Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Owen Woods on June 22, 2010, 12:28:55 AM

Title: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on June 22, 2010, 12:28:55 AM
As some of you will know, I've gone a bit overboard on eBay over the last few weeks, exams being my excuse. This means that I have a number of boxes that need fixing up that I am intending to do something about over the next few months.

1) Hohner 1140C. This was kindly donated to me by Rob2Hook of this parish. It's a lovely little one-row; it's been a bit beat up but is basically sound. I've enjoyed playing it, but it does need an overhaul. Valves are dropping off it and the wax is dry and cracked. In addition the reeds need a tune and are a bit rusty. Other than that it is pretty good, bellows are sound, gaskets aren't leaking and neither are the pallets. I'd put in a strap bracket and probably a new thumbhook as well.

2) Weltmeister C/F Club. Bought off eBay for �20 plus p&p. This isn't in as good condition as the one-row. The grill (which is a horrible plastically material) has broken on both panels and will need to be carefully taken out and replaced with something else. Not sure what, as it needs to be flexible to bend round the top, yet rigid enough not to collapse. Pallets need refacing, I can feel the air leaking out of them. Bellows gaskets are leaking like a sieve. I'm not sure about the bellows, there's been some repair work done but they seem to be reasonably sound. I'm hoping that I won't have to retape them. On the bass side, the mechanism (which picks up the tonic when you press the bass) is sticking slightly. It is all on a rod and it may be that the wood has swollen slightly. A bit of care with some sandpaper might sort it out, but I'd have to take it to pieces first. The reeds are more or less in tune and the leathers seem to be in reasonable nick, no real rattly noises coming through. One of the bass reedplates has fallen off though, so the bass end will need rewaxing. If I do get around to tuning the treble end then I should probably revalve and rewax anyway.

3) Hohner Imperial IIA (PA). Bought off eBay for �5 plus p&p. This is a PA around the size of a Liliput (The bellows dimensions are approx 25mm by 14.5mm. I am sure that there are measurements for the Liliput somewhere on the web but can't find them quite at present). It has two octaves in the treble and an astonishing 32 [4*8] bass. My original thought when buying it was that it would make an unusual frankenstein, but I'm rather loath to split it up, even if I had another half. The other problem is that it is bass/major/minor/dominant and only goes up to E. If I were to make it usable I would probably shift it 2 down, making it end in F#, using the Bb reeds for the B row and probably having to buy new reeds for the F# row (4 semitones seems a lot to ask for a reed). This would obviously be a bit of a bugger to do, so I probably won't get round to it. The bass machine is in fantastic condition, not a sticky key in sight and not dirty or grimy at all inside. Tuning is pretty much OK for the bass, with the wax and valves in reasonable nick. I am hearing a slight, very high pitched sound when I play it though, don't know what might cause that. Slight annoyance in that someone replaced one of the bellows pins with a screw, which at least isn't philips and is suitably shiny. It doesn't look too out of place and it is on the back and more importantly doesn't appear to be leaking. So I won't bother replacing it. Some of the remaining bellows pins are very rusty. The bellows are completely shot, need retaping as a minimum. Bellows gaskets appear to be perished. On the treble end, it is in need of a full reed overhaul and it is sounding rather hard, not sweet at all. In addition the keys need levelling and the pallets are all wonky. I haven't the first idea what to do about that, other than physically bending them, which just seems wrong. All in all it has the potential to be a really very interesting box, but would need a lot of work doing to it.

4) Hohner Amati IIIM 3 row B-griff CBA. Semi-intentionally bought off eBay last week. Hasn't arrived yet. This, I vow, will be the last box for a while UNLESS I find a Liliput or even better a Preciosa OR I find something else that is really remarkable and unmissable :P

So those are the three boxes that I am planning to do up over the summer. If I am optimistic then I suppose that I might get one finished. Aim is to start Thursday next week, when I have no parents breathing down my neck. In order of difficulty I list the things that I need to do below.

Obviously there are lots of things that I need to get first, which is my job for Wednesday. Most importantly, bellows gasket, valves and accordion wax. Then there is pallet facing, fine sandpaper, a set of needle files, a chromatic tuner (getting one of them cheaply might be difficult), bellows straps, strap brackets, thumbstrap, grille cloth, felt (for treble action on the Imperial), bellows tape and probably springs, bellows pins and all sorts of other things that I will break or lose. Getting all of this stuff from Charlie Marshall will probably cost a bundle, in the region of �100 I think, so I will do one box at a time to limit the shock to my bank balance. Not altogether sure which one. Probably the one-row, despite my slight nervousness about starting tuning. A friend of mine has started tuning boxes and said that it wasn't quite as difficult as people say, which is a relief somewhat. Should be a challenge at any rate.

My hope is that by posting here I will actually get on and do some of it! I'll let everyone know how I get on.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on June 22, 2010, 12:02:09 PM
Please do! In return we (probably anyway) promise encouragement from the sidelines.  :-*
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on October 25, 2010, 06:12:20 PM
After a long time of doing nothing, I am gradually getting round to doing things on this, since my degree is going so badly :P
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: rees on October 25, 2010, 06:57:53 PM
About time too! (says I looking round at the fifteen or so melodeons sitting forlornly on the shelf waiting for me to find a "bit of spare time").  :Ph
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Lester on October 25, 2010, 08:18:07 PM
About time too! (says I looking round at the fifteen or so melodeons sitting forlornly on the shelf waiting for me to find a "bit of spare time").  :Ph

Turns out "a bit of spare time" is a vey large amount of hours if my experience is anything to go by. I have spent bl00dy hours - stripping tape off of bellows and then fitting new, taking pallet facing off and then fitting new, dewaxing reeds and then rewaxing, removing valves and fitting new. The only upside is it has put off the evil hour of tuning, mind you I have just completed the first pass of the "on key" reeds of the G row and they don't sound so bad except the very high B reed which I killed  :-[.

Very satisfying when it goes well very very frustrating when it doesn't.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on October 26, 2010, 12:07:29 AM
About time too! (says I looking round at the fifteen or so melodeons sitting forlornly on the shelf waiting for me to find a "bit of spare
time").  :Ph

Turns out "a bit of spare time" is a vey large amount of hours if my experience is anything to go by. I have spent bl00dy hours - stripping tape off of bellows and then fitting new, taking pallet facing off and then fitting new, dewaxing reeds and then rewaxing, removing valves and fitting new. The only upside is it has put off the evil hour of tuning, mind you I have just completed the first pass of the "on key" reeds of the G row and they don't sound so bad except the very high B reed which I killed  :-[.

Very satisfying when it goes well very very frustrating when it doesn't.


Sounds like you are in the same position as me, just plus time and experience Lester (:) I've got three boxes in various states of disrepair. I'm rather looking forward to doing all the tedious but possible jobs, because they aren't tuning :P I have a disadvantage in that I've NEVER done it before and don't have any "spare" reeds to do it on :( I have read lots about it, but am resigned to the fact that my PA's reeds are probably going to end up half out of tune and half broken. They sound terrible anyway and the box is worthless, so never mind :P I Need to get the hang of it (ish...) with that box though, because the others I would quite like to keep...

EDIT: Plus time refers to the fact that you are substantially ahead of me, not that you have more spare time than me, but given that you are retired and I am at the University of "Let's work them so hard that any hope or enthusiasm will be drained from their unresisting bodies" then I'd be surprised if you do :P

The three dance sides, ceilidh band and piano trio have nothing to do with it of course *cough*
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on October 26, 2010, 01:26:16 AM
I am currently scouring the archives (what a useful forum this is) for advice on tuning and the big problem that I have at the moment (apart from not being able to do it of course) is that of tools.

Basically I have no tools, no equipment WHATSOEVER. I have a few poor quality screwdrivers and that's a bit it. Some things I could get out from the department tool store and I could use their machines, but really they are geared towards larger scale stuff and to be honest aren't very student friendly. Raw materials I think I'd have to get myself.

So much as I would like to make my own files and reed tools I'm not sure that it is going to be an option.

As I understand it, the German method of tuning the underside reeds(which looks a lot simpler than the Italian one) is to get a pinger and to jam it at the top and lever up the reed, then supporting it with coffee sticks etc. Those are no problem, I'm well experienced at swiping large quantities of stirrers (useful for making sword locks). The pinger though, CGM stocks them in two sizes. These are quite cheap and seem to be cheaper than those that I would find elsewhere. I don't think that ecnomising on those would be particularly possible (I could make them out of sheet aly easily, but they'd be too thick, too rough and would need sanding etc). The pingers should last for ages as well.

Then there is the scratcher. If I have understood it correctly then this should be used for scratching the bottom of the reed. Is this because it is so sensitive that using a sander would remove too much material. If so God Help Me, but is there a particularly recommended scratcher? For the rest of it I believe that I can use sandpaper, which is good because it is cheap. I could buy a sanding pen, but another poached stirrer and some sandpaper glued to it seems better (Theo mentioned fine on one side, coarse(r) on the other, although I think that it'll be a while before I can work up the courage to use coarse paper). Although I don't even have any glue with me. More expense. That reminds me, I need to go through the archives to find out what glues to use.

Then there is the problem of tuners. *sigh* I don't have a decent electronic tuner and really can't afford Dirk's program or a Stroboflip. I don't have an iPod touch or I could use the app. I could use Bill's tuner, but I have to calibrate it to the clock and I don't know how to do that. I also don't think that anyone has used it so far, which (although I am sure that it is fine) does worry me slightly. So I could buy a normal chromatic tuner, but I am reticent to do that, because it is more expense. I'm not sure what the answer is here, probably to work out how to calibrate Bill's tuner.

Lots more archive searching needed I think :(
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Andy Simpson on October 26, 2010, 07:19:30 AM
It's always worth buying the best tools you can for the job, they'll generally get better results and make life much easier and the ones for reed tuning and waxing aren't expensive compared to the specialist tools needed in other areas. To put things in perspective, the last set of special files I bought for the nut slots in stringed instruments cost me £120 and I also need to buy a cello peg reamer, the cheapest version of which costs €70 not including shipping from Germany, I'll probably have to make my own peg shaper as well because to buy one would cost €99. Compared to that, £25 for a set of tuning tools or £13.95 for a waxing spoon from CGM is a bargain.

If you're going to go with the sandpaper on a stick method then double sided tape, (an invention on a par with the internal combustion engine and the wheel in my book, I wouldn't have got where I am today without it), is better than glue for that purpose, much less messy, easier to change once the paper is worn and you can use it more or less straight away. The advantage of using sandpaper isn't the cost, (wears quickly, cost of tape, cheap sandpaper is rubbish and good sandpaper is quite expensive), but being gentler on the reeds and safer for a beginner than a file. The file that Theo himself recommends for tuning only costs £2.70 from Axminster.

Acquiring the tools, equipment and know-how to repair instruments isn't cheap, there are more economical ways than others but it will cost you a bit however you do it and if you're serious about it you'll have to find a way to pay for what you need, which will probably involve a lot of hard work and/or some big sacrifices.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Theo on October 26, 2010, 09:46:16 AM
Acquiring the tools, equipment and know-how to repair instruments isn't cheap, there are more economical ways than others but it will cost you a bit however you do it and if you're serious about it you'll have to find a way to pay for what you need, which will probably involve a lot of hard work and/or some big sacrifices.

You will also need to invest considerable amounts of time. 
Learning where to remove metal to raise or lower the pitch of a reeds only takes a few minutes, but learning how to control that process, to achieve the desired effect takes much longer, and you must develop good manual dexterity, and good listening skills.  You also need to learn to work towards applying these skills quite quickly.  For example a typical Hohner two row contains 61 reed plates, 122 reed tongues.  If it takes you say 2 minutes to tune one tongue then the full job would take about 4 hours, get that time down to half a minute per tongue and you could do it in an hour.  Same sort of time calculations apply to cleaning, waxing, applying new valves.  The number of times that operations have to be repeated can drive you up the wall.  You need to be able to set aside extended periods of time where you are undisturbed and can give your whole attention to the task. 

You also need space where you can lay out all the parts with no risk of them being disturbed when you are not working on them.

Good luck.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Lester on October 26, 2010, 11:18:55 AM
I have now tuned two reed plates (yes two whole reed plates) on my pokerwork the G and the A and they are in tune and have the same tremolo. Only taken ~2 hours so about a week to go  :o
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on October 26, 2010, 11:59:43 AM
You will also need to invest considerable amounts of time. 
Learning where to remove metal to raise or lower the pitch of a reeds only takes a few minutes, but learning how to control that process, to achieve the desired effect takes much longer, and you must develop good manual dexterity, and good listening skills.  You also need to learn to work towards applying these skills quite quickly.  For example a typical Hohner two row contains 61 reed plates, 122 reed tongues.  If it takes you say 2 minutes to tune one tongue then the full job would take about 4 hours, get that time down to half a minute per tongue and you could do it in an hour.  Same sort of time calculations apply to cleaning, waxing, applying new valves.  The number of times that operations have to be repeated can drive you up the wall.  You need to be able to set aside extended periods of time where you are undisturbed and can give your whole attention to the task. 

You also need space where you can lay out all the parts with no risk of them being disturbed when you are not working on them.

Good luck.

I'll need it :P I'm not sure whether I will get through it, but I'm determined to give it a good shot. If the result of my efforts means that I can do quick simple fixes on my boxes but have to get a tech in for the bigger jobs then I will be delighted. My PA has 94 reed plates on treble and bass. That is a lot of time! I am going to use that box as the test rig and rewax and revalve it and then try tuning it. Losing the money on the valves some of which will inevitably have to replaced (along with the reeds...) is a pain, but one that goes with practising anything.

I have quite some way to go in terms of reading about tuning before I can start, although obviously once I do any reading that I do will quickly be supplanted by a whole series of "what not to do's".

Space is not a problem, I have loads of it this year. I've got that planned out. Time is potentially more of a problem and I am sure that I won't get far this term for that reason.

It's always worth buying the best tools you can for the job, they'll generally get better results and make life much easier and the ones for reed tuning and waxing aren't expensive compared to the specialist tools needed in other areas. To put things in perspective, the last set of special files I bought for the nut slots in stringed instruments cost me £120 and I also need to buy a cello peg reamer, the cheapest version of which costs €70 not including shipping from Germany, I'll probably have to make my own peg shaper as well because to buy one would cost €99. Compared to that, £25 for a set of tuning tools or £13.95 for a waxing spoon from CGM is a bargain.

If you're going to go with the sandpaper on a stick method then double sided tape, (an invention on a par with the internal combustion engine and the wheel in my book, I wouldn't have got where I am today without it), is better than glue for that purpose, much less messy, easier to change once the paper is worn and you can use it more or less straight away. The advantage of using sandpaper isn't the cost, (wears quickly, cost of tape, cheap sandpaper is rubbish and good sandpaper is quite expensive), but being gentler on the reeds and safer for a beginner than a file. The file that Theo himself recommends for tuning only costs £2.70 from Axminster.

Acquiring the tools, equipment and know-how to repair instruments isn't cheap, there are more economical ways than others but it will cost you a bit however you do it and if you're serious about it you'll have to find a way to pay for what you need, which will probably involve a lot of hard work and/or some big sacrifices.

£120? Bloody hell. I'm getting off easily :P I can't say that a file is looking inviting at the moment, sandpaper I like the look of for that reason. I am intending to get the Axminster files that Theo talks about, since they are so cheap. The postage is a nuisance though and I don't know anywhere that stocks Axminster stuff near me. Perhaps if I buy a sanding pen that would be more cost effective, given what you say about sandpaper.

Could I use a scriber as a scratcher, if I sharpened it on a diamond stone? I can get both of those things nice and cheaply from the hardware store. Buying one of the things from Hohner is not an option, WAY too expensive. I've scoured the thread (tallship's one is particularly useful) and Theo suggests snapping off a drill bit and grinding it to shape. CGM do one for about £10 which seems reasonable, but I don't know enough about them to know whether it is the thing to get.

There's more, but I've got a lecture in a minute's time :P
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Theo on October 26, 2010, 02:15:17 PM
Losing the money on the valves ...


What!  Valve are about the cheapest part of the job.   Don't be tempted to try to flatten out old curled leather valves, they need to go in the bin! Using good new valves is essential to getting a good result.  I've just had to do a complete re-valve and re-wax of a Hohner two row that had been "overhauled" by an amateur who had cut their own valves from leather.  It played like a cold pudding!

If you are really strapped for cash then perhaps you should start with the instrument with fewest reeds which will be the Hohner 1140.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on October 26, 2010, 02:34:43 PM
Losing the money on the valves ...


What!  Valve are about the cheapest part of the job.   Don't be tempted to try to flatten out old curled leather valves, they need to go in the bin! Using good new valves is essential to getting a good result.  I've just had to do a complete re-valve and re-wax of a Hohner two row that had been "overhauled" by an amateur who had cut their own valves from leather.  It played like a cold pudding!

If you are really strapped for cash then perhaps you should start with the instrument with fewest reeds which will be the Hohner 1140.

Don't worry, it's just me being grumpy :P It'll cost about £20 I think for the PA in valves, which isn't unappreciable, but equally really isn't that much.

Remembered my other question. On tallship's thread he pretuned the reeds before waxing. I hadn't heard of anyone doing this before, apart from with brand new reeds. Am I to presume that this was because he was converting the box, rather than retuning?

EDIT: Actually maybe I've miscounted. Probably more like £15...
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Lester on October 26, 2010, 02:48:18 PM
Remembered my other question. On tallship's thread he pretuned the reeds before waxing. I hadn't heard of anyone doing this before, apart from with brand new reeds. Am I to presume that this was because he was converting the box, rather than retuning?

I have just discovered that even when you tune the reeds on a tuning rig, in the blocks with new wax, valves and TLC they still need fine tuning once the blocks are in the box. Now I already knew this but was unaware how much they would need tuning as a result of fitting the blocks. Still now tuned 12 reeds G -> E so can play Donkey Riding and it sounds OK to TSMB as well as me  ;D
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on October 26, 2010, 03:08:30 PM
Remembered my other question. On tallship's thread he pretuned the reeds before waxing. I hadn't heard of anyone doing this before, apart from with brand new reeds. Am I to presume that this was because he was converting the box, rather than retuning?

I have just discovered that even when you tune the reeds on a tuning rig, in the blocks with new wax, valves and TLC they still need fine tuning once the blocks are in the box. Now I already knew this but was unaware how much they would need tuning as a result of fitting the blocks. Still now tuned 12 reeds G -> E so can play Donkey Riding and it sounds OK to TSMB as well as me  ;D

I suppose that makes sense, but it is a bit of a pain :P So should you tune them slightly sharp on the rig so that ((hopefully) the difference will be less acute when in the instrument?
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Lester on October 26, 2010, 03:14:43 PM
Remembered my other question. On tallship's thread he pretuned the reeds before waxing. I hadn't heard of anyone doing this before, apart from with brand new reeds. Am I to presume that this was because he was converting the box, rather than retuning?

I have just discovered that even when you tune the reeds on a tuning rig, in the blocks with new wax, valves and TLC they still need fine tuning once the blocks are in the box. Now I already knew this but was unaware how much they would need tuning as a result of fitting the blocks. Still now tuned 12 reeds G -> E so can play Donkey Riding and it sounds OK to TSMB as well as me  ;D

I suppose that makes sense, but it is a bit of a pain :P So should you tune them slightly sharp on the rig so that ((hopefully) the difference will be less acute when in the instrument?

If only it were that easy  >:(  I seems to me (a bit of a virgin at tuning) that the reeds move in random directions on installation of the blocks. I tune them on my rig, then install them, check the tuning (Dirk's Tuner) and note how far they have to move and in which direction, take the block out (this seems easiest rather than trying to do it in the box especially for the pull notes), tune it as per the note, reinstall, recheck, retune etc etc etc.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on October 26, 2010, 03:15:34 PM
Remembered my other question. On tallship's thread he pretuned the reeds before waxing. I hadn't heard of anyone doing this before, apart from with brand new reeds. Am I to presume that this was because he was converting the box, rather than retuning?

I have just discovered that even when you tune the reeds on a tuning rig, in the blocks with new wax, valves and TLC they still need fine tuning once the blocks are in the box. Now I already knew this but was unaware how much they would need tuning as a result of fitting the blocks. Still now tuned 12 reeds G -> E so can play Donkey Riding and it sounds OK to TSMB as well as me  ;D

I suppose that makes sense, but it is a bit of a pain :P So should you tune them slightly sharp on the rig so that ((hopefully) the difference will be less acute when in the instrument?

If only it were that easy  >:(  I seems to me (a bit of a virgin at tuning) that the reeds move in random directions on installation of the blocks.

Fantastic. I suppose I should have known :P The more I read about tuning the more I want to have a go :P
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: malcolmbebb on October 26, 2010, 04:20:20 PM
Coming back to valves - I need to refit some Hohner mylar(?) valves that seem to be in good nick, but on Googling around I can't readily identify a suitable adhesive. Superglue has been mentioned, but I'm not keen on using it.
Contact or spray cement also, as generic terms, but I'm not sure how these relate to purchase-able products.
Any suggestions?

Ta

Malcolm

PS bought a cheap electronic metronome in Aldi or Lidl a while ago - it has a tuner function.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on October 26, 2010, 04:29:43 PM
Bostik seems to be recommended by people on here (:)
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Lester on October 26, 2010, 04:31:43 PM
Coming back to valves - I need to refit some Hohner mylar(?) valves that seem to be in good nick, but on Googling around I can't readily identify a suitable adhesive. Superglue has been mentioned, but I'm not keen on using it.
Contact or spray cement also, as generic terms, but I'm not sure how these relate to purchase-able products.
Any suggestions?

Ta

Malcolm

PS bought a cheap electronic metronome in Aldi or Lidl a while ago - it has a tuner function.

Rees recommends B&Q Solvent Free  All Purpose Glue but I can't get on with it, it does not stick as well as what I use - Bostik Contact. Bostik also has the advantage of getting you high from the solvent   >:E

Don't use Super Glue!
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on October 26, 2010, 11:29:24 PM
I'v eused Evostik (also with free "high").  ;D
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: blafleur on October 26, 2010, 11:46:11 PM
The only thing I've gotten superglue to work well on is my fingers. :Ph
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: malcolmbebb on October 27, 2010, 07:45:34 AM
Quote
I've used Evostik (also with free "high")

Can you still get this? I thought it was water based now (and not as good?)?
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on October 28, 2010, 11:56:41 AM
I'm in the midst of my order to Charlie Marshall and don't know how much wax to order :|bl I'd rather get more than necessary, because I'm sure that waxing is one of the most useful of the restoration skills in terms of working on your own boxes, but how much is too much? :P How much wax does it take to do one two voice two row melodeon? Whatever it is I'll add 25% and then multiply by 5. That should leave lots behind even if I do bugger up the waxing and have to redo it (:)
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on October 28, 2010, 12:13:05 PM
I also don't know whether to order the reed scratcher or not. I need to do some more research on them, because a) I don't really know why they are necessary, b) I don't know what makes a good reed scratcher, in terms of shape etc. and whether there is a particular method of sharpening them and c) I don't know why there is such an enormous price difference between this and the Hohner one. It strikes me that a scriber (which I could get from my local hardware shop) would do just as well, but I don't know whether my logic is right :P

And I still haven't sorted out what to do about tuners. I don't suppose anyone has a copy of Dirk's tuner that they aren't using? :P

I am thinking about my PA's bellows. They seem airtight, but need retaping. I am currently working up the enthusiasm for this :P My Club bellows are sound and have had repairs to the tape. I am considering whether I really need to work up the enthusiasm to retape them. Retaping does not seem like the most interesting part of restoring, but it looks an awful lot more fun than repapering (c.f. tallship's thread)
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 28, 2010, 12:47:15 PM
I also don't know whether to order the reed scratcher or not. I need to do some more research on them, because a) I don't really know why they are necessary, b) I don't know what makes a good reed scratcher, in terms of shape etc. and whether there is a particular method of sharpening them
I made my own scratcher from an old Swiss needle file, one of the round tapered sort. I used the edge face of a carborundum oilstone to grind away the teeth of the file to make it smooth for about the last inch or so, and also to reduce the tip diameter to about 0.5 mm. It's important to grind the teeth off the file for the last inch in order to avoid damaging the slot sides of the reed plate when working on the underneath 'pull' reeds.

I finally ground the tip to a flat surface, so looking end on, it was a flat circle 0.5 mm in diameter, with sharp edges.The steel is hard enough to scratch the reed, but you need to have the oilstone on hand whilst working on the reeds in order to periodically touch up and maintain the sharpness of the scratcher. A x10 or x20 hand-lens (which all geologists have, of course) is useful to check on the sharpness, and you can also feel the sharpness by testing it carefully against the side of your thumb.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Andy Simpson on October 28, 2010, 01:13:40 PM
and you can also feel the sharpness by testing it carefully against the side of your thumb.

Your thumbnail is much safer and makes it easier to judge sharpness.

I have the scraper from CGM and it's just a c.2.5mm square bar with the end ground at a slight angle in a wooden handle.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Bill the Farmer on October 28, 2010, 04:46:28 PM
I'm in the midst of my order to Charlie Marshall and don't know how much wax to order :|bl I'd rather get more than necessary, because I'm sure that waxing is one of the most useful of the restoration skills in terms of working on your own boxes, but how much is too much? :P How much wax does it take to do one two voice two row melodeon? Whatever it is I'll add 25% and then multiply by 5. That should leave lots behind even if I do bugger up the waxing and have to redo it (:)

I got the stick wax from Charlie, and used less than half of it to completely re-wax a Liliput. I've got 6 sticks and a bit in a tuna tin left. I would imagine that if you use Charlie's tuna tin and paintbrush method you would use less.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on October 28, 2010, 06:06:55 PM
I'm in the midst of my order to Charlie Marshall and don't know how much wax to order :|bl I'd rather get more than necessary, because I'm sure that waxing is one of the most useful of the restoration skills in terms of working on your own boxes, but how much is too much? :P How much wax does it take to do one two voice two row melodeon? Whatever it is I'll add 25% and then multiply by 5. That should leave lots behind even if I do bugger up the waxing and have to redo it (:)

I got the stick wax from Charlie, and used less than half of it to completely re-wax a Liliput. I've got 6 sticks and a bit in a tuna tin left. I would imagine that if you use Charlie's tuna tin and paintbrush method you would use less.

Thanks for that Bill. By the way, how do you calibrate your tuner? I'm thinking of using it, as I don't have a decent chromatic tuner.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Bill the Farmer on October 28, 2010, 07:25:50 PM

Thanks for that Bill. By the way, how do you calibrate your tuner? I'm thinking of using it, as I don't have a decent chromatic tuner.

You don't need to, unless you think that the clock in your sound card is out. There are two ways of checking, you can check against another tuner, or the signal generator I put on the tuner web page, or you can record a tone, say from a melodeon, play it back and compare with the instrument. That's how I found out that some sound cards are out, I didn't believe it until I'd proved it. Dirk's tuner has a calibrate feature to take care of that. I tried to do the same but couldn't get it to work well enough. Macs have that feature built in, and I found the clock on my daughter's macbook was out.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on October 29, 2010, 01:59:57 AM
I made my own scratcher from an old Swiss needle file, one of the round tapered sort. I used the edge face of a carborundum oilstone to grind away the teeth of the file to make it smooth for about the last inch or so, and also to reduce the tip diameter to about 0.5 mm. It's important to grind the teeth off the file for the last inch in order to avoid damaging the slot sides of the reed plate when working on the underneath 'pull' reeds.

I finally ground the tip to a flat surface, so looking end on, it was a flat circle 0.5 mm in diameter, with sharp edges.The steel is hard enough to scratch the reed, but you need to have the oilstone on hand whilst working on the reeds in order to periodically touch up and maintain the sharpness of the scratcher. A x10 or x20 hand-lens (which all geologists have, of course) is useful to check on the sharpness, and you can also feel the sharpness by testing it carefully against the side of your thumb.

Ah right, so the scratcher should have a circular cross section, rather than a point? Why is that?


Thanks for that Bill. By the way, how do you calibrate your tuner? I'm thinking of using it, as I don't have a decent chromatic tuner.

You don't need to, unless you think that the clock in your sound card is out. There are two ways of checking, you can check against another tuner, or the signal generator I put on the tuner web page, or you can record a tone, say from a melodeon, play it back and compare with the instrument. That's how I found out that some sound cards are out, I didn't believe it until I'd proved it. Dirk's tuner has a calibrate feature to take care of that. I tried to do the same but couldn't get it to work well enough. Macs have that feature built in, and I found the clock on my daughter's macbook was out.

Ah, I assumed that your signal generator would suffer from the same problem, I thought that it would be based on the clock. Good good! I tested mine and it needed a miniscule correction (6 clicks). I tried working it just using the little microphone built into the laptop, unfortunately I don't have a reference tone, but it seemed to work pretty well, although it was a little slow to react at times. I tried testing one of the reeds on my PA and I'd run out of bellows before it had stabilised! Mind you, I run out of bellows pretty quickly anyway...
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 29, 2010, 02:25:40 AM
I made my own scratcher from an old Swiss needle file, one of the round tapered sort. I used the edge face of a carborundum oilstone to grind away the teeth of the file to make it smooth for about the last inch or so, and also to reduce the tip diameter to about 0.5 mm. It's important to grind the teeth off the file for the last inch in order to avoid damaging the slot sides of the reed plate when working on the underneath 'pull' reeds.

I finally ground the tip to a flat surface, so looking end on, it was a flat circle 0.5 mm in diameter, with sharp edges.The steel is hard enough to scratch the reed, but you need to have the oilstone on hand whilst working on the reeds in order to periodically touch up and maintain the sharpness of the scratcher. A x10 or x20 hand-lens (which all geologists have, of course) is useful to check on the sharpness, and you can also feel the sharpness by testing it carefully against the side of your thumb.

Ah right, so the scratcher should have a circular cross section, rather than a point? Why is that?
I'm not saying that it necessarily has to have a circular cross-section, neither should it have taper down to a fine point. But the old needle file I converted into a scratcher was a circular cross-section anyway. I didn't grind it down to a sharp point, partly for the sake of maintaining some strength at the tip, and also because it would have entailed even more tedious hand-grinding to take it down that far. I also think that a sharp needle-pointed scratcher would tend to risk digging into the steel reed tongue when you push the scratcher towards the rivet end of the tongue, rather than cutting a controlled shallow groove.

The key thing is to maintain a sharp edge to the circular tip, by fairly frequent touching up on the oilstone.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Bill the Farmer on October 30, 2010, 06:09:13 PM
Ah, I assumed that your signal generator would suffer from the same problem, I thought that it would be based on the clock. Good good! I tested mine and it needed a miniscule correction (6 clicks). I tried working it just using the little microphone built into the laptop, unfortunately I don't have a reference tone, but it seemed to work pretty well, although it was a little slow to react at times. I tried testing one of the reeds on my PA and I'd run out of bellows before it had stabilised! Mind you, I run out of bellows pretty quickly anyway...

Laptops seem to have separate devices for the microphone and the speakers. The speaker clock is always fine, otherwise audio files would play off key, but they don't seem to worry about recording. That's why the signal generator works. It's a bit of a trade off with the response time, you can either resolve similar notes, so you can see more than one reed at a time, or have a faster response, but not both.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on October 30, 2010, 06:25:46 PM
I'm not saying that it necessarily has to have a circular cross-section, neither should it have taper down to a fine point. But the old needle file I converted into a scratcher was a circular cross-section anyway. I didn't grind it down to a sharp point, partly for the sake of maintaining some strength at the tip, and also because it would have entailed even more tedious hand-grinding to take it down that far. I also think that a sharp needle-pointed scratcher would tend to risk digging into the steel reed tongue when you push the scratcher towards the rivet end of the tongue, rather than cutting a controlled shallow groove.

The key thing is to maintain a sharp edge to the circular tip, by fairly frequent touching up on the oilstone.

Ah right. I think that I now understand more about the scratcher, thank you (:)

Laptops seem to have separate devices for the microphone and the speakers. The speaker clock is always fine, otherwise audio files would play off key, but they don't seem to worry about recording. That's why the signal generator works. It's a bit of a trade off with the response time, you can either resolve similar notes, so you can see more than one reed at a time, or have a faster response, but not both.

I will give it a go and tell you how I get on (:)
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: malcolmbebb on October 30, 2010, 06:33:43 PM
Intrigued by these computerised tuning aids - can somebody give me an explanation - or a link? (or, indeed, both)

I'm guessing using the computer's sound card with some software to make a tuner?

Malcolm
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Lester on October 30, 2010, 06:44:35 PM
Intrigued by these computerised tuning aids - can somebody give me an explanation - or a link? (or, indeed, both)

I'm guessing using the computer's sound card with some software to make a tuner?

Malcolm

Dirk's Tuner (http://www.dirksprojects.nl/index.php?Page=Tuner/accordion_tuner.php)
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: forrest on October 30, 2010, 08:11:43 PM
There is also one essential ingredient that is necessary for tuning and repair, not available from any suppliers:
                                 
                                                    P_A_T_I_E_N_C_E.

 If you haven't mastered the correct technique, learn it.

 If you don't have the correct tool, obtain it.

 If you don't have the proper material, find it.

 If you just can't wait to finish and hear how it sounds, take a breather.

 Professionals, like Theo and others, are accomplished craftsmen who have a great wealth of experience in the art of repair and tuning of free reed instruments. They can move fairly quickly because of their  experience, confidence, and equipment. The rest of us, in our different levels of skill must proceed more cautiously. We are extremely fortunate to have the goodwill and helpful advice willingly shared by the professionals on this forum. Many operations necessary for repair and tuning can be irreversible, but I believe that most of us are certainly capable of learning and accomplishing excellent results. Patience could make the difference between a great playing instrument :||: with a great feeling of satisfaction, ;D ........or merely a sad tale   :'(.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Lester on October 30, 2010, 08:14:59 PM
There is also one essential ingredient that is necessary for tuning and repair, not available from any suppliers:
                                 
                                                    P_A_T_I_E_N_C_E.

 If you haven't mastered the correct technique, learn it.

 If you don't have the correct tool, obtain it.

 If you don't have the proper material, find it.

 If you just can't wait to finish and hear how it sounds, take a breather.

 Professionals, like Theo and others, are accomplished craftsmen who have a great wealth of experience in the art of repair and tuning of free reed instruments. They can move fairly quickly because of their  experience, confidence, and equipment. The rest of us, in our different levels of skill must proceed more cautiously. We are extremely fortunate to have the goodwill and helpful advice willingly shared by the professionals on this forum. Many operations necessary for repair and tuning can be irreversible, but I believe that most of us are certainly capable of learning and accomplishing excellent results. Patience could make the difference between a great playing instrument :||: with a great feeling of satisfaction, ;D ........or merely a sad tale   :'(.

Is there any way of getting  P_A_T_I_E_N_C_E quickly   >:E
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Lester on October 30, 2010, 08:17:57 PM
Today I have discovered that to clean up and brighten a my rather sad old Pokerwork polishing the pokerwork with Solvol Autosol is really good. Fetches all the grime and grot off along with a very, very small amount of the original finish then a quick buff up and it looks really good.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: forrest on October 30, 2010, 08:27:43 PM

Is there any way of getting  P_A_T_I_E_N_C_E quickly   >:E

Why yes, Lester.....I have found that instantly wrecking something precious and expensive works for me....!  ::)
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Lester on October 30, 2010, 09:09:43 PM

Is there any way of getting  P_A_T_I_E_N_C_E quickly   >:E

Why yes, Lester.....I have found that instantly wrecking something precious and expensive works for me....!  ::)

Good point, well made!
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on October 31, 2010, 01:15:10 AM
Another question, bellows tape. PVA or special glue (i.e. Charlie Marshall's stuff). PCA would be more convenient, but both are cheap. I've heard contrasting reports on this forum regarding use of PVA, hence why I ask.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Lester on October 31, 2010, 08:12:11 AM
I have used Charlie's "Special" glue and it worked well have not used anything else so can't compare. Mind you his set of instructions have a heavily crossed out first line which recommend using Wallpaper Overlap and Border Adhesive (http://www.homebase.co.uk/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/ProductDisplay?langId=-1&storeId=20001&partNumber=920351&Trail=searchtext%3EOVERLAP) so that is another option.

Previous post that may be of interest HERE (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4390.msg55658.html#msg55658)
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on November 04, 2010, 01:39:02 PM
Ah well, no going back now :o Just spent masses and masses of money on parts and tools. Well, admittedly far far less than I would spend getting someone competent to repair my boxes, but still more than they are worth :P

It'll be interesting how far I get this term. I am not expecting to get very far, due to work and other commitments, but with luck I should at least have cleaned, revalved and rewaxed one of the three.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on November 05, 2010, 12:08:06 PM
Happy to report that along with everybody else on this forum I cannot recommend Charlie Marshall's services highly enough (:)
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on November 06, 2010, 04:55:49 PM
Stuff is arriving gradually, should be able to begin very shortly.

CGM's "pingers" are not reed lifters, as I had assumed, but a bit of judicous trimming makes them perfectly adequate. I can now lift reeds with the german method. Required a bit of practice, mainly because I was very cautious about damaging the tip, but now all is well. It requires me to slip a bit of blue-tac paper underneath it before I can shim it with the same tool, but all is well otherwise. I use the Italian method for bass reeds, using a bent bit of paperclip, which seems to work amazingly well. Not suitable for treble reeds though, as I think that it would scratch it massively.

I do have a few questions.

Although I don't think that any reed is sticking (although I haven't tested them all properly) some of them aren't perfectly level, i.e. the reed is skewed slightly. Is this something that I should be worried about and is it something that I can fix? I have heard people talk about adjusting the gap between the top of the reed and the slot, but have no idea how one would go about doing it.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: blafleur on November 06, 2010, 06:08:11 PM
Don't worry so much what the reed looks like when starting out, only what it sounds like. After you've tuned a few you'll learn to recognize a problem by looking at the reed.  Sound each individual reed, there should be an instant response.  If you hear a rush of air before the reed sounds ( and sometimes doesn't sound at all on the little reeds), the gap is probably too big, in other words, the tip of the reed is sitting too high above the reed plate.  If the reed doesn't sound at all (and no rush of air), or sounds choked before sounding, the gap is probably too small.  All of these problems can also be caused by bad leathers, leathers hanging up, or debris in the reed.

You also need to do this after tuning because sometimes tuning will alter the reed gap. Filing on a good quality reed will sometimes pull a piece of metal to the edge of the reed and it will either hit the slot side or stick. If it's just hitting, you'll get a metallic sound when sounding.

There are far more knowledgeable people here than me, but to reset the reed gap, I just bend the reed (VERRRRRRY CAREFULLY) in the desired direction, a very little at a time, checking response.  The large reeds take a fair amount to change the gap, but be especially cautious on the little reeds, it's easy to bend just the tip and that's not good.  On the little reeds I usually us a scalpel blade (flat part) to work the reed so the there's less chance of putting too much force on the very tip.   

Anyone not agree the info I've put, please do not refrain from calling me on it.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on November 06, 2010, 06:29:22 PM
There are three dimensions involved and I'm not sure about any of them. There is the rotation perpendicular to the reed plate, where the reed bends away from the plate (which I have on some of my bass reeds). I think this is what you are referring to blafleur.

There is also the rotation about the rivet, where the gap between the side of the reed and the slot changes. Then there is also the height of the reed, where the gap between the top of the reed and the slot changes. From a site search I see that a way of doing this is to take a small hammer and hit the top of the plate with the end of the reed resting on a flat metal surface (as in the Maugein video). This does not strike me as an easy job :-\
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on November 08, 2010, 06:17:29 PM
Any more opinions on this? I'm starting to dissemble and clean reeds before revalving and rewaxing this weekend.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Lester on November 08, 2010, 06:45:53 PM
Any more opinions on this? I'm starting to dissemble and clean reeds before revalving and rewaxing this weekend.

I have gone through the worry stage that you seem to be at, what you need to do is give it a go. Once you get going you will learn with every thing you do. I have finished my first wax/valve/tune, it took a long time, I broke one reed, but I learned masses which will make the next one easier, etc etc.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on November 08, 2010, 07:55:13 PM
Any more opinions on this? I'm starting to dissemble and clean reeds before revalving and rewaxing this weekend.

I have gone through the worry stage that you seem to be at, what you need to do is give it a go. Once you get going you will learn with every thing you do. I have finished my first wax/valve/tune, it took a long time, I broke one reed, but I learned masses which will make the next one easier, etc etc.

This is quite true! The thing is that I won't have time to do anything until the weekend (probably, unless I decide that work is optional), so I've got lots of time to worry... I think I'm prepared for everything up until tuning, but I suddenly thought of this issue of reed alignment and thought I'd check :P
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on November 08, 2010, 07:57:39 PM
Ooh, another question. The reed plates on my PA are waxed in but have tacks as well. I was planning on removing these and not replacing them. Is this a hideous idea? I had a feeling that someone recommended doing it and it would be a right pain to put them all back again.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: waltzman on November 08, 2010, 11:08:02 PM
Ooh, another question. The reed plates on my PA are waxed in but have tacks as well. I was planning on removing these and not replacing them. Is this a hideous idea? I had a feeling that someone recommended doing it and it would be a right pain to put them all back again.

I think the consensus is that the tacks are unnecessary.  I believe Theo has mentioned that he has a bucket full of them.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on November 08, 2010, 11:10:17 PM
Excellent. Mind you, if it turned out that they were essential then I would conveniently mishear :P There is no way I'm replacing all of them. Would be worse than retaping bellows (which I'm not exactly looking forward to).
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Lester on November 08, 2010, 11:37:17 PM
Would be worse than retaping bellows (which I'm not exactly looking forward to).

Retaping bellows is a hideous task, I am part way through my second go and at least this time the tape came off easily but I am still scraping the old glue off, I am ~3/4 hours into it and still about another hour before I start retaping. It is a dirty/dusty/tedious horrible job but kind of satisfying when it is complete  ;)
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on November 09, 2010, 02:04:28 AM
Would be worse than retaping bellows (which I'm not exactly looking forward to).

Retaping bellows is a hideous task, I am part way through my second go and at least this time the tape came off easily but I am still scraping the old glue off, I am ~3/4 hours into it and still about another hour before I start retaping. It is a dirty/dusty/tedious horrible job but kind of satisfying when it is complete  ;)

Well I've done a *lot* of cardboard modelling in my time, so I have a lot of patience with bits of paper and glue. I'm imagining it to be unpleasant though and am fully expecting to leave it to the holidays where I can spend an entire day or two on it.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: forrest on November 09, 2010, 02:58:15 AM
Any more opinions on this? I'm starting to dissemble and clean reeds before revalving and rewaxing this weekend.

Hello Ukebert, this may come in a bit late, but you should probably look over this website (http://talkingreeds.com/) to get some background on reed repair. It gives you an overview of the task at hand, and much useful and worthwhile information.

Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on November 09, 2010, 11:52:59 AM
Any more opinions on this? I'm starting to dissemble and clean reeds before revalving and rewaxing this weekend.

Hello Ukebert, this may come in a bit late, but you should probably look over this website (http://talkingreeds.com/) to get some background on reed repair. It gives you an overview of the task at hand, and much useful and worthwhile information.



It isn't late and thank you very much (:)
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: blafleur on November 09, 2010, 02:23:10 PM
That is a great site that I've never seen before. Thanks for posting J.W.

Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on November 14, 2010, 12:57:24 AM
Started today! Didn't get that much time, but managed to strip my 1 row of treble reeds, take what remained of the old valves off, cleaned and checked the clearances.

Theo's tip with the PCB polishing block works a treat by the way. Rust just disappears. The reed pan on the 1140 is pretty poor quality, when I was taking one of the pins out it took some of the pan with it. I've glued it back on, looks better now. The reed pinger from CGM (still haven't worked out what that is for) works very well at scraping off old wax, as it is thin at one end, so you can apply more pressure, but isn't sharp, so you don't scratch the pan/block.

Tomorrow aim is to revalve and rewax that one and hopefully tackle the bass end as well.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on November 15, 2010, 03:14:16 AM
OK, bostik. How do you make it usable? It is so sticky, it just separates into massive strands and is impossible to apply. The only way that I could do it is to apply the glue directly to the underside of the valve, but it is so easy to apply and when it contracts then it buckles the valve and I have to discard it. Tips? A friend suggested putting it on the radiator for a few minutes to heat it up.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Lester on November 15, 2010, 08:01:26 AM
OK, bostik. How do you make it usable? It is so sticky, it just separates into massive strands and is impossible to apply. The only way that I could do it is to apply the glue directly to the underside of the valve, but it is so easy to apply and when it contracts then it buckles the valve and I have to discard it. Tips? A friend suggested putting it on the radiator for a few minutes to heat it up.

I just lay the tube down on my glueing board (IKEA plastic chopping board) and by gently applying pressure a small amount of glue can be dispensed directly on to the valve which, if pressed firmly in place, should not crinkle.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Broadland Boy on November 15, 2010, 08:47:45 PM
Or a blob on a matchstick / toothpick / wire / point ended object of own choice so you have the equivalent to the 'unsend' key which you may get if picking it up on the valve from the tube nozzle (teashirt etc. etc.)

Reading through History unfolds they use a backlight and reedplate sized hole in a blanking sheet so you can see if the reed it centralised in the plate by the line of light around it - may also show up any burrs / corrosion / other cr@p which might distort its dulcet tones......

Richard
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Christopher K. on November 15, 2010, 10:19:28 PM
Quote
I just lay the tube down on my glueing board (IKEA plastic chopping board)...

Brilliant, hadn't thought of going there for assorted workbench items. Compared with the Home Creepo, $0.69 for a work surface is a steal. I bet there are all sorts of things in there waiting to be re-purposed.

Imagine : "Yes dear, I'd love to go to IKEA! Love to!" She used to have to bribe me with creamed herring.

Sorry for the diversion. It is an interesting thread, please proceed...  ;D
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on November 16, 2010, 01:17:09 AM
Progress:

Work is slow, as I can only really spend an hour a day or so. The one row has had all of it's reeds stripped, cleaned, reset and revalved on one side. I'm not sure how critical revalving the uppermost side is before tuning, I suppose that it would make some difference. Bellows gasket has been replaced (and annoyingly leaks on one corner, due to the join overlapping, which of course I didn't notice). I've tried filling said join with glue, if that doesn't work I'll put new gasket on again. I need to attach the strap brackets and thumbstrap (I'm thinking a locknut or similar), rewax (hopefully done tomorrow, depending on how things go), new grille cloth and of course tuning.

The Weltmeister needs new gaskets, reed overhaul (although the reeds are in better condition than the hohner, the bass action needs swedging, retuning, new bellows straps. Also needs a new grille and ideally a new fingerboard, which will be fun. The grille I've started on, the fingerboard will provide much needed practice with CAD/CAM. Might start the reed overhaul this week, I'm quite enjoying it. Very relaxing.

The PA I'm leaving for a bit, mainly because I've realised just how difficult waxing in the tiny reeds is going to be, so I'm leaving that till last. That needs retaping, new bellows straps, full reed overhaul, new gaskets and so on.

Tuning is still the storm cloud on my horizon. I'm sort of prepared except that I still don't have a scraper.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 16, 2010, 07:31:59 AM
<snip>
Bellows gasket has been replaced (and annoyingly leaks on one corner, due to the join overlapping, which of course I didn't notice). I've tried filling said join with glue, if that doesn't work I'll put new gasket on again.
</snip>
For what it's worth, my methodology is that if there is a sufficiently good seal on the old bellows gasket to enable you to carry out the other restoration/reed work first, leave the gasket replacement as the last job to be done. The reason I do this is that whilst carrying out the other work, the repeated removal and re-assembly of the bellows from the instrument's ends may cause further detriment to the gasket and hence the air-tightness. Once you are happy with the reeds and the tuning, only then replace the bellows gasket, and then disturb it as little as possible thereafter.

If you have an air leak caused by a section of overlapping gasket, you should be able to use a very sharp blade to make a single cut vertically down through the overlapping strata (guess my profession!), remove the overthrust section and press the remaining part of the ramp down into place, butting it up to the other end of the gasket. It ought to butt up snugly and will become even more snug when the gasket is compressed on reassembly.

It is also not a good idea to have your join on a corner; make it on one of the straight sections instead.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Theo on November 16, 2010, 08:10:38 AM
Re: fitting 'outside' valve.   There is no point IMHO in not fitting the outside valve.  If you use a good  slim scratched you only need to lift the valve a tiny amount to get the scratched, or the reed lifter into position.  Fitting the valve does make a small but significant flattening of the pitch of the reed.  If you plan to have wet tuning it probably won't be noticable,  but with dry or swing tuning you will not get a good result.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on November 16, 2010, 01:12:19 PM
Re: fitting 'outside' valve.   There is no point IMHO in not fitting the outside valve.  If you use a good  slim scratched you only need to lift the valve a tiny amount to get the scratched, or the reed lifter into position.  Fitting the valve does make a small but significant flattening of the pitch of the reed.  If you plan to have wet tuning it probably won't be noticable,  but with dry or swing tuning you will not get a good result.

Cool, I'll do that then.

<snip>
Bellows gasket has been replaced (and annoyingly leaks on one corner, due to the join overlapping, which of course I didn't notice). I've tried filling said join with glue, if that doesn't work I'll put new gasket on again.
</snip>
For what it's worth, my methodology is that if there is a sufficiently good seal on the old bellows gasket to enable you to carry out the other restoration/reed work first, leave the gasket replacement as the last job to be done. The reason I do this is that whilst carrying out the other work, the repeated removal and re-assembly of the bellows from the instrument's ends may cause further detriment to the gasket and hence the air-tightness. Once you are happy with the reeds and the tuning, only then replace the bellows gasket, and then disturb it as little as possible thereafter.

If you have an air leak caused by a section of overlapping gasket, you should be able to use a very sharp blade to make a single cut vertically down through the overlapping strata (guess my profession!), remove the overthrust section and press the remaining part of the ramp down into place, butting it up to the other end of the gasket. It ought to butt up snugly and will become even more snug when the gasket is compressed on reassembly.

It is also not a good idea to have your join on a corner; make it on one of the straight sections instead.

Good advice. You misunderstand me though, the join is on the box, not the gasket! It's got mitred corners, but there is a bit of a gap where some wood has been chipped away or something. In future though I will fit the gasket last.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 16, 2010, 03:21:21 PM
Good advice. You misunderstand me though, the join is on the box, not the gasket! It's got mitred corners, but there is a bit of a gap where some wood has been chipped away or something.
Ah - that's more like it. I thought it sounded a bit odd!
Yes - you can use PVA woodworking glue to fill small gaps. It's even better if you can get some fine wood dust approximately the same colour as the original wood. Rub some scrap wood on a file or carborundum paper and collect the wood dust. Mix it with a blob of glue and then gradually feed it in to the gap. You might need to use several applications to fill a deep hole. When thoroughly dry, file/sand smooth.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Theo on November 16, 2010, 03:39:02 PM
One problem with pva is that you really need to get the joint completely apart to get the glue to all parts.  If you just press pva into trhe visible cracks you may stop the air leaks but quite probably the joint will still be weak and may spring open again. In this sort of case you would cause much greater damage by taking the casing apart to get the glue where it needs to be.   

In this situation I much prefer to use superglue/cyanoacrylate because it is able to penetrate into the finest cracks by capillary action.    Use a good quality well know brand, and don't use the thicker gel types, nor the extra thin type.   Use clamps to get the crack to close up before applying any glue, the feed the superglue along all visible parts of the crack inside the box as well as outside,   after a few moments you should see the liquid disappear along the line of the crack,  when this happens add a little more glue and continue adding it until no more is absorbed.   Then leave the clamps in place for 25 hours - superglue sometimes needs longer to fully cure in deep cracks.

The result should be an airtight joint with good resistance to future cracking.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on November 16, 2010, 07:45:30 PM
One problem with pva is that you really need to get the joint completely apart to get the glue to all parts.  If you just press pva into trhe visible cracks you may stop the air leaks but quite probably the joint will still be weak and may spring open again. In this sort of case you would cause much greater damage by taking the casing apart to get the glue where it needs to be.    

In this situation I much prefer to use superglue/cyanoacrylate because it is able to penetrate into the finest cracks by capillary action.    Use a good quality well know brand, and don't use the thicker gel types, nor the extra thin type.   Use clamps to get the crack to close up before applying any glue, the feed the superglue along all visible parts of the crack inside the box as well as outside,   after a few moments you should see the liquid disappear along the line of the crack,  when this happens add a little more glue and continue adding it until no more is absorbed.   Then leave the clamps in place for 25 hours - superglue sometimes needs longer to fully cure in deep cracks.

The result should be an airtight joint with good resistance to future cracking.

Ah - that's more like it. I thought it sounded a bit odd!
Yes - you can use PVA woodworking glue to fill small gaps. It's even better if you can get some fine wood dust approximately the same colour as the original wood. Rub some scrap wood on a file or carborundum paper and collect the wood dust. Mix it with a blob of glue and then gradually feed it in to the gap. You might need to use several applications to fill a deep hole. When thoroughly dry, file/sand smooth.

Thanks for that Theo and Steve. The joint hasn't split apart, it's just a bit damaged. I don't have any scrap wood (unless I use some of College's furniture :P) and don't have any superglue, but if I do have to reglue a joint then I will bear that in mind. In this case, I've dabbed a bit of wax over it and it's sealing a lot better now. I may still redo the gasket after finishing the rest of it though.

Progress for today: Finished revalving and rewaxed treble and bass ends. Had a few plates that were initially waxed in the wrong places on the bass end, but that is fixed now. Note to self: it is all very well keeping the order of the plates constant in whatever you do, but just in case you have got them mixed up, it's a good idea to check before waxing!

The treble side I have tested and all notes sound, in the right order in the right direction, with no warbles, rattles etc. which is encouraging. The bass end is drying as we speak. Or as I type, anyway. I've been using an encaustic stylus to wax, which takes a bit of getting used to, but is very easy to do once you've got the hang of it. Plug it in, wait to warm up, stick into wax block and draw along like a pen. The tricky bit is getting the speed right, too slow and the wax is too thick, too thin and it won't make a good seal. It helps to angle it so that you can see the wax flowing out of the head. Some of my plates aren't waxed in particularly neatly, but this was my first time and I'm fairly pleased with it.

I've also installed some strap brackets, replaced the treble grille cloth and have replaced half of the bass end cloth. After that I need to test the pallets for leaks, replace as necessary and then it's just tuning...

Might do a reed overhaul on the Weltmeister first :P I'm enjoying reed work and I love the smell of reed wax (although I hear that it isn't very good for you).
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Theo on November 16, 2010, 11:58:24 PM
:P I'm enjoying reed work and I love the smell of reed wax (although I hear that it isn't very good for you).

Wax fumes gave me asthma.  It is no joke.  You must avoid inhaling the fumes from the melted wax.  The nice smell from the warm wax as it cools is probably safe, but if you encaustic stylus produces any fumes then for the sake of your health you should work with a fume extractor.  Anyone in the university who does soldering should have one.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on November 17, 2010, 02:01:26 AM
:P I'm enjoying reed work and I love the smell of reed wax (although I hear that it isn't very good for you).

Wax fumes gave me asthma.  It is no joke.  You must avoid inhaling the fumes from the melted wax.  The nice smell from the warm wax as it cools is probably safe, but if you encaustic stylus produces any fumes then for the sake of your health you should work with a fume extractor.  Anyone in the university who does soldering should have one.

I haven't seen any smoke, no wax is burning. The stylus is warm enough that you notice if it touches you but nowhere near warm enough to burn you. I don't know how to know whether it is a problem, does wax just give off harmful fumes when it melts? If so that is really quite inconvenient :P

I think I trapped one of the bass chord valves under the plate, it's rattling. Bother, nearly perfect. Also a few reeds seem to have shot sharp, markedly. I'm wondering whether I've done something to them or whether it's just a byproduct of an overhaul.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Christopher K. on November 17, 2010, 03:06:03 AM
Quote
...you should be able to use a very sharp blade to make a single cut vertically down through the overlapping strata (guess my profession!)...

Dunno, prolly a gneiss one you shouldn't take for granite.. chalk full of interesting specimens, no doubt..

'coat!  :|glug

(The missus and I are rockhounds, too, albeit of the amateur variety.)
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 17, 2010, 06:49:38 AM
I think I trapped one of the bass chord valves under the plate, it's rattling. Bother, nearly perfect.
Bother indeed :( !
The valve may be fouling the side or end of the chamber and not lifting correctly, allowing the reed tongue to vibrate against the valve. At least you've identified the most likely cause and can proceed to investigate and put it right.

Quote
Also a few reeds seem to have shot sharp, markedly. I'm wondering whether I've done something to them or whether it's just a byproduct of an overhaul.
The change in pitch is probably a result of the rewaxing and revalving. The final frequency of the reed tongue is partly controlled by the acoustic coupling between the tongue and all the other nearby components which 'force' their own frequencies on to the tongue vibration. Rewaxing will change ('improve') that acoustic coupling and renewing the valves will also have an effect too. This is why it is very desirable to do the final tuning with the reed blocks in-situ, using the instrument's own bellows or else a tuning bellows of the same dimensions as the instrument's. 
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on November 17, 2010, 11:48:45 AM
I think I trapped one of the bass chord valves under the plate, it's rattling. Bother, nearly perfect.
Bother indeed :( !
The valve may be fouling the side or end of the chamber and not lifting correctly, allowing the reed tongue to vibrate against the valve. At least you've identified the most likely cause and can proceed to investigate and put it right.

Well I got the offending reed plate wrong, so I unwaxed two before I found the right one. I've rewaxed it, it still rattled. I removed both valves and rewaxed it again, it still rattled, I've just this moment realised what it must be and have tested. The reed was fouling the plate ever so slightly. Not enough to prevent it sounding, but enough to get it to rattle.  Most annoying. Still, it isn't any more, I've reset it.

Another thing that I've found is that there is a substantial delay before one of my reeds sounds. Is this to do with tip clearance or reed angle away from the plate or something?

Quote
The change in pitch is probably a result of the rewaxing and revalving. The final frequency of the reed tongue is partly controlled by the acoustic coupling between the tongue and all the other nearby components which 'force' their own frequencies on to the tongue vibration. Rewaxing will change ('improve') that acoustic coupling and renewing the valves will also have an effect too. This is why it is very desirable to do the final tuning with the reed blocks in-situ, using the instrument's own bellows or else a tuning bellows of the same dimensions as the instrument's. 

Cool, that's what I thought. As long as it isn't me, all is well!

This instrument is flat mounted, which makes some things more difficult. Not sure whether it's best to start tuning this or to start with the Weltmeister. This one is worth more to me (and worth more in real terms) and also has H reeds instead of T reeds (which are no longer available), so it might be more sensible to start with the welty.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on November 18, 2010, 12:30:27 PM
OK, three questions:

Firstly, different response times, it this due to the angle that the reed makes with the plate, in the direction normal to the plate?

Secondly, one of my reds plays fine at very low pressures but sharpens at higher pressures. I don't know what this means but I'm guessing that it's bad :( To my knowledge I haven't done anything to it, haven't started tuning yet.

Thirdly is there an easy way of stripping old pallet leather off pallets? It's a horrible job and I'm worried that I'm not making the surface as flat as it should be.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: blafleur on November 18, 2010, 02:40:48 PM
Delays in reed response with audible air is either a leak, or the opposite reed valve is either hung open or in bad shape, but usually the reed tip gap is too big.  As you be finding out by now, it takes very little to make a big difference in these contraptions.  You should be able to compare the reed gap with the surrounding ones to get an idea if it's too big, if it's a visible reed. 

I also found, like you, that making changes inside can often affect tune. 
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Theo on November 18, 2010, 02:54:50 PM
Reeds that sharpen can be caused by something fouling the reed tongue in the lower third of the reed tongue.  Sometimes glue from the adjacent valve can squeeze out enough to reach the reed.

I peel off pallet leathers with the aid of a sharp knife, then sand down to clean wood with a sheet of coarse abrasive paper glued into a board.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 18, 2010, 03:02:33 PM
OK, three questions:

Firstly, different response times, it this due to the angle that the reed makes with the plate, in the direction normal to the plate?

Secondly, one of my reds plays fine at very low pressures but sharpens at higher pressures. I don't know what this means but I'm guessing that it's bad :( To my knowledge I haven't done anything to it, haven't started tuning yet.

Thirdly is there an easy way of stripping old pallet leather off pallets? It's a horrible job and I'm worried that I'm not making the surface as flat as it should be.
Ans.1
Yes, the set of the reed - the gap - governs the response. If the gap is too wide, the reed will be slow to start and may sound loud but breathy when it does get going. If the gap is too narrow, the reed will speak easily at low bellows pressure, but will tend to choke off at higher pressures. A gap which is exceptionally narrow may fail to speak at all. Compare with the gap of neighbouring reeds that do have the correct response.

Ans.2
This also sounds as if the gap is not adjusted correctly. I think I am right in saying that a gap which is slightly too narrow will exhibit the pitch changes you mention - i.e. sharpens at higher pressures. But this isn't necessarily a constant rule.

The gap can be adjusted very carefully. To increase the gap, slide a thin shim under the reed tongue to about 1/3 or 1/2 its length and very gently lever up the reed tongue until you begin to feel a little bit of increased resistance. Do this a little bit at a time, checking the result by sounding the reed either in the instrument or on the block on a tuning bellows. You may not be able to notice any difference visually - small fractions of a milimetre can make all the difference.

To reduce the gap, use a non-scratching pointy thing like a cocktail stick to gently depress the reed into the slot a few times. Again go very carefully, a bit at a time and test the result constantly.

For reeds on the underside of the reed plate the procedure is the same, except it is more awkward to make the gap narrower. You will need to use a reed lifter - either the Italian hook style, or the Hohner lever style - to pull the reed into the reed plate slot and then lift it even further with a shim.

For each reed there will be a 'sweet spot' setting where the adjustment is just right. The amount of gap can also be tailored to your own playing style. If you are a habitual forceful bellows player, you will need a slightly increased gap setting. Remember that the gap setting can affect the tuning, and also that filing/scratching a reed to tune it can change the stresses in the reed tongue which may cause it to bend very slightly with resulting effects on the gap. So - it's a wonder that reeds can ever be tuned and respond properly. But of course they can even though it is a trade-off compromise between speed of response and constancy of pitch at differing bellows pressures. It goes to show that tuning and setting a reed is an art and fine skill, where experience, patience and a good ear are the best teachers. Don't be too afraid of trying it - it's the only way to learn, but go very carefully.

Except in a single voice box, you will have two or more reeds sounding together for each button, so it is important that the gap for all the reeds on each button is set so that all the reeds speak at the same time, otherwise you will get uneven tremolo as first one reed speaks and then the second reed joins in a fraction of a second later.  

Ans.3
I've only done this once. I removed all the pallets from the rods and pulled off most of the old facing material with my fingers, then used a Stanley knife blade as a scraper to remove the residual leather/felt and glue. I finished off by gently sanding each pallet face just down to bare wood (but no further) by rubbing on a sheet of carborundum paper laid on top of a flat surface (a scrap piece of melamine-covered board). Clearly you need to maintain as flat a surface as you can on the pallet face, but if the replacement facing material is a felt/leather composite (such as Charlie Marshall sells), there is sufficient 'give' to accommodate minor departures from optical flatness.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on November 18, 2010, 07:05:45 PM
MY GOD :P Thanks everyone, even more to think about ;D
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on November 22, 2010, 03:53:08 AM
Got a lot of work this week, so probably not much happening on this until the weekend :( However, got my first commission :P Ollie has asked me to rewax a bass reed plate that has fallen off. Exciting times! :P

I have another question which has just occurred to me. My first box, on the pull D bass, the note would sound fine until you pulled it hard, whereupon it made a sound like a vibraslap. Is this a case of something fouling the bottom half of the reed, as above, or what? I don't have it any more, but I always wondered why it did that.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: blafleur on November 22, 2010, 12:03:12 PM
That's usually caused by the reed valve in some manner, either it's getting caught and the reed is hitting it, or is having some of those sympathetic vibrations.  Reed valves serve a great purpose, but they sure like to cause trouble now and then.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: an bosca ceoil on November 22, 2010, 11:36:03 PM
As some of you will know, I've gone a bit overboard on eBay over the last few weeks, exams being my excuse. This means that I have a number of boxes that need fixing up that I am intending to do something about over the next few months.
Cannot recall seeing any mention of Preciosa or Regina in this thread.
Unless you have a doppelganger, can only assume MAD symptoms to be worsening?
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on November 22, 2010, 11:42:16 PM
As some of you will know, I've gone a bit overboard on eBay over the last few weeks, exams being my excuse. This means that I have a number of boxes that need fixing up that I am intending to do something about over the next few months.
Cannot recall seeing any mention of Preciosa or Regina in this thread.
Unless you have a doppelganger, can only assume MAD symptoms to be worsening?

Yes, MAD symptoms are worsening as always :P
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on December 02, 2010, 11:02:56 AM
Nothing done over the last few weeks :( Work has caught up on me. Bit cautious about the weather, my heating only comes on after midnight and I'm wondering whether gluing is a good idea with the cold.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Steve_freereeder on December 02, 2010, 05:04:40 PM
my heating only comes on after midnight
Erm... Doesn't your thermostat/timer need adjusting?
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on December 03, 2010, 04:32:35 AM
my heating only comes on after midnight
Erm... Doesn't your thermostat/timer need adjusting?

Hah. As if college gave us access to such things :P

I think they've changed it though, someone must have complained. I might move my workbench nearer the radiator.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on December 06, 2010, 10:42:08 PM
Took advantage of the milder day yesterday to do some more work.

Still haven't got round to cycling to the hardware store to buy sandpaper, so the pallets on the 1140 are still resolutely not refaced. Instead I started on the Weltmeister. I cleaned, revalved and rewaxed all the reeds on the F row, with great success, sounding lovely, no warbles or rattles. Slight problem is that I muddled up the reed plates on one side and I don't know which one. It will take some thinking to work out which plates need to be swapped and it is a tremendous nuisance. Never mind.

The bass end was also done, with one rattle, valve improperly glued. Fixed that. The bass reeds are rather slow to respond, so I adjusted the tip clearances fractionally which improved it a bit. They are supposed to be 3 voice though, two reeds and a third linked for every bass, so I suspect that the chamber size is slightly smaller than necessary for that reason.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Lester on December 07, 2010, 08:41:14 AM
Slight problem is that I muddled up the reed plates on one side and I don't know which one. It will take some thinking to work out which plates need to be swapped and it is a tremendous nuisance. Never mind.

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5400.msg68770.html#msg68770 (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5400.msg68770.html#msg68770)   ;)
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on December 07, 2010, 01:00:42 PM
Slight problem is that I muddled up the reed plates on one side and I don't know which one. It will take some thinking to work out which plates need to be swapped and it is a tremendous nuisance. Never mind.

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5400.msg68770.html#msg68770 (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5400.msg68770.html#msg68770)   ;)

I know, I know :P I forgot about the half row. I knew that I had put them back wrong, so sorted them into size but forgot the half row was on that reedblook :P
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Theo on December 07, 2010, 01:16:12 PM
When I replace a set of reeds I first just tack the reeds in place with a spot of wax at each end of each reed plate, then I play through all the reeds on the tuning bellows, just to check that I have not good a reed plate flipped over, or some other error.  If its a box where there are more rows of buttons than reedblocks (eg one of the smaller clubs) I'll put the blocks into the instrument and play through all the notes.  Any misplaced reeds can then be easily be identified and put in the correct positions without having to remove lots of freshly placed wax.   It also shows up the presence of badly fitted valves.  This has saved me lots of time.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on December 07, 2010, 01:20:30 PM
That sounds like a very good idea. I'll bear that in mind for the next block :P
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on December 10, 2010, 03:55:59 AM
Thought that some might be interested in my thumb hook solution. Not the most elegant, prettiest or neatest solution, but quick, easy and cheap. I removed the old rivets using pliers and careful application of force and then used one of the holes to attach the new one. I used a 20mm, 4mm diameter bolt to go through the hole and through the thumbhook and then a nylon insert nut on the end. This is a nut which will stay on and won't unwind itself. It means that the thumbhook is free to rotate and can be easily removed. It looks rather unattractive, but it cost me a grand total of 30p and took minutes to fit.

In other news I've waxed one half of the bass block for the Weltmeister and have glued the pallets onto the felt/leather for the 1140. Tomorrow I'm hoping to do the other half of the Welty bass block, rewax the treble end, was the pallets into position and pack everything away, I'm going home on Sunday.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on December 10, 2010, 05:52:25 PM
Right, I've waxed the pallets in for the 1140 and everything is sealing beautifully. In fact I can almost declare the 1140 done bar tuning, apart from one reed which will not behave :( It seems to choke, not sounding unless there isn't much air in it. I solved the other reed problem with the bass end by clearing some glue which had crept to the side of the reed without me noticing, this didn't work this time. I probably won't unwax it and have another go for a few days, until then, any ideas on what I should look for?
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Lester on December 10, 2010, 06:00:54 PM
Am I reading you right that you are using wax to hold the pallets on. I'm a hot glue man myself, would not have thought wax was robust enough to hold pallets that move around unlike reeds that sit still. But YMMV?

ps, Half way through tuning my 1140, now just need to decide how much tremolo.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on December 10, 2010, 07:37:26 PM
Well my Bouebe is waxed in, it's fairly common I think. Besides, I don't have a hot glue gun but I do have lots of reed wax. I'll see how it goes, if it turns out to be useless then it's not much bother to replace. Remember that there should be no force acting to pull the pallets away from the levers at any time.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Theo on December 10, 2010, 07:49:25 PM
Remember that there should be no force acting to pull the pallets away from the levers at any time.

Clearly you aren't studying physics!  There is inertia, as the lever accelerates the pad away from the board for a start!
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: malcolmbebb on December 10, 2010, 07:50:59 PM
Don't you just hate it when somebody posts what you were in the middle of typing!
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Theo on December 10, 2010, 07:54:48 PM
Go on then Malcolm,  there are more forces that the one I started with:
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: malcolmbebb on December 10, 2010, 08:01:21 PM
LOL - this is one of those occasions when one ponders the wisdom of a previous post...

I was trying to make a pun on "it sucks", but it's been a long day - just settle for air pressure, unless there is a way of only playing squeeze notes on a one row...

and I'm sure John K could provide a few more :-)
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on December 10, 2010, 08:57:53 PM
Remember that there should be no force acting to pull the pallets away from the levers at any time.

Clearly you aren't studying physics!  There is inertia, as the lever accelerates the pad away from the board for a start!

Well yes, but then the pad is accelerated into the lever once the lever stops moving. You would get fatigue loading on the wax this way, but I'd be surprised if it would be significant in terms of the natural life of the wax (as it will go brittle eventually anyway). What else is there?

I hadn't thought of air pressure though. Again, I'd be surprised if it makes a difference. Time will tell.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on December 12, 2010, 02:21:44 AM
Played the 1140 today. Treble side is sounding nice, very rounded sound. Bass end I'm not happy with. It feels sluggish and I have a suspicion that I've used too thick valves. I'm thinking of starting again. Plus my gluing was evidently done in a bit of a hurry, since it has spread to the tongues in some places.

I'm also considering abandoning the encaustic stylus. It worked a treat on the 1140, but the Welty's reedblocks mean that the reeds are just close enough together that I can't get the iron in between. I tried laying wax on the previous plate and immediately, before it dried, jamming the next plate in, but either that doesn't work very well or I'm not very good at doing it. If I try to fill in the gap afterwards, it just lays wax on top of the gap and leaves an air gap between that and the block. Surface tension :(

I think that in that case the best bet might be Charlie Marshall's brush method. I was wondering whether anyone had tried using one of those little wax heaters that they have on eBay for manicures. I don't know what temperature they go up to, but it would be a neat way of melting wax. Otherwise I'll have to mess around with dimmer switches with my old soldering iron I suppose, but that method has always seemed rather messy. Or use a spoon or one of those pen things. More research needed!
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: malcolmbebb on December 12, 2010, 09:11:38 AM
As a thought, you could try wrapping some wire around the bit of your iron. You might get enough heat transfer to get the wire into awkward spaces but have enough heat to flow the wax.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Bill the Farmer on December 12, 2010, 03:44:58 PM
As a thought, you could try wrapping some wire around the bit of your iron. You might get enough heat transfer to get the wire into awkward spaces but have enough heat to flow the wax.

That works, I posted a photo (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4494.msg57077.html#msg57077) on here a while ago. It's no good for getting wax between the reed plates on a Liliput, neither is Charlie's tuna tin and paintbrush method. The paint brush fluffs up when you dip it in the wax. I just made sure there was plenty of melted wax on the side of the next slot and put the next reed plate down quick before it got cold.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on December 12, 2010, 08:57:01 PM
As a thought, you could try wrapping some wire around the bit of your iron. You might get enough heat transfer to get the wire into awkward spaces but have enough heat to flow the wax.

That works, I posted a photo (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4494.msg57077.html#msg57077) on here a while ago. It's no good for getting wax between the reed plates on a Liliput, neither is Charlie's tuna tin and paintbrush method. The paint brush fluffs up when you dip it in the wax. I just made sure there was plenty of melted wax on the side of the next slot and put the next reed plate down quick before it got cold.

I have seen people do that, this seems to be a good idea. It's still a bit of a nuisance, as the only wax that I have is in blocks rather than sticks, but I'm sure that a knife will cure that. I am also home, so there is a chance that I might be able to find some copper wire in the shed (:)

Annoying re: Liliput, as my Imperial has the same size and orientation of reeds (I believe). Sounds like what I was doing on the Welty is the right way forward, I just need more practice! Apart from anything, the stylus heats the wax only just beyond it's melting point, so that it dries very quickly. If I were to make two trips with wax I'd need to be pretty sharpish with the next plate.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Lars on December 12, 2010, 10:17:50 PM
I had a similar problem with my soldering iron - the tip being too large and too thick to get good results. I simply took an old file to the tip, and tapered the end (about an inch from the tip) down to a couple of mm. I've had to wax a couple of boxes where the reeds were too close for even that tip to work, so I did the 'wrapped wire' trick. Worked alright for a single box, but it was a bit annoying compared to the regular method.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on December 13, 2010, 12:10:03 AM
I had a similar problem with my soldering iron - the tip being too large and too thick to get good results. I simply took an old file to the tip, and tapered the end (about an inch from the tip) down to a couple of mm. I've had to wax a couple of boxes where the reeds were too close for even that tip to work, so I did the 'wrapped wire' trick. Worked alright for a single box, but it was a bit annoying compared to the regular method.

I thought of that, I have a spare tip, but For every mm you file down, you get less wax in the stylus. I will try it, I expect, but I'm fully expecting that it just won't be worth it.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: StupidFingers on December 16, 2010, 08:24:14 PM
I'm also considering abandoning the encaustic stylus. It worked a treat on the 1140, but the Welty's reedblocks mean that the reeds are just close enough together that I can't get the iron in between. I tried laying wax on the previous plate and immediately, before it dried, jamming the next plate in, but either that doesn't work very well or I'm not very good at doing it. If I try to fill in the gap afterwards, it just lays wax on top of the gap and leaves an air gap between that and the block. Surface tension :(

Hi.

One of the bad habits I picked up from my father when using a soldering iron with electronics is the stripping of insulation off of wire using the tip of the iron (smells funny and is the sort of thing the health and safety guys would be pulling their hair out over if one were to do it in a working environment).  He decided to take the larger of the two soldering irons in his possession and make a modification.  To the outside of the element he strapped a half inch wide strip of thin metal leaving a tag sticking out.  Into this tag he cut a "V" notch.  When the iron was hot, it was then possible to push a piece of insulated wire down into the notch, twist, then pull thus baring the wire.

If the tag could get hot enough to melt plastic, then a similar arrangement (with the tag adapted for the purpose) might be useful in melting wax in the smaller gaps between reed plates where it is not possible to fit the tip.  There is still the problem of getting the wax in there in the first place, but you could at least gain access to wax that was already there such as with your "jamming" technique.

Of course, this is all theoretical and I haven't tried this myself (yet!) so would require some experimentation somewhere you're not going to cause any damage!
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on December 18, 2010, 12:27:32 PM
Yesterday I decided that it would be quite possible to convert my Imperial to counterbass, as long as I didn't mind rebuilding a reedblock, building a new soundboard and rebuilding around 30% of the mechanism from scratch. Perhaps a bit of an ask :P

I do genuinely think though that 32 stradella with counterbass is possible for an instrument the size of a Liliput.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Theo on December 18, 2010, 04:17:52 PM
Yesterday I decided that it would be quite possible to convert my Imperial to counterbass, as long as I didn't mind rebuilding a reedblock, building a new soundboard and rebuilding around 30% of the mechanism from scratch. Perhaps a bit of an ask :P

I do genuinely think though that 32 stradella with counterbass is possible for an instrument the size of a Liliput.

It should not be necessary to rebuild reedblocks and soundboard in a 32 bass Imperial, you have all the reeds there already, its just the mechanism that would have to be changed.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on December 18, 2010, 06:13:19 PM
Yesterday I decided that it would be quite possible to convert my Imperial to counterbass, as long as I didn't mind rebuilding a reedblock, building a new soundboard and rebuilding around 30% of the mechanism from scratch. Perhaps a bit of an ask :P

I do genuinely think though that 32 stradella with counterbass is possible for an instrument the size of a Liliput.

It should not be necessary to rebuild reedblocks and soundboard in a 32 bass Imperial, you have all the reeds there already, its just the mechanism that would have to be changed.

Nope, I've got all 12 for the chords, but converting to counterbass requires an extra four bass reeds... The point is that at present it is bass/major/minor/dominant, which is little better than a melodeon bass, even if it were to be converted to F/F# instead of Eb/E. So it only has 8 bass reeds :( It does have 3 voice bass, i.e. low, tonic and high tonic, the high tonic being taken from the chord reeds. I thought about scrapping the middle reeds and putting bass reeds in there instead, rebuilding the reedblock to accommodate them, but 1) the chambers of the bass reeds would technically have to be altered because the airflow would be different b) it would involve rebuilding the mechanism anyway and c) the soundboard doesn't have 2 holes, it has two holes overlapping. So it would need a new soundboard as well!

To fit all the reeds in and keep the three voice bass I think that it would need another reedblock, there isn't quite room to extend the current one. This would be OK I think, but would require slight alterations to the main mechanism to accommodate the extra levers. I think that you could use the original axle and housing if you only added three reeds, but not 4 :( The housing  for the axle is a little complex, but could be made less complex. The rest of the housing you could reuse. I'm not sure how you would couple the counterbass levers to the bass pads, since they are on a simple lever system that is then coupled to the tonic, rather than on a separate horizontal axle system like the bigger stradella boxes. Shouldn't be too difficult though. In order not to impede anything else, the key rods for the counterbass would need a dogleg almost immediately and then led vertically down in the gaps between the bass rods. This would mean that the rod material would have to be very stiff, because there would be a couple acting on it. I would be worried about space for the extra rods and pallets between the soundboard and the axles, shimming the axles back would work but would require recutting all of the chord activating rod things (running out of terminology). This is a limited stradella and so things are done slightly differently from a big box. As it is, recutting the bass rod things would be a necessity.

Most parts could be built in department. The big problem with building new reedblocks is that you would then need to move the air button, probably trying a linked pad system, like the Preciosa. This would probably require a new soundboard, since the current air button hole is right in the middle of the new reedblock. There are a few minor cracks in the soundboard anyway. The soundboard is fitted on a ledge it looks like and then glued in. Making it would be a nuisance, as department is geared up for metalwork rather than wood. I could make a metal soundboard I suppose, my Casali has one. Not sure how you would best glue that in though. That would be the way to do it, because I could then get the water cutter to cut it accurately. Making the new reedblock would be a right pain, although I could take the dimensions from the other one.

Conclusion is that it would almost be worth starting again from scratch :P But a fun thought experiment.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on December 28, 2010, 12:50:41 AM
Quick update that I haven't done a lick of work since I got home, apart from some Engineering, which doesn't really count. However, I am resolved to finish the reed work for the Welty when I get back and start tuning it :o Wish me luck, I'm beginning to go through the old threads for a second time and make notes... I'm be interested to see how Telemorris gets on as well :P
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Telemorris on December 28, 2010, 01:08:16 AM
I am resolved to finish the reed work for the Welty when I get back and start tuning it :o Wish me luck, I'm beginning to go through the old threads for a second time and make notes... I'll be interested to see how Telemorris gets on as well :P

Yes! Good luck. I keep looking through the threads myself and finding advice hidden in unexpected places or threads. Keep us posted on your progress. I'm especially interested in what puzzles or problems you run into and how you resolve them, or what the forum wizards have to say. Keep going!
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Martyn on December 29, 2010, 11:50:43 AM
OK, three questions:


Thirdly is there an easy way of stripping old pallet leather off pallets? It's a horrible job and I'm worried that I'm not making the surface as flat as it should be.

By far the easiest method I have found for removing old pallet facing leather is to get a margarine tub lid or something similar, pour a tiny amount of methylated spirit into it. Then all you need to do is to stand the pallets in it for about 10 seconds, take them out and leave them to stand for about a minute.
The old leather can then be easily peeled off. It takes about 10 minutes in total to do a two row box.

It is a good idea to put the stripped pallets into the tub and give them a short blast with a hair dryer to make sure they are dry before fitting the new facings.

Martyn
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on December 29, 2010, 12:17:44 PM
That's a good tip, thanks Martyn (:) I'll see about getting some spirits for the next one. Not sure where I'm going to get a margarine tub though, it takes me 7 weeks to get through one :P
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Steve_freereeder on December 29, 2010, 01:35:09 PM
Not sure where I'm going to get a margarine tub though, it takes me 7 weeks to get through one :P
Buy the margarine anyway plus some nuts and seeds and then make some Blue Peter birdcake. You can use all the marge in one go then, as well as doing your bit for the local environment and wildlife.  (:)
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on December 29, 2010, 04:13:26 PM
Not sure where I'm going to get a margarine tub though, it takes me 7 weeks to get through one :P
Buy the margarine anyway plus some nuts and seeds and then make some Blue Peter birdcake. You can use all the marge in one go then, as well as doing your bit for the local environment and wildlife.  (:)

But I don't have a garden! :P Maybe I'll swipe a margarine pot from home if we use one up before I go.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: an bosca ceoil on December 29, 2010, 05:10:32 PM
Not sure where I'm going to get a margarine tub though, it takes me 7 weeks to get through one :P
Buy the margarine anyway plus some nuts and seeds and then make some Blue Peter birdcake. You can use all the marge in one go then, as well as doing your bit for the local environment and wildlife.  (:)

But I don't have a garden! :P Maybe I'll swipe a margarine pot from home if we use one up before I go.

Can you not understand the simplest of instructions? :D
They quite clearly state that you should use the lid from a margerine (sic) tub.
This can be reused to protect any unused margarine after thorough washing if no cling-film is available.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Graham Spencer on December 29, 2010, 05:15:57 PM
I'd be interested to know the specific properties that margarine (other non-dairy spreads are available!) brings to the equation; why is ANY shallow plastic container not suitable? Why can I not use the lid from a container of, for instance, olives? Is there a margarine cartel secretly directing melodeon repairs? I think we should be told...... ;D
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on December 29, 2010, 05:18:57 PM
Not sure where I'm going to get a margarine tub though, it takes me 7 weeks to get through one :P
Buy the margarine anyway plus some nuts and seeds and then make some Blue Peter birdcake. You can use all the marge in one go then, as well as doing your bit for the local environment and wildlife.  (:)

But I don't have a garden! :P Maybe I'll swipe a margarine pot from home if we use one up before I go.

Can you not understand the simplest of instructions? :D
They quite clearly state that you should use the lid from a margerine (sic) tub.
This can be reused to protect any unused margarine after thorough washing if no cling-film is available.

Oops... :|bl That would make more sense :P
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: malcolmbebb on December 29, 2010, 05:25:01 PM
Can you not understand the simplest of instructions? :D
They quite clearly state that you should use the lid from a margerine (sic) tub.
This can be reused to protect any unused margarine after thorough washing if no cling-film is available.
Although, thinking about it, you don't actually need to remove the lid in the first place. Just make sure you've made your lunchtime sandwich before you start your melodeon repairs.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on January 02, 2011, 12:51:09 AM
Thanks to a conversation with Steve today I now feel a lot happier about starting tuning (:) I generally feel unwilling to start something before I am organised and know what I am going to do and he has helped a lot with that.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on January 30, 2011, 01:48:20 AM
Well, I was aiming to start tuning by the end of the month... that hasn't happened. No particular reason, just me not getting round to doing much. However, I have now finally finished rewaxing and revalving the treble end of my Welty, so technically I can start right away! Except that I won't, there's a fair bit of prep to do first.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Telemorris on January 30, 2011, 07:07:13 PM
Ukebert,

I'm finding the process of tuning to be fairly straightforward. The first 10 to 15 reeds I worked on were slow going because I didn't have a feel for how much metal to take off to achieve the amount of pitch change I needed. As I've done more, I've become more confident and can now get to the correct pitch for a reed in about three tries. I've decided to switch to the Dedic tuning design and so all my reeds need to be lowered in pitch. I'm learning a lot about how to use the scratcher to get there. Once I get close to the pitch, say 2 - 3 cents sharp, I'll switch to 320 grit wet or dry sand paper for the final touchups. The 320 seems to be a good grit - not too aggressive and not too slow. 600 grit was too slow once I'd gotten confident.

Good luck with the tuning.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on February 24, 2011, 01:54:24 AM
An update: As those following my facebook feed will know, this term is going very badly for me and so box repair has taken a back seat due to lack of time. So all I've done is finish rewaxing and revalving the Welty.

I do now have a junk PA to practice taking metal off reeds, chickening out of going straight for the Welty. I'd like to get away with having more than half the reeds intact once I've finished with it. Hopefully messing around with the PA will give me a feel for it.

When I'll get round to doing it though I have no idea :( I seem to have no time, so little time that I spend most of it complaining about how little of it I have. Typical student unfortunately :P
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on September 07, 2011, 12:53:49 AM
Well, after a long hiatus, finally started tuning today!

Well, sort of. I was messing around with the junker PA that I have, bought off Ollie. The reeds are crap, it's poorly made, plays horrible and the bellows are shot, so I don't feel bad about purposefully ruining it.

Had a go at altering pitch of reeds (tuning is too strong at this time). Decided to see how much metal needed to be taken off to get different effects, started off with steadily raising the pitch of one reed from B to C. First tried the sanding pens that I have. The 320 I found a bit aggressive, the 400 was a bit more reassuring. But then I decided that it was very slow, so tried the file. This worked very well, but it was difficult to file evenly. I raised the reed up a semi-tone and noted a loss of timbre, a lot of the lower harmonics had disappeared. No real way to get them back, my guess is that taking metal off more of the reed would avoid that? Not sure. I was fairly localised to the tip. This is why I have a junker. Gauging the effect of tuning is easier when you are taking larger amounts of metal off.

Unfortunately I need a new scraper, or I need to make mine properly. I was using the tip of a needle file that I had ground down a bit on a stone. Probably not enough, it wasn't hard enough really. Made very little difference in pitch. I found that using the sanding pen was more effective, but took off a greater surface area of metal. Requires more experimentation. Also practised pinging up a reed on the other side and scraping it, which was fine. No room for a pen, so scraping is all I can do.

Didn't have much time, so didn't actually tune a reed dead on. My laptop ran out of battery and I needed to have some food before then. Also found that the tuner that I am using (Bill's) tends to fluctuate a lot when I excite the reed. It varies by as much as a cent, which is obviously not ideal. Might consider getting a commercial tuner from somewhere. Expense is the big issue there though :(

Conclusion is that it is quite difficult. Felt like I was blind, not knowing how much to take off. Appreciating the advantage of a tuning table rather than tuning bellows and wondering how I am going to do fine-tuning inside the instrument.

Considering having a frequency analysis program open alongside the tuner in order to quantify what my ears are telling me.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Telemorris on September 07, 2011, 01:06:15 AM
Don't be intimidated, just keep going. You do get the hang of it after awhile. Keep going on the PA and you haven't lost anything important. I've been using Dirk's Tuner and find it quite helpful. Theo uses a different tuner and tunes mostly by ear, especially when tuning the tremolo.

Did I send you a scratcher? If not, PM me and I'll send you one that works for me. I've found then fairly easy to make.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on September 07, 2011, 01:32:14 AM
PM sent ;D

Thinking of getting the Strobosoft. Dirk's tuner is too much, whereas the Strobosoft is only around £30. I could probably stretch to that. I don't think that I need the deluxe edition.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Telemorris on September 07, 2011, 05:11:35 AM
Now that I've retuned my Erica for the third time, I'm finding it much easier and I'm more accurate. Do your test tuning on the PA reeds but work on getting whatever reed you are working to be exactly the pitch it's designed for. I'm assuming you won't be repitching the Welty? If you are not repitching the Welty, you've only got very small changes to make to get it back into tune. I wouldn't worry about changing the pitch by a half or whole tone since it's not needed.

Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 07, 2011, 08:21:28 AM
Unfortunately I need a new scraper, or I need to make mine properly. I was using the tip of a needle file that I had ground down a bit on a stone. Probably not enough, it wasn't hard enough really.
I made mine from a ground-down needle file and it works very well.
Using an old oil-stone I first ground away all the file teeth for about 4 cm away from the tip continually rotating the file to keep it even and circular (it took ages). This process wears a groove in the stone, which is quite useful for subsequent re-sharpening of the file/scratcher. Then (using a different part of the stone) and holding the file at 90° to the stone surface, I ground the tip flat so that I ended up with a small flat circle on the tip about 0.5 mm dia. and with sharp edges.

When the scratcher is in use, you need to keep touching up the sharpness on the tip with the oil-stone.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Theo on September 07, 2011, 08:31:47 AM
PM sent ;D

Thinking of getting the Strobosoft. Dirk's tuner is too much, whereas the Strobosoft is only around £30. I could probably stretch to that. I don't think that I need the deluxe edition.

If you have access to an iphone or ipad the Peterson apps are excellent, and much cheaper than the full strobosoft.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Lester on September 07, 2011, 08:34:18 AM
Did I send you a scratcher? If not, PM me and I'll send you one that works for me. I've found then fairly easy to make.

Ed's scratchers are fabulous, I use nothing else  ;D
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on September 07, 2011, 02:03:08 PM
PM sent ;D

Thinking of getting the Strobosoft. Dirk's tuner is too much, whereas the Strobosoft is only around £30. I could probably stretch to that. I don't think that I need the deluxe edition.

If you have access to an iphone or ipad the Peterson apps are excellent, and much cheaper than the full strobosoft.

I don't, and unfortunately much as I would like an iPad, iPhone or iPod touch, the price saved would be less than zero when the price of the hardware is taken into account.

Does anyone know of a nice cheap but effective electronic tuner?

I am going to get one of Ed's scratchers. Thanks very much to him!
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Telemorris on September 07, 2011, 03:01:51 PM
Ed's scratchers are fabulous, I use nothing else  ;D

Glad to hear it's working for you Lester!
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Martyn on September 08, 2011, 10:46:13 AM
PM sent ;D

Thinking of getting the Strobosoft. Dirk's tuner is too much, whereas the Strobosoft is only around £30. I could probably stretch to that. I don't think that I need the deluxe edition.

If you have access to an iphone or ipad the Peterson apps are excellent, and much cheaper than the full strobosoft.



I don't, and unfortunately much as I would like an iPad, iPhone or iPod touch, the price saved would be less than zero when the price of the hardware is taken into account.

Does anyone know of a nice cheap but effective electronic tuner?

I am going to get one of Ed's scratchers. Thanks very much to him!


These tuners are really good for the money http://www.jhs.co.uk/seiko.html
I use one similar to the SAT 501 as a backup to my Korg. They are very accurate and also show how many cents sharp or flat you are.

Martyn
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Mike Averill on September 09, 2011, 07:39:18 PM
This http://code.google.com/p/ctuner/ from a melnet member Bill the Farmer is quite good for single reeds.
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Pete Dunk on September 10, 2011, 06:06:44 PM
I don't know how I managed to miss the whole of this thread the first time through! ukebert, I'm sorry mate, some of the questions were obviously aimed in my direction but the answers you got from others were at least as good as mine would have been.

I'd be trying out Bill the Farmer's tuner, not least because of the attractive price point!

You seem to have the scratcher thing sorted now but I put a 120mm long piece of 3mm round steel stock (would have used brass but there wasn't any to hand) into the chuck of a lathe. Popped a 1mm tungsten drill bit into a chuck in the tail stock and bored a hole about 12mm deep into the steel rod. I next put the 1 mm drill into a vice with the twist part projecting up, this I snapped off using a smart tap with a hammer. The resulting piece of tool steel (the plain shank of the drill) was then Araldited into the steel handle and ground roughly square on a grinder and then given the Theo treatment to get it nice and sharp.  :D
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Graham Spencer on September 13, 2011, 07:35:09 AM
I'd be trying out Bill the Farmer's tuner, not least because of the attractive price point!

I'll second that - I've just given it a try and I'm suitably impressed. Incredibly easy to install, set up and use, and I find it much more useful than the Seiko and Korg tuners I've been using. OK, it doesn't have the bells & whistles of Strobosoft, but I'm not likely to want to tune a box to Artistic Temperament or Wilberforce's Strangulated Myxomatosis Minor, or whatever.  Thanks Bill - fine job!

Graham
Title: Re: A series of holiday projects
Post by: Owen Woods on September 18, 2011, 11:15:15 PM
I don't know how I managed to miss the whole of this thread the first time through! ukebert, I'm sorry mate, some of the questions were obviously aimed in my direction but the answers you got from others were at least as good as mine would have been.

Don't worry, your thread (and is) was a constant source of information and inspiration! For me tuning is the big hurdle still to go.

@GPS It is Bill's tuner that I'm using. I just found that it fluctuates a lot, but perhaps that is just due to the reed itself and I need practice at sounding it consistently (I'm using tuning bellows rather than a table).
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal