets of keys and pallets must be the same. Then provided the rigidity of the cross connection between the two pallet rods is at least an order of magnitude greater than the rigidity of the springs (rigidity is the inverse of elasticity) the mechanical response of the action should be half way between the responses of the two sets of actions before the conversion- actually it will be a tiny bit faster than the mid point because removing the keys will reduce the mass that the springs have to accelerate to close the pallets when the fingers are lifted off.
-
Are you sure? A spring strong enough to keep 1 pallet closed is not necessarily strong enough to keep 2 pallets closed.
I'm not an accordion builder but some of the designs I've seen offer very light button feel and fast action - these include coil spring designs and alternatively designs that have springs acting directly downward on the pallets themselves.
PG
-
Assuming that both rows of keys share a common axle, is it possible simply to leave the key levers of the redundant row in place beneath the finger board with the springs still in situ?
Yes, everything is on one axle. I intend leaving the redundant levers in place behind the keyboard.
Earlier I thought this was going to be a problem because the button posts (with the buttons removed)
still protrude beyond the surface of the keyboard. I thought I might have to cut them off at the shaft, which
I would have been very reluctant to do at this stage, but found that they will easily bend inwards out of the way.
As regards the springs, I have experimented and as expected, two springs per button will be far too heavy.
One spring feels about right. If there is pallet blow-back, I will need to adjust the tension on both or try
what Paul has mentioned here;
.... designs that have springs acting directly downward on the pallets themselves.
-
I’ve experimented a lot with springs, and you can make your own without much difficulty and have them provide just the right amount of tension. As someone else mentioned, you could also use the springs intended for a Hohner HA114, and then adjust the tension to your liking.
-
.... you could also use the springs intended for a Hohner HA114...
What type of spring does the HA114 have?
-
.... you could also use the springs intended for a Hohner HA114...
What type of spring does the HA114 have?
Like this:
http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Springs.html#7
-
...Which looks to be identical to the Erica springs.
-
But thicker.
-
But thicker.
Is it not just a generic Hohner treble spring?
On Charlie's site it says; "Hohner treble springs model 114 & other models".
I don't see an Erica-specific spring on his website.
-
Eric as use two different weights of spring.
Insde row (short levers) .5mm wire diameter
Outsidectow (long levers) .55mm wire diameter
114 use the same shape of wire but thicker again I think .65 or .7mm. I don’t have one handy to measure.
They all look the same from a distance, but the difference in n wire thickness is important.
-
OK. That makes sense. On the Hohner shop (http://www.hohner-cshop.de/en/Accordion/Diatonic/2-row/Erica/) website, you have a variety of springs.
-
It was only last week that I eventually got around to installing the reeds.
I haven't fine tuned yet. Still mulling over the final sound I want to achieve.
Yesterday I repadded the pallets.
I've never owned a one-row before, mainly because I never really got on with the left-hand side on conventional ones. The very narrow space between the row of buttons and the outer edge of the fingerboard was always an issue for me as well.
On my 'homemade one', I have used a regular two-row fingerboard with the outer row holes sealed off.
Also, I wanted to have better left-hand chord options. For now, it's chords only; G/G, D/A, A/E, F#/B (minus thirds).
The action is not bad, but I think I can improve it further by tweaking the springs.
As I say, I've never played much on a one-row, and I've clocked up less than an hour of playing on this one...
but here's a wee tune (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ElfE6T2fyjk).
-
Tidy playing and workmanship.
-
Well done, very clever.
-
Math thu!
It sounds and looks good- there's something visually appealing about the pair sof staggerd pallets moving together.
-
It was only last week that I eventually got around to installing the reeds.
I haven't fine tuned yet. Still mulling over the final sound I want to achieve.
Yesterday I repadded the pallets.
I've never owned a one-row before, mainly because I never really got on with the left-hand side on conventional ones. The very narrow space between the row of buttons and the outer edge of the fingerboard was always an issue for me as well.
On my 'homemade one', I have used a regular two-row fingerboard with the outer row holes sealed off.
Also, I wanted to have better left-hand chord options. For now, it's chords only; G/G, D/A, A/E, F#/B (minus thirds).
The action is not bad, but I think I can improve it further by tweaking the springs.
As I say, I've never played much on a one-row, and I've clocked up less than an hour of playing on this one...
but here's a wee tune (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ElfE6T2fyjk).
Great work, many thanks for sharing this. Hope you don't mind that I shared the video also on facebook (I would delete it if you object).
PG
-
Thanks everyone for the positive comments.
I've been "commissioned" to produce two more by friends of mine. I have in mind also to make a six-voice
Baldoni type.
The advice, suggestions and photos that members shared here were very helpful and much appreciated.
Hope you don't mind that I shared the video also on facebook
That's fine Paul.
-
.
As I say, I've never played much on a one-row, and I've clocked up less than an hour of playing on this one...
but here's a wee tune (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ElfE6T2fyjk).
Lovely...and also splendidly appropriate for Theme of the Month... :|glug
-
As I say, I've never played much on a one-row, and I've clocked up less than an hour of playing on this one...
but here's a wee tune (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ElfE6T2fyjk).
That's a canny conversion. Well done! Lovely tune and brilliant playing. (:)
-
It was only last week that I eventually got around to installing the reeds.
I haven't fine tuned yet. Still mulling over the final sound I want to achieve.
Yesterday I repadded the pallets.
I've never owned a one-row before, mainly because I never really got on with the left-hand side on conventional ones. The very narrow space between the row of buttons and the outer edge of the fingerboard was always an issue for me as well.
On my 'homemade one', I have used a regular two-row fingerboard with the outer row holes sealed off.
Also, I wanted to have better left-hand chord options. For now, it's chords only; G/G, D/A, A/E, F#/B (minus thirds).
The action is not bad, but I think I can improve it further by tweaking the springs.
As I say, I've never played much on a one-row, and I've clocked up less than an hour of playing on this one...
but here's a wee tune (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ElfE6T2fyjk).
Nice job! And playing!
I don’t see anything about what you used for reeds to make up the balance LM side.
Different box or were you able to use some of the leftovers?
-
Thank you baz, Steve and boxcall. I am genuinely humbled by your kind comments.
I don’t see anything about what you used for reeds
I used a new set of dural quality, LMMH reeds in the key of D, sourced from Fratton Accordions.
They're not bad at all, but next time I think I will go a grade better.
For the left-hand chords, I used spare reeds that were knocking about the place.
I made up the bass as well but opted not to install them (for now at least).
I wanted to keep the instrument as light as possible, and besides, I don't think they added much to the 4-voice mix.
I just came across your own project (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,23700.msg282327.html#msg282327)recently boxcall, and read it with great interest. Well done there.
Actually, you might be able to help me out if you don't mind. I would be interested to know what the degree
of tremolo is on the MM reeds in your Beltuna.
Indeed, if anyone reading this can offer advice on that, I would appreciate it.
-
Yesterday I repadded the pallets.
I wanted to acknowledge Lester's excellent tutorial "Hot Rod a Hohner Episode 2 - Reface Treble Pallets (https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=9&v=g7nVDIXF3qc&feature=emb_logo)".
As this was a task I had never performed previously, this video proved invaluable.
So, here's to Lester (https://cdn4.vectorstock.com/i/1000x1000/11/63/thumbs-up-emoticon-vector-9701163.jpg).
-
Thank you baz, Steve and boxcall. I am genuinely humbled by your kind comments.
I don’t see anything about what you used for reeds
I used a new set of dural quality, LMMH reeds in the key of D, sourced from Fratton Accordions.
They're not bad at all, but next time I think I will go a grade better.
For the left-hand chords, I used spare reeds that were knocking about the place.
I made up the bass as well but opted not to install them (for now at least).
I wanted to keep the instrument as light as possible, and besides, I don't think they added much to the 4-voice mix.
I just came across your own project (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,23700.msg282327.html#msg282327)recently boxcall, and read it with great interest. Well done there.
Actually, you might be able to help me out if you don't mind. I would be interested to know what the degree
of tremolo is on the MM reeds in your Beltuna.
Indeed, if anyone reading this can offer advice on that, I would appreciate it.
Mine is around + 8 or + 9 ish on the +M reeds , while doing this check I’ve noticed a few spots where its drifted M reeds being a little sharp.
On a picture I have save of Triskel’s ( Acadian) its plus 7.5 on one M and minus 7.5 on the other M reeds.
Dedic tuning which might be better for a box with no stops, ?
Same amount of tremolo approx. but the latter will be on pitch .
-
I’ve owned two Beltuna 4-stops. The first was in D (no longer in my possession) and I remember it being tuned 440-442 (the M+ reeds obviously being tuned to 442). I currently have one in the key of G that was originally 440-441 but I’ve since tuned it up to 440-442.
Matt
-
On a picture I have save of Triskel’s ( Acadian) its plus 7.5 on one M and minus 7.5 on the other M reeds.
Dedic tuning which might be better for a box with no stops, ?
As I recall, Triskel had specifically requested stronger tremolo than normal. My Acadian is marked +5/-5 inside, which is more typical of the 'Quebecois tuning' used by Marc Savoy. Incidentally, the box sounds fine on LM-H and LM+H settings, maybe thanks to the moderate offsets.
I was working on a Messervier last week and that one had M voices tuned nominally 0/+10. Nice sound too.
This week it's a Morelli I have on the bench. This one is 0/+20 (more tremolo than my ears like..).
-
Thanks for the replies fellas. That information is very useful to me.
-
but here's a wee tune (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ElfE6T2fyjk).
Not an obvious choice of tune for a one-row..
-
"Not an obvious choice of tune for a one-row.."
Please forgive my usual ignorance; but "Why not?"
-
"Not an obvious choice of tune for a one-row.."
Please forgive my usual ignorance; but "Why not?"
Indeed.
-
but here's a wee tune (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ElfE6T2fyjk).
Not an obvious choice of tune for a one-row..
See here... (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,25095.msg298755.html#msg298755)
-
Pearse ,
Showing my ignorance, but as a matter of interest what was your "wee tune"?
P
-
On youtube it shows the title as When The Tide Comes In
-
I’ve owned two Beltuna 4-stops. The first was in D (no longer in my possession) and I remember it being tuned 440-442 (the M+ reeds obviously being tuned to 442). I currently have one in the key of G that was originally 440-441 but I’ve since tuned it up to 440-442.
Matt
That’s what mine is using Hz 440- 442 but as I said a few notes M reeds have gone up in pitch
The A note being the worst , time for a check up I guess.
Do reeds tend to go sharp rather then flat over time?
-
Pearse ,
Showing my ignorance, but as a matter of interest what was your "wee tune"?
P
On youtube it shows the title as When The Tide Comes In
The tune is known by several different titles (https://thesession.org/tunes/1985). I choose to call it "When the tide comes in" because it's my favourite title, and I live right beside the sea.
-
Pearse ,
Showing my ignorance, but as a matter of interest what was your "wee tune"?
P
On youtube it shows the title as When The Tide Comes In
The tune is known by several different titles (https://thesession.org/tunes/1985). I choose to call it "When the tide comes in" because it's my favourite title, and I live right beside the sea.
Thanks.
Remiss of me not to have seen the title on you tube...but the way my internet is at the moment it was a small miracle I managed to view it at all.